The Desperado (1954) Poster

(1954)

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Better-than-average Allied Artists western
JohnHowardReid8 April 2018
Warning: Spoilers
A Silvermine Production, released through Allied Artists Pictures Corp. Copyright 20 June 1954 by Allied Artists Pictures Corp. No New York opening. U.S. release: 20 June 1954. U.K. release through Associated British-Pathe: 23 April 1954. No Australian theatrical release. 7,210 feet. 80 minutes.

SYNOPSIS: Fleeing from the State Police under the corrupt administration of the 1870s, a young Texan is befriended by gunman Sam Garrett. COMMENT: Wayne Morris was the last of the "B" western heroes and The Desperado is the second last of the "B" western series. It's a shame it's not the official last as it's a much superior a film to Two Guns and a Badge. With The Desperado the series "B" western would have gone out in really grand style. Blessed with an intriguing script by none other than Daniel Mainwaring, The Desperado is probably the best-written "B" western ever made. Gone are all the usual "B" stereotypes of plot, setting and characterization. Instead we are presented with a fascinating and unusually complex story, involving real, believable people.

Director Thomas Carr has risen to the occasion nobly, drawing ingratiating performances and character studies from unlikely players like Wayne Morris, Jimmy Lydon, Rayford Barnes and even Dabbs Greer. One of our favorite heavies Lee Van Cleef has a major dual role, while Nestor Paiva is unusually effective in a deep-dyed villainous role with absolutely no comic undertones whatever. John Dierkes also makes a wonderfully sadistic bully-boy, but Roy Barcroft fans will be disappointed to find him in a minor sympathetic role as a too law-abiding ex-sheriff.

Production values are better than the usual Silvermine level. There are plenty of scene changes, extras, a fair amount of action, and some reasonably effective locations. Technical credits including staging, lighting and music scoring are also impressive by Monogram's usual standards.

Oddly, The Desperado is not listed in Mainwaring's credits as published in Backstory 2: Interviews with Screenwriters of the 1940s and 1950s edited by Pat McGilligan (University of California Press, 1991). Whilst certainly a lesser effort than classics like Out of the Past, The Lawless and Invasion of the Body Snatchers, it is most definitely worthy of inclusion.

OTHER VIEWS: This better-than-average Allied Artists western moves at a good clip, boasts an interesting cast and will please most action fans. Although it starts off with the usual time-wasting rolling Foreword title (underlined by Kraushaar's customarily plodding score), production values are pretty fair, while Carr's direction is slightly more imaginative than his usual norm.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Sometimes You Know Too Much
boblipton9 June 2020
Jimmy Lydon burns the last of his image as Henry Aldrich. He's the son of an ex-sheriff who gets in trouble with the Reconstructionist government in Texas and makes a run for it. He hooks up with gunslinger Wayne Morris, who takes him under his wing and makes Jimmy a deadly man with a gun with a couple of tips about how to wear his gun belt.

Morris is surprisingly good, as is Lee Van Cleef in a small role. Maybe it's a good movie in its main body, even thought Morris' character seems very odd for the steely and disconnected killer he is supposed to be. Maybe it's the opening, with a bunch of titles about how this was darkest period in Texas history; after all, Black people had the franchise.

Sometimes you know too much history to shrug your shoulders and go with the legend.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
bad filmmaking
SnoopyStyle10 June 2020
"There is one dark and grim page in Texas history; it concerns the three years 1870 to 1873, during which Texans suffered and smouldered under the carpetbag administration of Governor E. J. Davis. Texas law was administered and enforced by a despotic organization called the Texas State police -- known as the "Bluebellies". Constitutional rights were ignored -- such as the right to keep and bear arms, the right to have public meetings, private property rights and most of the other expressions of human dignity and freedom of which Texas has always been so rightfully proud. Naturally, they did something about it..."

It's not the right way to gain sympathy. From the start, the Bluebellies have barely done anything and the rebels are already throwing dynamite at them. This is definitely a movie for the Confederate flag crowd. Even so, it does not understand how to gain the rooting interest. They have to suffer from true tyranny first before they can fight back. If the rebels throw the first punch, then the rooting interest is lost. This movie assumes the audience's sympathies right from the opening text. It is possible to go darker if they are simple criminals fighting the cops but this movie is saying something else.

Eventually, we do get to the police beatings but it looks fake. Honestly, one of the slaps missed entirely even as an acting fight. Then they escape in the least difficult way possible. I'm willing to judge this without accuracy or subject matter concerns. I'm not willing to ignore bad filmmaking. It's bad melodrama. The acting is average to bad broad work. The leads are never that appealing. At best, it's a workable B-movie. As for title, shouldn't it be plural? This is probably a cult classic for right thinking Americans.
2 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Claims to be historical, but reaks of fiction.
mark.waltz14 March 2022
Warning: Spoilers
The opening titled narration indicates that this is based on a true story of the Texas government between 1870 and 1873 during the restoration era, but all of the characters are obviously written for the story which isn't all that interesting. Wayne Morris leaves the cast and is supported by Jimmy Lyndon, best known for playing Henry Aldrich and Beverly Garland, best known for fighting monsters and raising a new husband's three sons. The story deals with two law abiding citizens of Texas who turn against the government and become outlaws because of the corruption. Lyndon loses girlfriend Garland because of this when he goes on the run, with Lyndon eventually wanted for murder.

It's obvious that the story surrounding the truth of the corruption of the Texas government was only utilized as a basis for the story so you're not really getting anything historical at all. It's your standard outlaws on the run western, around town for Cameron and it really isn't all that interesting. Lee Van Cleef and Dabbs Greer (from "Little House on the Prairie") are a few familiar faces in the supporting cast, and they are more interesting than the two leads. Garland is always a welcome presence, and she gets to do more than the normal average western movie heroine. This one's quite generic as far as low-budget westerns go, a major disappointment because with the historical background, it could have been so much more interesting and educational rather than just ordinary.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Blue Bellies Go Home!
hitchcockthelegend16 August 2015
The Desperado is directed by Thomas Carr and adapted to screenplay by Geoffrey Holmes from the novel written by Clifton Adams. It stars Wayne Morris, Jimmy Lydon, Beverly Garland, Rayford Barnes, Dabbs Greer and Lee Van Cleef. Music is by Raoul Kraushaar and cinematography by Joseph Novak.

"There is one dark and grim page in Texas history; it concerns the three years 1870 to 1873, during which Texans suffered and smouldered under the carpetbag administration of Governor E.J. Davis. Texas law was administered and enforced by a despotic organisation called the Texas State police - - known as the "Bluebellies." Constitutional rights were ignored - - such as the right to keep and bear arms, the right to have public meetings, private property rights and most of the other expressions of human dignity and freedom of which Texas has always been so rightfully proud. Naturally they did something about it..."

For the whole of its 80 minutes running time, The Desperado crams as much in as it possibly can, producing a mightily strong Western in the process. Stripping it down to the core the story is about a good man forced to turn bad, who does bad things in the name of correcting the wrongs done to him. He's forced to go on the run with a man he can't stand, leaving the woman he loves behind. Hooking up with a famed outlaw, he learns how to become a killer, but always the screenplay has us completely on his side, all while the finer details back in his home town build the other half of the story.

A man does his own killing.

His time on the run sees a friendship formed, with camp fire bondings prominent, while his backbone is continually tested by certain encounters. The narrative twists and turns to build a compelling case, the odds are firmly stacked against him as a dastardly acquaintance with an ulterior motive moves and shakes to ruin his life. The backdrop is one of bully boy law enforcement and big political change, of a place full of weasels, cowards, liars and idiots, marking this out as a film very dark in nature.

Don't put faith in anybody but yourself.

Violence and action is never far away either, as director Carr keeps things lively, and Novak's black and white photography is sparkling (TCM hold a lovely print). The acting is hardly grade "A" stuff, but the principal players turn in very effective shows. Morris owns the film as the wise and weary outlaw Sam Garrett, a role you can tell he is very much enjoying playing, while the beautiful Garland works really hard to make her love interest character more than a token offering - and she succeeds. Bonus for Oater fans is Van Cleef popping in for some dramatic impact, where he plays twins! Wonderful.

This is very much an under seen film, and personally I'm a little proud to be able to put out on the internet what appears to be the first non professional review. It's different to the usual Wayne Morris fare and I'm convinced that Western lovers who like some dark tints in their films would heartily enjoy this one. See it if you get chance! 8/10
16 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Mainly for American western buffs
searchanddestroy-112 March 2023
As a French moviegoer, even if I have heard of the Civil War in USA, Quantrill, Jesse James, William - Billy the the Kid - Bonney, Calamity Jane and many other legends of the West, I had never heard of those Bluebellies in Texas corrupted administration. So this is rather complex for me to fully understand the context of this story. But it remains watchable, agreeable, thanks mainly to Wayne Morris. It is of course predictable ten miles in advance but it remains better than the previous Thomas Carr's B westerns, made in the early fifties. With this one, Thomas Carr improved his filmography, showed a bit more ambition, and it will continue after this one; for instance several westerns starring Joel Mc Crea and some famous western figures.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
The corrupt Texas Police
bkoganbing9 June 2020
Wayne Morris is an outlaw and Jimmy Lydon is an outlaw in training so to speak and each can be considered a Desperado. Both are fleeing from carpetbagger justice in Texas and its infamous and corrupt Texas State Police.

That was then and the corruption of the Police was an article of faith in Texas history then. Actually the biggest sin of the Police in real life was that they let black people in the ranks.

But they o with the end of Reconstruction and Lydon goes on trial for a pair of murders e didn't commit.

Average western with a discredited point of view.
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Not Very Good
sxct9 January 2023
I have never watched a movie that seems to have been written by a 12 year-old for a school play. Writing and acting (?) have set a new low. It's too bad though because it could have been better even though the cast was a bit better than "B" level.

Wayne Morris has made some decent films as has Lee Van Cleef. I wasn't expecting High Noon quality but I was expecting at least mid-morning. But I guess I need to lower my expectations when I turn on this type of film. Nevertheless, I live with these types films as I do get some humor out of them. After reading this revue. I hope I haven't rated it too high.
0 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed