Underrated (Horror List) - Metacritic Sucks!!
Movies with scores below 5.5 or similar that I like or with low ratings that I think are underrated or poorly treated by metacritic
List activity
31 views
• 0 this weekCreate a new list
List your movie, TV & celebrity picks.
122 titles
- DirectorJohn SimpsonStarsKatheryn WinnickLaura BreckenridgeJessica LucasThree women are stalked by a killer with a grudge that extends back to the girls' childhoods.
- DirectorDelaney BishopStarsAyla KellRiker LynchLisseth ChavezTerrorized at multiple stops on a road trip to Joshua Tree, three friends realize something unexpected is pulling the strings.
- DirectorHideo JôjôStarsKanata HosodaYumi KawaiMizuki KayashimaA man has an obsession that, if he is to die, it would be by being killed by a high school girl. With his strange obsession in mind, he decides to become a teacher.
- DirectorUmberto LenziStarsAndy J. ForestSonia PetrovnaSusanna MartinkováA man has dreams of a house and a witch, his girlfriend suggests a break and and head for her family home unbeknown to him the house is the same as in his dreams.
- DirectorHoward AvedisStarsMary Beth McDonoughDavid WysockiBill PaxtonConvinced that her father's death was not accidental, a beautiful girl decides to investigate to find out the truth, aided by her boyfriend. Her sleuthing draws her to a local mortuary, where many secrets will be revealed.
- DirectorTim MathesonStarsAlly SheedyStephen CaffreyTracey NeedhamInspired by what happened to Clint Goodman, the protagonist of the first film, an adulterous husband from Clint's small town plans to do the same things to his wife, Laura.
- DirectorYong-ki JeongStarsKim Bo-raKim Jae-hyunShin So-yulA public service worker at Oksu Station witnesses a shocking incident and recruits his friend to help uncover the truth behind the station's mysterious happenings.
- DirectorRichard CiupkaStarsJohn VernonSamantha EggarLinda ThorsonSix young actresses auditioning for a movie role at a remote mansion are targeted by a mysterious masked murderer.
- DirectorCybil RichardsStarsJacqueline LovellMatt ShueKurt SinclairA race of extraterrestrials has evolved to exist only as beams of light. Having no physical experience in their collective memory, they send Kara to Earth to experience as many sensations as possible.
- DirectorDean JonesStarsBruce DernBrian KrauseClifton PowellSamantha is kidnapped by a serial killer, locked in a cage, and forced to witness dozens of people being killed. After 10 days in captivity, the killer begins to fall in love with her until she is rescued by police.
- DirectorNicholaus GoossenStarsKatrina BowdenJeremy BastianCavan CunninghamTwo brothers come upon a rarely used shortcut in their new town.
- DirectorJohn ShibanStarsJaimie AlexanderMichael ChildersJennifer CormackThe film follows Nicole Carrow, a young woman who is threatened by a maniac serial killer, after her boyfriend Jess, is abducted in a rest stop.
- DirectorAdam GieraschStarsJessica LowndesRoss KohnRoss McCallA young woman tries to find her injured boyfriend in a bizarre and dangerous hospital.
- DirectorDave PayneStarsDevon GummersallDerek RichardsonTina IllmanStrangers trapped at an eerie travel oasis in the desert must unravel the mystery behind their visions of dying people while they are preyed upon by a decaying creature.
- DirectorDave PayneStarsMichael MuhneyStephen MartinesLew TempleA sheriff and his son chase casino robbers, only to find the all of them are being chased by something else.
- DirectorJoe GaytonStarsLance HenriksenClaire StansfieldJohn DiehlGovernment scientists attempt to reanimate a corpse they found in the desert, but end up inadvertently creating a monster.
- DirectorJohannes PerssonStarsMolly NutleySofia KappelVincent GrahlA group of social media experts are hired to help an old family business to thrive. But they soon find themselves stuck on a tiny island in a lake in which an ancient Swedish witch is said to live.
- DirectorIsaac RodriguezStarsAli AlkhafajiChristine BrownSarah FroelichIn 1999, two friends use a webcam for the first time and stumble across a mysterious browser game that may be haunted.
- DirectorK PontutiStarsAlexandra LorethJoe MullinsJeanne O'ConnorThe horror of a woman suffering from hysteria.
- DirectorTakashi ShimizuStarsKôkiRiku HagiwaraKeiko HoriuchiIn a so-called "spirit video", Kanon (Kôki) is astonished to see a high-school girl who looks exactly like her.
- DirectorBen JaggerStarsFrancesca XuerebViktoria VinyarskaEric WiegandTwo best friends and roommates are terrified by the vengeful spirits dwelling in their apartment. Based on the novel published by Kobunsha and written by Nanami Kamon.
- DirectorAnthony C. FerranteStarsTrish CorenRachel HarlandJilon VanOverThere are rumors that a long shut down and neglected hospital is haunted by the inhabitants that died there in a fire. Four college students are about to discover that the myths might just be true.
- DirectorAlex MerkinStarsJeni RossMark GhaniméHamza HaqWhen an escape room attraction turns from a fun bonding activity to a dangerous paranormal experience, a father and daughter must flee from an angry spirit.
- DirectorWill WernickStarsEvan WilliamsAnnabelle StephensonElisabeth HowerSix friends test their intelligence when an escape room they participate in takes a dark and twisted turn.
- DirectorFranck KhalfounStarsJennifer Jason LeighBella ThorneMckenna GraceA desperate single mother moves with her three children into the notorious, supposedly haunted, real-life Amityville house to try and use its dark powers to cure her comatose son. Things go horribly wrong.
- DirectorDaniel FarrandsStarsJohn RobinsonChelsea RickettsPaul Ben-VictorOn the night of November 13, 1974, Ronald DeFeo, Jr. took a high-powered rifle and murdered his entire family as they slept. At his trial, DeFeo claimed that "voices" in the house commanded him to kill. This is their story.
- DirectorSean CarterStarsBella ThorneChandler RiggsIoan GruffuddA family become imprisoned in their home by intruders who force them to play a life and death game where the mysterious rules become clear as the night unfolds.
- DirectorMichael McQuownVincent J. GuastiniStarsDavid BanksSara AreyanoCortney PalmA genre-defying mixture of horror, sci-fi, myth, mystery and thrills told as four interlocking tales in one intelligent anthology. Ghosts, spirits, creatures, demons and more from the paranormal world collide with rational curiosity.
- DirectorMathieu RattheStarsMathieu RattheVictor Andres Turgeon-TrellesKimberly LaferriereIn Gracefield, three couples are spending a long weekend in a luxurious cabin when suddenly an uninvited guest in the form of a meteorite, comes crashing the party...
- DirectorHowie AskinsStarsRyan McCoyBrett RosenbergAshley BrackenRyan makes a documentary on his friend, Brett, and his first time camping, until a mysterious figure in the woods starts hunting them.
- DirectorJustin BarberStarsFlorence HartiganLuke Spencer RobertsChelsea LopezTwo decades after three teenagers disappeared in the wake of mysterious lights appearing above Phoenix, Arizona, unseen footage from that night has been discovered, chronicling the final hours of their fateful expedition.
- DirectorLars KlevbergStarsKathryn PrescottTyler YoungSamantha LoganHigh school loner Bird Fitcher has no idea what dark secrets are tied to the Polaroid camera she finds. It doesn't take long to discover that those who have their picture taken with it, soon die.
- DirectorStewart SparkeStarsLyndsey CraineMichaela LongdenLizzie Aaryn-StantonSophie's 18th birthday becomes a bloodbath when monsters descend upon her house and start to devour the party guests. Sophie and her friends must rally together to send their party crashers back to hell.
- DirectorRob ZombieStarsSheri Moon ZombieMeg FosterBruce DavisonRadio DJ Heidi is sent a box containing a record--a "gift from the Lords". The sounds within the grooves trigger flashbacks of her town's violent past. Is Heidi going mad, or are the Lords back to take revenge on Salem, Massachusetts?
- DirectorDennis BartokStarsShauna MacdonaldSteve WallLeah McNamaraRecovering after a terrible accident, Dana struggles to regain her life and family when she encounters a malevolent ghost in her hospital room.
- DirectorTravis ZariwnyStarsSummer H. HowellKeenan LehmannMeredith RoseA girl and her friends find a game in the attic that summons a creature known as The Midnight Man, who uses their worst fears against them.
- DirectorMary LambertStarsEdward FurlongAnthony EdwardsClancy BrownA teenage boy and his father move to his recently-deceased mother's hometown, where they encounter the ancient Native American cemetery with the power to raise the dead.
- DirectorJim GillespieStarsAgnes BrucknerJonathan JacksonMeagan GoodA group of teenagers fear for their lives in the swamps of Louisiana, chased by Mr. Jangles, a man possessed by 13 evil souls, and now relentless in his pursuit of new victims.
- DirectorTobe HooperStarsAngela BettisBrent RoamMarco RodríguezA historic Hollywood hotel houses a supernatural evil. It's been subdued for decades, but when renovations start, a series of murders take place.
- DirectorDennis DonnellyStarsCameron MitchellPamelyn FerdinWesley EureA ski-masked maniac kills apartment complex tenants with the contents of a toolbox.
- DirectorDarren Lynn BousmanStarsJessica LowndesJoe AndersonLin ShayeAn investigative reporter teams up with a police officer to solve the mystery of why a seemingly good man murdered her sister's family.
- DirectorDarren Lynn BousmanStarsStephen MoyerMia KirshnerAllie MacDonaldA man takes his family on a camping trip and becomes convinced they are being stalked by the legendary monster of the New Jersey Pine Barrens: the Jersey Devil.
- DirectorJeff MaherStarsColin PriceAlysa KingGwenlyn CumynFour people find themselves stuck on a haunted antique bed where leaving means suffering a gruesome death. Plagued with frightening hallucinations, they must figure out the bed's secrets before they are ultimately picked off one by one.
- DirectorDarren Lynn BousmanStarsCarolyn HennesyHannah FiermanCourtney HalversonIn the 1950s in small-town Georgia, a pregnant young woman named Agatha seeks refuge in a convent.
- DirectorMarcus NispelStarsStephen LangKevin ChapmanKelly BlatzA group of teenagers accidentally release an evil spirit that starts to possess them one by one.
- DirectorKevin GreutertStarsIsla FisherAnson MountGillian JacobsAfter moving to a vineyard to start a new life with her husband, a pregnant woman begins to experience terrifying visions.
- DirectorKevin GreutertStarsDeborah Kara UngerBen SullivanChelsea RickettsSet in the 1980s, an estranged family hires a cult deprogrammer to take back their teenage son from a murderous cult, but find themselves under siege when the cultists surround their cabin, demanding the boy back.
- DirectorNick JongeriusStarsPatrick BaladiBen BattCharlotte BeaumontSeven tourists with troubled pasts find themselves trapped at a satanic mill in rural Holland. As they're attacked for their sins one by one, the night becomes a fight for survival.
- DirectorJonathan LiebesmanStarsChaney KleyEmma Caulfield FordAntony BurrowsA vengeful spirit has taken the form of the Tooth Fairy to exact vengeance on the town that lynched her 150 years earlier. Her only opposition is the only child, now grown up, who has survived her before.
- DirectorJaume Collet-SerraStarsChad Michael MurrayParis HiltonElisha CuthbertA group of teens are unwittingly stranded near a strange wax museum and soon must fight to survive and keep from becoming the next exhibit.
- DirectorTakashi ShimizuStarsYumi AdachiHideko HaraFûju KamioOne day a mysterious box arrived and a curse began to spread all over. The source of the box is 'Jukai Village'. The village is hidden in Jukai Forest, a suicide spot that once you enter it, you can never come out.
- DirectorKenta FukasakuStarsMisaki YonemuraHiroya MatsumotoRina SaitoSix classmates receive an e-mail from Asuka; who supposedly committed suicide. Later that night they all get together in a classroom and are surprised by a person wearing a bloody rat mask. The costumed Rat quickly begins attacking them while screaming; this is revenge for Asuka's death.
- DirectorScott ChambersStarsGeorgina JaneMichael OwusuAbi Casson ThompsonAfter being horrendously embarrassed by the mean girls at school, Faye, a practicing witch, summons the evil Cupid to take revenge on all those who wronged her.
- DirectorDave ParkerStarsSophie MonkTad HilgenbrinkWilliam SadlerA group of young horror fans go searching for a film that mysteriously vanished years ago but instead find that the demented killer from the movie is real, and he's thrilled to meet fans who will die gruesomely for his art.
- DirectorRobert HallStarsBobbi Sue LutherKevin GageLena HeadeyA young girl wakes up in a casket with a head injury and no memory of her identity. She quickly realizes she was abducted by a serial killer and she must fight to survive.
- DirectorPatrick LussierStarsJensen AcklesJaime KingKerr SmithTom returns to his hometown on the tenth anniversary of the Valentine's night massacre that claimed the lives of 22 people. Instead of a homecoming, Tom finds himself suspected of committing the murders, and it seems like his old flame is the only one that believes he's innocent.
- DirectorSteve BeckStarsJulianna MarguliesGabriel ByrneRon EldardA salvage crew discovers a long-lost 1962 passenger ship floating lifeless in a remote region of the Bering Sea, and soon notices that its long-dead inhabitants may still be on board.
- DirectorSteve BeckStarsTony ShalhoubShannon ElizabethEmbeth DavidtzWhen Cyrus Kriticos, a very rich collector of unique things, dies, he leaves his house, fortune, and his prized collection of ghosts.
- DirectorSean S. CunninghamJoe DanteJohn GaetaStarsJayce BartokHenry GibsonLara HarrisSeven strangers on a Hollywood movie studio tour are trapped inside an infamous House of Horror and forced to tell their most terrifying stories to get out alive.
- DirectorWilliam MaloneStarsStan IvarWendy SchaalLyman WardAfter a member of a geological research team who was sent to Saturn's largest moon: Titan crashes their spacecraft into a space station, another team is sent to Titan to investigate, not knowing the terror that awaits them.
- DirectorSidney J. FurieStarsBarbara HersheyRon SilverDavid LabiosaA woman is tormented by an invisible being.
- DirectorTobe HooperStarsSteve RailsbackMathilda MayPeter FirthA race of space vampires arrives in London and infects the populace, beginning an apocalyptic descent into chaos.
- DirectorChristian AlvartStarsDennis QuaidBen FosterCam GigandetTwo crew members of a spaceship wake up from hypersleep to discover that all their colleagues are missing. Despite this, it appears that they are not alone.
- DirectorAndy FetscherStarsNathalie KelleyNick EversmanKlaus StiglmeierWhen a group of urban explorers venture beneath Berlin, their guide hurts himself and the group must struggle to escape the subterranean maze beneath the city.
- DirectorGlen MorganStarsMichelle TrachtenbergMary Elizabeth WinsteadLacey ChabertOn Christmas Eve, an escaped maniac returns to his childhood home, which is now a sorority house, and begins to murder the sorority sisters one by one.
- DirectorJames WongStarsMary Elizabeth WinsteadRyan MerrimanKris LemcheWendy Christensen and a group of teens who escaped a fatal roller-coaster crash face a bloody date with Death.
- DirectorStephan ElliottStarsEwan McGregorAshley JuddPatrick BerginA private eye shadows a female serial killer of men all over the U.S. without her knowing as he, strangely enough, occasionally acts as her guardian angel.
- DirectorGrégory LevasseurStarsAshley HinshawJames BuckleyDenis O'HareAn archaeological team attempts to unlock the secrets of a lost pyramid only to find themselves hunted by an insidious creature.
- DirectorBrandon ChristensenStarsAlyson GorskeAngel PraterKio CyrThe Puppeteer, a convicted murderer on death row, has always maintained his innocence, claiming that it was an evil force that controlled his body as he slaughtered his victims.
- DirectorFranck KhalfounStarsJeremy ScippioJ. John BielerMonaia AbdelrahimA woman stops at a remote gas station in the middle of the night and becomes the target of a sociopathic sniper with a secret vendetta.
- DirectorEli RothStarsJordan LaddRider StrongJames DeBelloFive college graduates rent a cabin in the woods and begin to fall victim to a horrifying flesh-eating virus, which attracts the unwanted attention of the homicidal locals.
- DirectorNicolas GessnerStarsJodie FosterMartin SheenAlexis SmithA thirteen-year-old girl, who lives with her absentee father, befriends a disabled teenage amateur magician and invites him, gradually, into her tenuous struggle against a predatory local neighbor.
- DirectorAntonia BirdStarsGuy PearceRobert CarlyleDavid ArquetteIn a remote military outpost in the 19th century, Captain John Boyd and his regiment embark on a rescue mission which takes a dark turn when they are ambushed by a sadistic cannibal.
- DirectorLouis MorneauStarsNicki AycoxNick ZanoLaura JordanAfter their car breaks down in the desert, four friends try to find their way back to civilization while trying to escape Rusty Nail's bloody wrath.
- DirectorDeclan O'BrienStarsSean SkeneBlane CypurdaDan SkeneA group of college students gets lost in a storm during their snowmobiling trip and takes shelter in an abandoned sanitarium which, unbeknown to them, is home to deformed cannibals.
- DirectorValeri MilevStarsAnthony IlottChris JarvisAqueela ZollAn inheritance leads a young man and his friends to an abandoned resort inhabited by two sketchy caretakers and a clan of mutant cannibals.
- DirectorDerek Son Tae-woongStarsOn Joo-WanHan Ji-minOh Tae-kyungStrange things start happening after a group of med students dissect a cadaver.
- DirectorKo Seok-jinStarsHan Eun-jeongHyominLee Hyung-sukAfter his parents are murdered, Bin is taken into the care of relatives. He begins to act strangely, the new occupants of his house experience horrific nightmares, and a mystery unfolds as a terrible secret is revealed.
- DirectorTakashi ShimizuStarsDaigo NishihataMizuki YamamotoYûta HiraokaMysterious deaths befall on employees of a VR-tech company. There's an unprecedented fear waiting between reality and the virtual world.
- DirectorCraig SingerStarsPatrick O'KaneRichard BrakeMichale GravesIn the small town of Stone Cove, Maine, sheriff's deputy Dwayne Hopper is on the night-shift. He discovers Ronald Perkins in a holding cell. He's a local pharmacist and suspect in the disappearance of fourteen children over the past ten years, including Hopper's young son. Interrogating Perkins, Hopper learns that the mad pharmacist has built an army of brainwashed people. Investigating, Hopper and the police unwittingly unleash his followers on the small town and a night of terror begins as the super-strong, zombie-like warriors wreak havoc with only one thing on their minds: "Kill for Mr. Perkins."
- DirectorSim Deok-GeunStarsKim Kang-wooKim SohyeGoo Ga-EunIn a community center where a mass murder took place years earlier and it involves a paranormal investigator who discovers a door to another world.
- DirectorKerry BellessaStarsSummer BellessaChris HillJasen WadeWhen a group of friends decides to follow a car they've seen posted on an Amber Alert, things start to go very wrong.
- DirectorErik Kristopher MyersStarsRachel ArmigerReed DeLisleMatt LakeA filmmaker discovers a box of video tapes depicting two students' disturbing film project featuring a local horror legend, The Peeping Tom. As he sets out to prove this story is real and release it as a work of his own, he loses himself and the film crew following him into his project.
- DirectorAdam GreenStarsRay WiseAdam GreenWill BarrattA documentary exploring genre based monster art takes an odd turn when the filmmakers are contacted by a man who claims he can prove that monsters are indeed real.
- DirectorRenny HarlinStarsHolly GossMatt StokoeLuke AlbrightA group of students go to the location of the infamous Dyatlov pass incident to make a documentary, but things take a turn for the worse as the secret of what happened there is revealed.
- DirectorEduardo SánchezStarsSamuel DavisDora MadisonRoger EdwardsA group of friends who venture into the remote Texas woods for a party weekend find themselves stalked by Bigfoot.
- DirectorSteven DeGennaroStarsCarter RoyAlena von StroheimChris O'BrienA group of filmmakers set out to make the first 3D found footage horror movie, but find themselves in a found footage horror movie when the evil entity from their film escapes into their behind-the-scenes footage.
- DirectorColin KrawchukStarsMichael SheffieldLelia SymingtonDelaney WhiteA malevolent being known as The Jester terrorizes the inhabitants of a small town on Halloween night, including two estranged sisters who must come together to find a way to defeat this evil entity.
- DirectorScott BeckBryan WoodsStarsShelby YoungCarter JenkinsChloe BridgesFive friends play a game in a ''mysterious'' forest with a long history as a beacon for troubled young people contemplating suicide.
- DirectorOlatunde OsunsanmiStarsTorrey DeVittoCaitlin StaseyHarry LennixA detective hunts down a killer using video footage shot by the victims of a massacre at an abandoned gas station.
- DirectorAndrew DouglasStarsRyan ReynoldsMelissa GeorgeJimmy BennettNewlyweds are terrorized by demonic forces after moving into a large house that was the site of a grisly mass murder a year before.
- DirectorJai-hong JuhnJi-han KimStarsLee Chae-youngChoi Cheol-hoCheon Hee-jooOnline fashion model Hyo-jeong faces imminent threat of being unemployed because of the younger and more fashionable generation coming after her. While replying on surgical procedures and treatments, Hyo-jeong hears about a mysterious yoga class that helps make perfect body shape from her old high school classmate, Ga-yeong. Hyo-jeong eventually attends the yoga class with three classmates: Mi-yeon, a boxer who failed to keep her body fit, Ji-won, who has unstable mental condition, and Ye-na, a movie star who is morbidly obsessed with her appearance. Meanwhile, police start to investigate the enigma behind this yoga class after finding out that a murder in the neighborhood was committed by a woman named Bo-ra, a former yoga class student.
- DirectorMark HartleyStarsSharni VinsonRachel GriffithsCharles DanceAt a private clinic, a young nurse soon discovers that one of the comatose patients is quite sinister.
- DirectorWill CanonStarsDustin MilliganScott MechlowiczCody HornA police officer and a psychologist investigate the deaths of five people who were killed while trying to summon ghosts.
- DirectorNick CohenStarsAnna BrewsterGeoff BellDaniel CaltagironeA weekend boating party turns into a nightmare for a group of young Londoners when they stumble upon a terrifying secret hidden in the reeds.
- DirectorRichard RaaphorstStarsRobert GwilymHon Ping TangAlexander TerentyevIn the dying days of WWII, a battalion of Russian soldiers is lured into the secret lab of a deranged scientist and forced to face off against an army of horrific flesh-and-metal war machines.
- DirectorOlatunde OsunsanmiStarsMilla JovovichElias KoteasWill PattonA thriller involving an ongoing unsolved mystery in Alaska, where one town has seen an extraordinary number of unexplained disappearances during the past 40 years and there are accusations of a federal cover up.
- DirectorJohannes RobertsStarsDavid SchofieldEliza BennettRuth GemmellA group of teachers must defend themselves from a gang of murderous youths when their school comes under siege after hours.
- DirectorVictor SalvaStarsLuke KleintankAlex McKennaAnthony Rey PerezWhen Nick Di Santo learns that his father is not only alive but can possibly reveal the origin of his son's dark gift, he sets out on a trip that takes him to an abandoned mansion he thought only existed in his childhood imagination.
- DirectorMax KalmanowiczStarsMartin ShakarGil RogersGale GarnettA nuclear-plant leak turns a bus-load of children into murderous atomic zombies with black fingernails.