Navajo (1952) Poster

(1952)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Very Unusual for the Time and Even Now
nafps20 February 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Natives playing Natives actually wasn't that unusual. There are examples going back to the 1910s, with Lilian St. Cyr. Jay Silverheels also portrayed Tonto on the Lone Ranger show on TV at the same time as this film.

What is unusual is a Hollywood film about Natives that takes place after 1900. This is to my knowledge is the only American film ever made about Indian boarding schools. In Canada there are at least half a dozen very well done films on the subject.

This film follows a Navajo boy fleeing the boarding schools. He is caught, forced to attend, given a white name, his hair cut off, must wear western clothing, and is forced to become culturally white in every way. He runs away and almost escapes, but decides to rescue two men pursuing him who are trapped on a mountain. The film is worth seeing for the landscapes alone.

There are some parts of true history left out, and it would be even more surprising had they been included. There was a high death rate from disease and suicides. Not just physical punishment but abuse was common, beatings, even chaining students to desks. Sexual abuse was also common. But society hadn't acknowledged such abuse of anyone yet, and wouldn't until the 1970s at least.

The narration of the boy becomes cumbersome at points. But the film and actors deserve praise for being groundbreaking in so many ways. Worth viewing for anyone interested in the history or subject.
20 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Story of life on an Indian reservation in the Southwest.
bux22 October 1998
Unusual tale of an Indian boy that rejects the white man's schooling on a Navajo reservation. Most of the actors are real Navajos. Cinematogropher Virgil Miller won accolades for his work on this one.
11 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Nominated For Two Oscars
boblipton27 March 2024
Francis Kee Teller's father has gone off and is now living with a White women. When his mother and grandfather die, young Teller goes in search of people to help burn them, in the manner of his people. But he is taken to the school run by the White people for children on the reservation.

This was nominated for two Academy Awards, probably a first for a Lippert release. Virgil Miller's black-and-white camerawork well deserves the nomination, with its stark and beautiful images of the Navajo Nation in Arizona and his portrait shots. It was also nominated for Best Documentary feature, and here I have my doubts. It is a story documentary, like Nanook of the North, and that sort of documentary was being replaced by a different form, more anthropological in nature. There's a good helping of that here in writer-director Norman Foster's feature. Still, the images and the glimpses in Navajo mythology is definitely worth your while.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed