Pippa Passes; or, the Song of Conscience (1909) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
First New York Times Movie Review
springfieldrental8 February 2021
The New York Times has been known for years for its concise, informative movie reviews. The Times' first ever film review appeared on Oct. 10, 1909, with a piece on D. W. Griffith's "Pippa Passes," which was a cinematic interpretation of Robert Browning's 1841 poem.

Moviemakers back then assumed all their viewers were familiar with the literary works they brought onto the screen. The Film D'Art movement in France in 1908 introduced a movement of literary, drama and artistic works into cinema, using professional actors to convey these works. Biograph Studios, under Griffith's directorship, adopted aspects of the film d'art to the United States, eschewing the simple, mundane movies which were a staple of small nickelodeon theaters and producing these more sophisticate works.

In the New York Times review, its writer made note of the intelligence of "Pippa Passes." Speculation is that's the reason why such a high-brow newspaper as the Times would have one of its writers review a movie for the first time. "Pippa Passes," the movie, shows three segments, all illustrating the force of God influencing the turnaround of some bad people and their actions. The trouble with Griffith's film is that this appears before "dialogue title cards" which would clear up a lot confusion for the viewers. The middle segment especially could add some additional clarification to the viewer who is unfamiliar with Browning's poem. Pretty standard Griffith work with no new innovations that he would bring to cinema every so often.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
It is a beautiful picture in every sense
deickemeyer7 January 2015
This company has been more than ordinarily ambitious in its reproductions of famous stories and novels, but it has never undertaken anything which required the acting that is demanded by this picture. This was one of Browning's most subtle poems, dealing almost wholly with psychology and its manifestations in a direction not usually noted. It is scarcely necessary to repeat the story excepting to note that it explains the influence which one may exert upon others and still be wholly unconscious of that effect. In this instance the singing of Pippa, who goes out with her lute to sing merely because she feels happy, much as the birds do, yet her singing is wonderfully efficacious in preventing crime and evil purposes. The subtle influence of a pure personality, pouring forth a song which declares "God's in His heaven, all's right with the world" is marvelous and raises a train of thought which is scarcely explainable. The acting in the picture is superb. Perhaps it may be said with truth that it has to be, otherwise the film would have no strength. There must be acting, and that of the very highest character, or the picture will fail of its purpose. It is very questionable whether this picture is understood by a majority of the audiences who see it, or will see it, in the future. It is a very dramatic, yet subtle story, and Browning was a master of this sort of writing. Consequently, it is questionable from a certain standpoint. It is quite likely that a larger proportion of those who will see the picture have never read the poem and may not understand it for that reason. But the fact that many will not understand it does not detract from its excellent presentation and its value as an art subject. The company says that it considers the picture in many respects the best it has ever put out, and there is a strong disposition to agree with the producers. It is a beautiful picture in every sense and its technical quality is sufficiently good to make it more attractive. If one does not understand the story he can at least enjoy the pictorial qualities. These make it worth seeing, especially the novel effect of the breaking dawn and approach of night. - The Moving Picture World, October 16, 1909
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Unconscious genuineness
luigicavaliere17 February 2019
Pippa is a girl who can accompany herself with the guitar. He has the power with his music to balance difficult relationships between people. The song of consciousness, which brings people back to consciousness, comes from an unconscious genuineness of the girl.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Griffith 1909
Michael_Elliott26 February 2008
Pippa Passes (1909)

*** (out of 4)

D.W. Griffith film about a young woman who wakes up one morning singing a song about Jesus and soon realizes that it has the power to save souls and heal the sick. Griffith made countless religious films but this here really isn't one of the better ones. The film has a good, pure message but it's way too over-dramatic and Griffith beats the viewer over the head with his message of faith. For historic purposes, this was the first film to be reviewed by the New York Times.

Available on DVD through Grapevine as part of their D.W. Griffith: The Director series.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
D.W. Griffith and Robert Browning
Single-Black-Male30 October 2003
Although I am not a Browning fan (in fact the only poems I do like are by Homer, Tennyson and Phyllis Wheatley), I do feel that this short film is significant because it shows signs of Griffith developing as a director. Give him a piece of prose and he can bring alive on the screen.
0 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed