User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Lodging-house drudgery
Igenlode Wordsmith18 December 2008
Warning: Spoilers
This is a rather mediocre comedy starring Dave Willis (as "Dave") and Pat Kirkwood (as "Pat") -- clearly the two were expected to be familiar personalities in their own right to the audience of the time.

Dave is the worm that turns; having accidentally come into possession of a valuable item by mistake through his own ineptitude, he invests the reward money into becoming joint owner of the lodging-house in which he lives, is bullied into acting as unpaid dogsbody rather than proprietor, and then inspired to mount a bullying takeover of his own by a lady guest who flatters him into thinking he resembles Napoleon. Pat is the spunky little maid-of-all-work who earns her mistress' anger by fraternising with Dave when he is a poorly-paid lodger, and then by using her influence with him to wangle herself above-stairs when he takes over as owner. She performs various song and dance numbers competently in the course of the film. Frankly, I found myself a bit confused by the relationship between Dave and Pat, since we are more or less led to assume that they are going to pair up, but she then shows no resentment at the end of the film when he suddenly goes off with an older, richer woman...

Notable among the various guests at the lodging-house are Tommy Trinder and Max Wall as a couple of down-on-their-luck music hall artistes who are perpetually quarrelling. We see nothing of their actual act except some of Max Wall's characteristic sprawling agility; personally, I would rather have seen a little more of this pair and a little less of the lugubrious Dave (described by a contemporary as having "a distinctive comedy personality.... reminiscent of Chaplin in its mixture of wistfulness and whimsicality", but not one that appeals to me in its combination of put-upon stupidity, cheeky chappy act, and resentment).

The film ends, perhaps predictably, on a "let's put on a show!" note, as Dave and Pat stage a cabaret to draw guests into their grand re-opening. Dave performs a fairly amusing novelty song about Napoleon and Pat reprises her earlier kitchen-table song and dance to the title number, backed by a chorus of maids and footmen. They invite all their old guests to attend, thus explaining why the same characters turn up again(!) Personally, I'm afraid I would concur with the less charitable "Monthly Film Bulletin" reviewer who concluded in September 1938: "A sufficient plot and good photography are not enough to support this limp and patchy picture." The dialogue is sometimes mildly funny but never rises to any great heights; the musical numbers are competent but unmemorable, the slapstick rather tedious, and on the whole the film is an inoffensive but dull one, not worth seeking out.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Fascinatingly bad
federovsky30 May 2014
Bizarre early British comedy starring the utterly forgotten Dave Willis - it's impossible to find a picture of him - one of those prewar characters they really don't make any more, even in Scotland. He's half-way between Chaplin's little tramp and George Formby - the theme being the little man asserting himself - a niche later filled by Norman Wisdom, but Willis is man of such dubious charisma and talent that it's a wonder he ever made it onto the music hall stage, never mind the big screen. He's so awful he might be adorable were it not for the Hitler 'tache and whiny Scottish voice which send you either recoiling from the screen or peering closely in disbelief.

It's a boarding house farce, unimproved by the surprisingly dire Tommy Trinder and Max Wall as a resident double act (though to be fair, they're supposed to be dire), but redeemed somewhat by the surprisingly good Pat Kirkwood, who is like a homely Merle Oberon and can sing to boot. Not a good film, but for comedy historians, fairly priceless.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
But Invest In A Thesaurus ...
writers_reign3 August 2009
Warning: Spoilers
... you're going to need one to look up ALL the synonyms for 'dire'. This garbage makes Climbing High look like Citizen Kane and I can think of absolutely nothing positive to say about it. It was shown as part of a Tommy Trinder season at the NFT but in the brochure the individual film was sold as a chance to see Max Wall. The attractions of Trinder are dubious at best but Wall is another matter; alas, neither are given very much to do and what they do have is humourless. The actual lead is played by Dave Willis, now completely forgotten - and deservedly so if this is a typical example of his talent - but apparently a big name in the thirties, especially in Scotland. I won't embarrass either the writers or director by naming them, for which, I'm sure, any surviving relatives will thank me, indeed, I can only register surprise that they had the courage to include their names in the credits.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
It's a good thing that the audience is smiling because the audience isn't
mark.waltz23 August 2020
Warning: Spoilers
The odd look of British comic Dave Willis, trying to hide his Stewie Griffin like head with a Chaplin/Hitler like mustache is very difficult to get past while watching this extremely dated British musical comedy. He's supposed to be a variation of the down on his luck cheery old chap who gets himself into one predicament after another, and it's by accident that he makes a bundle selling something for more than he paid for it in an auction he was manipulated to bid on.

Having been unable to pay his rent, he is now in a position to buy shares into the boarding house he lives in and is mistreated by the co-owner until he stands up to her and refuses to be her kicking post anymore. With the help of kitchen maid Pat Kirkland, a musical comedy star of the British stage, Willis attempts to put on a show which results in the participation of Tommy Trinder and Max Wall and several obstacles which threatened to prevent the show from going on.

A few innocuous but pleasant musical numbers help boost this up a little, but the attempts at humor in this fail miserably. The characters in the boarding house are a plethora of stereotypical personalities from the nearly deaf old lady to the pranksterous twelve year old who keeps knocking Willis down when she slides down the banister, and for the most part, they are very unpleasant. Willis's attempt at playing Napoleon is embarrassingly bad, a 30's version of Anthony Newley without the satisfaction of a decent singing voice. Even at 75 minutes, just seems interminably long. Any attempts at sunshine in this musical is blinded by a solar eclipse of the soul.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed