Who Killed Teddy Bear (1965) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
33 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Mineo heads odd but savvy cast in New York story that's a genuine creepshow
bmacv13 September 2002
Every now and again, a movie washes up on the fringes of the industry that's unlike anything else of its time – or any time. Who Killed Teddy Bear (no question mark) certainly qualifies; rarely discussed or even mentioned, it's not quite forgotten, either – it's hard to forget.

By 1965, the barriers were starting to be breached in what could be shown, or even implied, on the screen (Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf dates from that year). But Who Killed Teddy Bear rubs, brusquely and suggestively, against just about every taboo obtaining then or now. It's a New York story, but of the grotty 1960s, when Manhattan led the nation as an example of how American cities were surrendering to crime and vice and ugliness at the core.

Spinning platters in a seedy discotheque, Juliet Prowse starts getting obscene phone calls then finds a decapitated teddy bear in her apartment. Police detective Jan Murray takes the case, which holds an obsessive interest for him. Four years earlier his wife had been raped and murdered; now the world of perversion and fetishism has become his life, both professionally and privately (despite a young daughter, who listens to him listening to his lurid tapes from her bedroom). Prowse becomes so shaken by the stalking that she can't quite trust him, or for that matter her tough-as-nails boss Elaine Stritch, who, invited home to serve as protection, makes a pass at her. Shown the door, Stritch, in a slip and fur coat, wanders the dark streets and back alleys, where....

Top billing goes to Sal Mineo, 10 years after his debut as Plato in Rebel Without A Cause, as a waiter in the club. Back home he has a child-like grown sister, whom he locks in the closet when he's making the rounds of the porn shops and peep shows near Times Square. Though his character isn't gay, he's served up like prime, pre-Stonewall beefcake, halfway between raw and blue; towards the end, when Prowse teaches him to dance, he erupts like a go-go boy.

The movie bears all the marks of a starvation budget, but for once the saturated photography and jumpy cutting seem just right. The odd but savvy cast – even the young Daniel J. `Travanty' makes his debut as a deaf-mute bouncer – brings from Broadway and east-coast television a rough edge that's far from Hollywood's buffed and smooth product. But it's the vision of the TV-reared director, Joseph Cates, and writers Arnold Drake and Leon Tokatyan that makes Who Killed Teddy Bear so hard to shake. Neither a tidy thriller nor a nuanced character study, it nonetheless has a trump card to play: It's the real McCoy,a genuine creepshow.
40 out of 46 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
This is an important Movie !!
olddiscs29 July 2005
I couldn't believe how this unrecognized unheralded film of the mid 1960s captured the sleaziness & the downfall of NYC during that time The photography is amazing.. the score capturers the early disco era... Sal Mineo is unbelievably sensuous, erotic, neurotic, as is Elaine Stritch who plays the Lesbian, Marian wonderful performances.. Juliet Prowse is good in this role..Plot is a bit confusing.. and why did they cast Jan Murray (great TV comic game show host of that era) in this role? Ill never know.... But as I stated before, this film captures the sleazy, unclean, dark, cold snowy sado masochistic, days of NYC in the mid 1960s when that city was on the decline.. Broadway might have been booming, Babs was on B'WAY live in Funny Girl, The Merm was still around. ETC .but the side streets, the crime, the sex shops were running abound..this film captures it all..worth seeing and or buying if it becomes .. available, Bravo ,Sal Mineo. Elaine Stritch, and the director...
35 out of 40 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Sal dances!
bakerjp22 July 2001
Very much ahead of its time - this cult film vanished almost without trace after it was released, and it's very hard to find copies of it nowadays. So I consider myself fortunate to have been exposed to this sleaze-ball of a movie.

The highlight for me was in one of the final scenes where Sal Mineo and Juliet Prowse shimmy to one of the sassiest, silliest 60s dance tunes ever invented. Sal's wearing a little cut-off shirt and as he freaks out, more and more of his midriff is exposed. Sal's a long way from Rebel Without A Cause here, and looking all the better for it. This scene is worth the entrance fee alone. The title sequence is also hilariously evocative.

Full of weird characters, almost EVERYONE in this movie has a dirty little dark side waiting to be shown.
21 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
New York but not Hollywood New York
grunsel16 May 2006
When you think of movies about New York from this period in time, what comes to mind to me as a foreigner is a woodwind instrument blowing in the background while Jack Lemmon (or a lookalike) in a shiny suit neurotically babbles away something insignificant. Who killed Teddy Bear comes along and sticks its fingers up at the Hollywood system and is a break thru movie in every sense. This flawed, creaky, creepy and cranky movie is a delight. Not forgetting that you are led into the wonderful atmosphere by the wailing and unforgettable theme tune, which sounds like an old 45rpm record where the center hole has not been cut quite right.

IMHO due to Hollywood, American Independent film makers were just not taken seriously enough at this time, because of this, films like this have been unfairly over looked as great examples of low budget, gorilla technique( getting the shot before the police arrives etc). Taxi Driver was classic, but you know it was meticulously planned, every location permission was got and sums agreed, shots were retaken until they got it right. Well Who Killed Teddy Bear is wild and untamed and surely a minor classic?
22 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Scorsese must have seen this
christopher-underwood14 July 2009
Uneven, not very well paced and with some poor elements, this low budget piece of sleaze is still a good example of what can be done with a good idea, some decent actors and some balls. Great location shooting around Times Square/42nd Street clashes somewhat with some very flat interior sequences but all the electrifying disco scenes are excellent. Prowse really can dance and if Sal Mineo thinks he's auditioning all over again for Rebel Without A Cause, who can blame him with that physique. Lots of tasteless matters are gleefully paraded before us and even within the movie the lieutenant takes his dirty phone call research home never minding that his daughter is listening in. As others have mentioned, Scorsese must have seen this and in any event this would make a great double bill with Taxi Driver, also one would have to say that this is more sleazy and less glamorised than the more well known film. On a final note, how times change; completely rejected by the UK censors in 1965 is now released with 15 certificate.
13 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
It Could Have Been Me
wes-connors12 August 2008
Warning: Spoilers
The story of an obscene phone caller, herein given the technical term: "The Telephone Psychotic"; who, it is suggested, follows the natural course taken by these individuals, and becomes a homicidal killer. That does seem like a stretch, but the content of the calls certainly points in that direction. And, some of the discourse rings true. The (believable) fact that the obscene caller probably knows his victim makes it a more frightening. There are a lot of problems with the story; mainly, it really isn't about an obscene "Telephone Psychotic" caller; rather, it is about a stalker who uses to phone.

Sal Mineo (as Lawrence "Larry" Sherman) creates an interesting character; but, his considerable abilities as an actor do not equate with the inferior material. Mr. Mineo is, of course, the stalker. The film's structure seems to "tease" a little about the stalker's identity; but, it is fairly obvious from the opening credits. Could the very fit young man, clad in tight briefs, possibly be co-star Jan Murray (as Dave Madden)? Mineo's well-defined body is displayed very prominently throughout the film. And, he is photographed in a manner usually reserved, relatively speaking, for attractive female performers.

The climax for Mineo watchers will be the pool scene occurring after his gym workout. Be sure to look for uncut prints, because the scene is trimmed in cut versions. Not to be left out, beautiful Juliet Prowse (the object of his affection) has a couple of sexy underwear scenes of her own; but, they are not as lovingly shot as Mineo's. After the camera admires Mineo's body, so does Ms. Prowse; and, she tells him, point-blank, that he has a great body. The two of them, although they are supposed to be in cinematic opposition (stalker/victim) are great together. Whether flirting, dancing, or struggling, they display great synergy.

Elaine Stritch (as Marian Freeman) is another in the cast who deserved a better production. Ms. Stritch has been quoted as explaining, "I was a lesbian owner of a disco who fell in love with Juliet Prowse and got strangled on 93rd Street and East End Avenue with a silk stocking by Sal Mineo. Now who's not going to play to play that part?" Stritch gets to tell Prowse, "I dig soft things," and makes a small pass at the young woman (her employee, by the way). Prowse's character overreacts, which leads directly to Stritch's death.

Also disturbing (probably intentionally) is officer Murray's 10-year-old daughter listening in on her father's sex tapes. When she sees Prowse, she asks her dad, "Is she a hooker?" This parallels a situation in Mineo's home. In fact, Mineo, Murray, and Stritch's characters are related to each other in symbolic ways; and, they all desire Prowse (who desires Mineo). At least, the story is an interesting failure. The New York City locations are great; the movie brought Michael Chapman to filmdom. The dancing of Sal Mineo and high-heeled Juliet Prowse during the "It Could Have Been Me" song is a swimming classic (or, should have been).

******* Who Killed Teddy Bear (9/65) Joseph Cates ~ Sal Mineo, Juliet Prowse, Elaine Stritch, Jan Murray
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A Masterpiece of Sleaze!
scorpio-x16 July 2001
This film is truly a work of art of the highest magnitude and no, I am not kidding. Shot in glorious, high-contrast black-and-white, it reeks of exploitation from the note of the cheesy theme song all the way through the strobe-cut ending and every horn-blaring, high-heeling, hip-grinding moment in between. Sal Mineo plays a busboy obsessed with aspiring actress/club DJ Juliet Prowse (and Prowse is at her foxiest in this one, with her pencil skirts, kitten heels and cat eyes), coming off like a perverted puppy dog.

The obscene phone call bits--all heavy breathing, bulging tighty whiteys and sweat--will make you want to leave the theatre and take a shower. Or, if that isn't nasty enough for you, how about the scene with bulldyke Elaine Stritch fondling Prowse's fur (so to speak), or the retarded kid sister locked in the closet or the policeman obsessively playing audio tapes of various twisted criminal's confessions as his daughter listens wide-eyed from the other side of the door? Or how about the "twist lesson" that brings the film to it's climax (no pun intended)? Another asset of this great piece of cinema are its New York City location shots, especially when Mineo goes walking the city at night, looking for filth in scenes that must've influenced "Taxi Driver" (also love the W.S. Burroughs titles in the window of the "dirty bookshop"). I cannot recommend this movie highly enough. It's not available on video (Curses!), so if it's ever screened at the theater or on TV in your area, be there.
39 out of 42 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Phone Call from a Stranger
sol-19 May 2017
Harassed by an obscene phone caller, a young woman begins to wonder if the detective assigned to her case is behind the calls in this strange little mystery thriller starring Juliet Prowse. The film is incredibly well photographed in stark black and white by Joseph C. Brun (of 'Edge of the City' and 'Odds Against Tomorrow' fame) with awesome shots that initially obscure the phone caller's face, dizzy point-of-view shots as he later wanders the streets alone and some excellent tracking shots that walk along with Prowse. The supporting characters are refreshingly different too from those of the typical noir thriller, from Jan Murray's policeman, unhealthily obsessed with perverts, to Elaine Stritch in a terrific turn as Prowse's lesbian boss with designs on her, to Margot Bennett as a brain injured teenager. And then, of course, there is Sal Mineo, whose top billed supporting role is best left undisclosed until one has seen the film (it is really quite an experience). Tension nevertheless fades in and out throughout (an upbeat zoo scene in particular drags on too long) and the ending feels rather protracted, not to mention a little over-the-top, but this remains a surefire interesting motion picture beyond the mysterious title whose meaning eventually becomes clear. It is an aptly offbeat title too considering how daringly different the whole project feels.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
"....Doesn't anybody care?"
squill25 January 2000
The apex of 60s exploitation pix, with Sal Mineo, painted into over-exposing pants, as a proto-Travis Bickle: a pornophilic, body-building Times Square (filmed in its seedy heyday!) habitué fixated on disco dj/dancer Juliet Prowse. A smorgasbord of Hollywood taboos, including masturbation, incest, child abuse, transvestism, and lesbianism. Unbelievably wonderful!
34 out of 37 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Swinging but going nowhere...
JasparLamarCrabb2 March 2009
Warning: Spoilers
It's lurid and gritty to the point of exhaustion...unfortunately WHO KILLED TEDDY BEAR isn't a very good movie. Sal Mineo, wearing tight pants, a tight shirt and a tight jacket, is a busboy obsessed with record spinner Juliet Prowse. He makes dirty phone calls to her and follows her around NYC. Prowse suspects cop Jan Murray of being the perp and her lesbian boss Elaine Stritch thinks she's just plain crazy. Certainly way ahead of its time, but nevertheless oddly unsatisfying. The direction by Joseph Cates is mightily uneven and the occasional pyrotechnics (swirling cameras, strobe effects) don't go very far. The acting is a real odd mix, with Mineo giving a fine performance and Stritch and Murray offering solid support. Prowse, a dancer with a seemingly unending overbite, is somewhat bland. There's a lot of swinging music on the soundtrack.
5 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Who Killed Teddy Bear, Sal Mineo shines in a brilliant performance ahead of its time, in an ignored masterpiece
jpbrinkman20618 January 2006
Hard to believe and very sad to realize that we are coming close to the 30th anniversary of the death, in February-1976,of the brilliant, beautiful, enigmatic, and influential talent of Sal Mineo. He was one of the original 50's heartthrobs who debuted with his poetic performance in the now legendary James Dean classic, Rebel Without a Cause. Later, Mineo became known for his talent and his courage in his art and in his life. He would tackle much more difficult roles and become the first actor to declare his homosexuality, unapologetically. Teddy Bear is Mineo at his most brilliant, most haunting, most daring and most heartbreaking. Coming at a time in his career when he was frustrated with very little roles to choose from, came this harrowing film from director Joseph Cates. It is important to note, and upsetting to say that Teddy Bear is mostly regarded as a "cult classic" and sometimes viewed as a late night schlock/camp film. Nothing could be further from the truth. Here is a film that was not only ahead of its time in subject matter, as well as actors pushing the envelope, but also influencing Martin Scorsese's Taxi Driver(1976) and Alan J. Pakula's Klute (1971).First, it is important to note how much "Teddy Bear" resembles the great Italian films from the late '50's, early'60's. Another great feat for Joseph Cates, is showing the remarkable influence from Michaelangelo Antonioni's L'Eclisse. This is another film dealing with the issues of disillusionment with life and society. Antonioni films Italy as though the surroundings of the characters are being consumed by their environment, a constant theme in Cates' Teddy Bear. Even more remarkable, one can see similarities between Monica Vitti in L'Eclisse and Sal Mineo in Teddy Bear. Both actors never indicating, but truly feeling the confusion, the sadness, and despair with their lives and what they have amounted to. Cates is the one director who beat all others to the punch before imitation of Italian cinema in America became the norm. Joseph Cates dared to show New York as it sadly sometimes can be, a dark, hedonistic, and self absorbed web of sex, self satisfaction and ultimately personal confusion turning to crisis. And he found the perfect actor to personify this as well in the form of the lead character. Mineo never compromises from film's beginning to end. It is a performance of the kind James Dean would have probably played had he lived. And Mineo plays it with all of the same courage, energy and longing that James Dean himself did in Kazan's East of Eden. Alas, Mineo himself had surpassed Dean in some ways with this performance and still, it is ignored. By watching Mineo in this performance, one sees the influence for Robert De Niro's historic Travis Bickle character. A decade earlier Mineo created a character who becomes a victim of an uncaring society, sexual disfunciton and a New York spiraling into hell. Mineo's character certainly would have made movie legend, like DeNiro had done with Driver, if Teddy Bear had been accepted by theatergoers in the first place. Joseph Cates' brilliant directing is overlooked as well. One is reminded of Scorsece's Taxi Driver throughout. The parallels are very easy to see. Cates had made the first movie to address some very upsetting and complicated issues that apparently no one wanted to see on the screen in 1965. Cates treats each character it seems as though they have lost all sensiblility in some cases and are detached from any kind of emotion. Sadly, when each character comes close to any kind of connection, they become even more bitter or face a confusion they can't comprehend or would even want to. Cates also did a brilliant job in creating the other characters through through the other actors in the film. Juliet Prowse as a jaded but still hopeful actress who desperately seeks independence. Jan Murrey as a soul sick cop. And last but not least, the stunning,incandescent Elaine Stritch who steals every scene that she's in and showing a vulnerability and human frailty that would still surprise people in 2006. Teddy Bear has yet to be available on DVD in wide release. It is the last in a series of insults to Cates' vision and Sal Mineo's heartbreaking talent. How soon we forget and overlook an actor of such talent, grace and beauty as Sal Mineo. After seeing his shattering performance in Who Killed Teddy Bear he will be even more greatly missed.
41 out of 46 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Talented Actor in Rock Bottom Flick
dglink10 October 2014
Warning: Spoilers
An inept film that represents a major come down for its leading actor, "Who Killed Teddy Bear?" tries to be a moody psychological thriller, but ends up a seedy confused melodrama that dribbles to an unsatisfying finale. After a shadowy chilling opening, the first half is padded out with disco scenes that illustrate 1960's music and dancing at its worst and with a lengthy walk through New York streets intended to emphasize the lead female character's serious ambitions to get a role on Broadway. In contrast, the second half of the film lurches and jumps from one unrelated scene to another, leaving enormous plot holes and dangling threads in its wake.

As Lawrence Sherman, a nightclub busboy, Sal Mineo, whose credits include Oscar-nominated performances in "Rebel without a Cause" and "Exodus" does well with what little he is given by Arnold Drake's inadequate script. Inexplicably, Sherman lives with his mentally challenged sister, although any connection with the revelation that he is also a stalker and voyeur dangles among the film's many frayed threads. Mineo often resembles a young Marlon Brando, both in looks and the intensity of his performance. Despite the unsavory role, Mineo's talent is apparent, especially in contrast to the total lack elsewhere in the cast with the exception of Elaine Stritch, who also manages to rise above the wreckage; her brief, but intelligent performance as a nightclub manager shines. As Norah Dain, lovely Juliet Prowse is the center of attention for Stritch, the police lieutenant, assorted drunks, and the voyeur. While she displays her considerable dancing skills in one short scene, Prowse's acting chops pale in comparison. However, in fairness, the script prods the actress into erratic inexplicable mood shifts with little motivation; her swings occur with a suddenness that would give Meryl Streep whiplash. Jan Murray's performance as Lt. Dave Madden is best left unmentioned, and Margot Bennett is embarrassing as Mineo's sister.

The moody black and white cinematography is often effective in capturing the seediness of 1960's 42nd Street, and near abstract close-ups suggest an unrealized artistic intent on the part of director Joseph Cates. The latter half of the relatively short film hints at either major censorship cuts or a budget shortfall; a grainy Times Square police chase using a taxicab rather than a squad car suggests the latter. Scenes are cut off inexplicably, and actors are suddenly elsewhere without explanation. A murder goes practically without mention, which leads to an abrupt ending that is beyond comprehension. Evidently, the writer just ran out of ideas, and the director yelled "cut." "Who Killed Teddy Bear?" would be better titled "Who Killed Sal Mineo's Career?" The film is a sad late entry for an actor who began with such promise.
4 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Lurid, sleazy, irresistible.
Neal19 December 1998
Filmed entirely in real New York locations (much of it on the fly, by the look of it) and dripping with sordid Times Square atmosphere, this is a cheap, sensationalistic, slightly arty psycho-sex-thriller with a startling cast drawn from Broadway, Hollywood, and the Borscht Belt. Elaine Stritch is unforgettable as a lesbian in furs, and the camera drools over Mineo and Prowse in various degrees of undress amidst acres of risibly salacious dialogue. If all this weren't tempting enough, three original songs by Al Kasha and Bob Gaudio grace the very 60's soundtrack (and is that an unbilled Joanie Sommers singing the haunting title theme?) Director Cates is Phoebe's dad, and had done much classier stuff on TV before it fled west.
25 out of 28 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Dark and remarkable time capsule -- a small, gritty film too little seen
PrometheusTree649 February 2016
There is a 94 minute cut out there someplace....

Yet this is a remarkable film, and much better than I'd anticipated (I'd never seen it before until recently). Shot in the winter of 1964/65, it's ahead of its time and covers subject matter taboo even now, certainly for mid-'60s Hollywood... It's B&W photography is as haunted and moody as a PSYCHO-era horror film, but TEDDY BEAR has an organic quality about it most Hollywood movies don't have today and didn't have yesterday --- and it reminds those of us old enough to remember of how the cities, from the mid-'60s to the '70s, were beginning to fall apart in the wake of JFK's death and the rise of the incomprehensible Vietnam war (where all our tax dollars were going) -- when peep shows and adult "book stores", with their wares on display in the shop windows, popped up in even "nice" business districts beside Tiffany's, creating a tense and fascinating shabbiness that helped define the schism that was "the '60s".

So the cultural meltdown wasn't just about the hippies and their drugs and the acid rock and the protests which would soon follow this movie (not that there was much of a reaction to the film itself, as few people saw it then); for all the romanticizing of that decade (some of which is understandable), Walter Cronkite wasn't entirely wrong when he called the 1960s "a slum of a decade" and TEDDY BEAR hints at that better than most industry films of the time, and serves to remind us that the world of that era wasn't really all that innocent (even if it was a bit naive in other ways). Such was that echo chamber, filled with its cacophony of voices, that was the '60s -- where you had two decades seemingly shoved into one. And with this movie squarely on the cusp of both.

Good acting, taut direction, and a lot of layers going on at one time...
10 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A bizarre & haunting film about sexual obsession..
Falconeer5 December 2007
Here is one of the lost gems of the early 60's. Joseph Cates "Who Killed Teddy Bear" is a dark, seedy, and sex obsessed oddity that must have unnerved audiences in it's day. The sexy Nora Dane, played by Juliette Prowse, is receiving some very disturbing phone calls, complete with heavy breathing and some obscene suggestions. She doesn't know who this man is, but he seems to know a lot about her, like her name, where she lives, where she works, and what she looks like in her underwear. Elaine Strich plays the tough talking owner of the swinging nightclub where Nora works as a deejay. Her interest in the young Nora goes beyond simple friendship. After the mysterious phone calls become more threatening, Nora consults a detective, who has his own perverse obsessions. And then there is Lawrence, played by Sal Mineo, a shy and polite busboy who works at the club with Nora. And Nora seems to be the center of everyones obsessions, probably due to the fact that she seems to have no interest in sex at all. "Who Killed Teddy Bear" is filmed with an incredible amount of style, in shadowy, dreamlike black & white. For the segments featuring the obscene phone caller, the camera lens actually seems to be fogged up from the body heat and animal lust of the near naked stalker, as he lies on his bed and enjoys the sound of fear in the woman's voice, as he describes what he wants to do to her. And then there are the amazing shots of New York city, by day and night. Everything is light and shadow, lurid and overwrought. This is classic film noir, and it's low budget only adds to it's unique appeal, and adds an extra level of sadness and desperation to the tale. Sal Mineo especially, is outstanding here, as the sexually messed up loner, who lives with his retarded sister in a gloomy apartment. Why Sal never made it on the same level with James Dean and Brando, I cannot understand. This guy always turned in a great performance in everything he did, and possessed an incomparable screen presence. i recommend 'Teddy bear' to people who love cinema, and who have an appreciation for the art of film making. Though it is difficult to find, as there has never been an official video or DVD release, and most likely never will be. There are various online distributors selling bootlegs of this and other Sal Mineo titles, ranging from very good to poor quality. See this if you can. It's unforgettable.
14 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Strange, very strange.
brandoncruze28 August 2023
Warning: Spoilers
A bizarre American neo-noir crime drama starring Sal Mineo and Juliet Prowse featuring hints of masturbation, pornography, lesbians, stalking, and drugs. The film is now regarded as a minor cult classic.

The story concerns Nora (Prowse ), who works at a seedy club and she begins to receive perverted phone calls from a man who seems to be watching her. Dismissing them at first as a sick prank she soon realizes to her horror that they are actually something far more serious.

Sal Mineo plays plays Lawrence who works at the club as a busboy. Lawrence takes care of his mentally challenged sister, and their relationship seems very odd indeed. You have to see it to believe it. Sal spends most of this film in skin-tight jeans, shirts, and speedos all of which which shows off not just his muscled physique but also his manhood.

Mineo does deliver a riveting performance as the demented baby-faced stalker and the weird plot twists try to keep you engrossed to a point but the overall weirdness of the film is it's biggest downfall.

Gritty, exploitive, violent, kinky and at times, disturbing but worth a watch, if for nothing other than to marvel at Mineo's physique and crazed performance.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Sexy,compelling,sleazy
salmineo9 August 1999
Sal Mineo at his sexiest in this 65 thriller.This film must have really made shock waves when it was released.

Although,sleazy,campy and exploitive,it is also compelling,and a dirty pleasure to watch.Juliet Prowse plays the victim.This film offers an ending that would still shock viewers in the 90's
17 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Goes nowhere
Leofwine_draca16 September 2021
I heard a lot of good things about this one but wasn't overly impressed. I do like a lot of the psycho-thrillers from this era but this one is far too padded with endless back and forth dialogue and day to day stuff with the imperilled heroine. Sal Mineo is good value of course as the mixed-up young man at the centre of it all and the sexual aspect of the film makes it ahead of its time, but the low budget is all too obvious throughout and, for me, this just goes nowhere.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
First-rate trash!
gershom7 February 1999
"Who Killed Teddy Bear" is irresistible trash, an utterly sleazy film that wallows in B-movie murk without apology. The performances are fine (with the camera leering at the often half-dressed Mineo and Prowse), the script is the stuff of now-extinct 42nd Street grindhouses, and the cinematography seems right out of an early '60s voyeuristic fantasy. This one is guaranteed to touch a salacious chord in anyone with the nerve to sit through.
21 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
There never was a sexier pervert....
mark.waltz18 September 2015
Warning: Spoilers
Even before you see his face, you can feel the sensuality of Sal Mineo thrusting its way off the screen, wearing nothing but tighty whities as he makes several obscene phone calls at 6 O'clock in the morning. He's only fondling his legs, but the point is made. When you finally see Sal's gorgeous face, he's inside a really swinging nightclub where the customers are rude, crude, long to be nude, and using food to get the girls in the mood. Mineo works busing tables and takes over waiting them when the servers don't show up.

"If you're going make it in show biz, you're going to meet some pretty weird types. Of course, that is assuming that you're planning on making it on your feet, so to speak!" That's how you're introduced here to the legendary "Ladies Who Lunch" diva Elaine Stritch, playing an extremely glamorous lesbian who has the hots for D.J. Juliet Prowse. Tough but with a sense of compassion to the underdog, Stritch has a drunk customer kicked out and stands up for one of her deaf employees when the customer attacks him. She reminds me a great deal of Grayson Hall's character in the cult movie "Satan in High Heels", although this was obviously made on a bit of a higher budget even if it's still down the scale on its vision of a lack of polite society.

As for Mineo, don't let his polite on the surface nature fool you; He disguises his voice on the phone as you see only his bare chest and the tip of his jockeys, and this is where the perversion takes on a sexual film noir story, pre-dating "Basic Instinct" and "Fatal Attraction" by more than two decades. This is the village, and it is not a polite society. The film turns dirt into art, and it is absolutely fascinating to watch, even though you are praying that circumstances like this never happen to you. But when you work in the bar world of a big metropolis, you never know what type of sociopath is going to come in. Even the police detective interviewing Prowse after she is harassed on the phone has a very verbal way of describing the types of characters he has come in contact with. Don't click your heels together to hope to go back to Kansas; Once you're in the land of Odd, you're stuck there.

A jazzy music score aids in the vision of New York's dark side, and there's no turning back when you stay out past happy hour. Nights in New York always bring film noir to life, whether it's on screen or in reality. I have been searching for this dark and disturbing film ever since I became fans of both Mineo's and Stritch's, and in biographies on Mineo's life, Ms. Stritch went into great detail in her remembrances of him as a man and as an actor. Jan Murray is fantastic as the police detective overshadowed by the grittiness in his life, yet still leading the life of perfect father. A lot of detail went into the creation of each of these characters, and every moment is fascinating. Every character (including Murray) has their own elements of darkness, showing the inner anxieties we all carry and which can explode at any minute.

The teddy bear reference is an interesting metaphor both psychologically and visually, and in spite of the tacky nature of the theme, it is sensationalism that titillates no matter how much the viewer tries not to admit it. As Jean Simmons' missionary said in "Guys and Dolls", she's supposedly afraid of sin, so naturally, she's attracted to it. But these aren't the friendly colorful gamblers of Damon Runyeon's New York. This is a John Cassavettes/John Waters view of a changing society, filled with a gritty ugliness that the early film noir only dared to touch on.
13 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Edgy, sepulchral study on criminal depravity
EyeAskance11 December 2009
Pretty, young Juliet Prowse is a NYC discotheque DJ being stalked by sex-psycho Sal Mineo in this flawed but ahead-of-its-time shocker, a film perched on the median between arthouse and grindhouse which might appeal to enthusiasts of Sam Fuller's contemporaneous work.

Performances are strong from the key players(especially Elaine Stritch as Prowse's inured lesbian boss, Jan Murray as the solicitous investigator, and Mineo...a deeply disturbed but ultimately pitiable predator). Unfortunately, the film is marred significantly by the comically written and overplayed character of Mineo's little sister, doomed to eternal childhood as the result of a tragic accident.

Though there is intermittent creative camera-work at hand, production values are pretty low overall. Fortunately, the tawdriness of the whole affair calls for just that, and WHO KILLED TEDDY BEAR succeeds, perhaps despite itself. It's a gripping, stark, and quite depressing meditation on obsession, loneliness and perversion which touches bravely on every taboo in the book. This rife lurid sensationalism feels strangely at-odds with itself, however...the tone here seems more cautionary than uninhibited, possibly an ill-boding advisory propelled by the whiling fears of 60s-era reactionaries. The times, they were a-changing, and many at the far-right felt the nation's moral compass had become a pinwheel in the wind.

. 7.5/10.
10 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
The Late Teddy Bear
bkoganbing18 April 2009
According to a recent biography of Sal Mineo he was going through a lot of professional and personal angst at the time he was making Who Killed Teddy Bear. Professional because he was no longer the teen idol of the Fifties and roles were getting scarce. He was in the early Sixties discovering the fact he was indeed gay. Maybe the role of the sexually confused busboy might do something or maybe it was the best he could get.

Whatever it was Teddy Bear might have been the low point of his career and a few others in the cast. No one comes out of this with any glory.

Juliet Prowse is a disc jockey at a disco and of course she takes her turn on the floor as well. She's picked up a stalker and when she turns to the police for help she gets a cop with issues.

That would be Jan Murray, late of the borscht belt and of the television game show Treasure Hunt which I first remember seeing him in. His wife was brutally killed in a sex crime homicide and he now quite obsesses on the subject of sexual predators. He's also feeling a little lustful towards Juliet.

And he's not the only one. The owner of disco Elaine Stritch would like to make a little time with her. Normally I might applaud the fact that lesbianism even got a hint on the screen, but in such a crass and a exploitive film as Who Killed Teddy Bear.

It's one weird film, shot totally on location in New York with what looks like someone's Bell&Howell home movie camera. Production values are near zero.

Skip this trash by.
6 out of 28 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Beyond Noir!
big_bellied_geezer9 June 2005
Read Son of Cathode's review as he has it right about this great piece of film making that has somehow gone mostly unnoticed by those that fancy dark and gritty films. This film delivers in spades and in my final estimation, I can only add to what others have said before me in saying this was way ahead of it's time when one considers technique.

However, if this was attempted to have been made let's say in 1976 as opposed in 1965, it might of lost something in capturing the gritty underbelly which was somewhat different than the gritty style of a decade earlier and the finished product might have been too slick and obvious for 1976. I'm glad that the film makers were bold enough to have taken on such a project when they did it in 1965 and this film stands as a testament to their boldness.

Look online at some of the big online auctions and you can commonly find this title now days for under 20 bucks and well worth it as this is a must see film for those who REALLY like the noir style.
11 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Who Killed Teddy Bear
henry8-32 October 2021
Neo Noir thriller about a sexually confused individual (Sal Mineo) preying on Juliet Prowse. Troubled detective Madden, played by Jan Murray, whose wife was raped and murdered, starts to show an interest in the case snd gets closer to Prowse.

Originally a flop, this somewhat controversial sexual thriller has now gained something of a cult following. On the plus side Mineo is pretty convincing as the crazed youth plagued by his childhood experiences and Prowse not bad in the lead and Stritch always watchable giving it her usual tough cynical broad act. Less convincing is Murray who can't quite carry off the ambiguity needed for his character.

As a thriller this often works quite well, but the heavy handed sigh posting of any and all things sexual merely makes it seem all the more sleazy and exploitative and the endless visions by Mineo's character are rather crass.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed