Desperate Choices: To Save My Child (TV Movie 1992) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
A rather intense and well-depicted TV drama
cosmic_quest5 November 2006
'Solomon's Choice' is a heart-warming film about how a child's illness has all sorts of ramifications for all the family and the rights of parents and children.

The film centres on Cassie Robbins, an energetic sixteen-year-old who has a close relationship with her father Richard and stepmother Mel and dotes on her six-year-old half-brother Willy. But when she is diagnosed with leukaemia and chemotherapy fails, a bone-marrow transplant remains her only hope of survival. And this is when Richard and Mel clash as Willy could be a potential match but his mother isn't willing to risk the procedure since the little boy had a bad reaction to anaesthetic when he was last operated on. Richard reacts harshly when he sees Mel's reluctance to test their son as an example of her protecting her 'real' child over her step-daughter. As their family starts to collapse, Willy himself becomes increasingly aware that he holds the key to saving his sister.

The quality of acting in the film surpassed what is usually expected in made-for-television dramas. Cassie, played by a teenage Reece Witherspoon, was excellent as a likable girl coping with the turmoil of possible terminal illness and who is willing to die if that's what it takes to protect her little brother. Bruce Davison, as Richard, and Joanna Kerns, as Mel, give strong performances as parents who fiercely love their children but have to defend their differing views under such gut-wrenching circumstances. And a small Joseph Mazzello (better known as Tim in 'Jurassic Park'), in the role of Willy, gives a very endearing portrayal of a little boy caught in a situation he doesn't understand yet determined to support his sister.

The story is depicted in a manner that is quite realistic, with parents lashing out-- sometimes violently-- in the face of their child's possible death and children struggling to cope with illness and what is happening to their previously happy family. The film does well in showing a rather balanced view of both Richard and Mel's views, without turning the latter into a wicked stepmother hoarding her natural son to herself and instead she is just shown to be a worried mother. That said, personally, it was hard to agree with her and it would have been interesting to have seen the consequences to the Robbins' marriage and to an older Willy had Cassie died without the transplant.

'Solomon's Choice' is still one of the better TV dramas out there and is certainly worth catching if it's ever on.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Good for its genre and has Reese Witherspoon!
freydis-e4 February 2019
This is a typical made-for-TV heart-render, low budget, patchy acting and the story generally nothing that original. Let's take a family problem and do it by the usual numbers. Not my kind of thing and I watched it only because these film-makers lucked out by casting one of the best actors around, sixteen year old Reese in one of her earliest roles.

Two things are good here and they're very good. Reese was amazing even back then, lighting up every scene she's in, and that's most of them, delivering a masterclass to the more experienced folk around her - always totally believable and creating a character to really care about. The other one: here is a story with no bad guy, not even a selfish guy. Everyone is trying to look out for everyone else and yet 'the slings and arrows of outrageous fortune' can still manage to tear them apart.

Bad things. Stuff was missing. Other reviewers have complained about the ending and this is one where viewers are left to pick their own. I didn't mind that but I didn't like that the brother's opinion is never sought or listened to - only discovered by accident. Yes, he's a little kid, he can't make the decision, but that shouldn't mean no-one cares what he thinks. A conversation is missing between Cassie and Mel - they are natural allies here and this would go a long way to mitigating Mel's blind stubbornness. Finally there's no apology from Mel for that stubbornness, which has put Cassie at greater risk.

If you like this kind of film at all, watch this one - Reese Witherspoon alone makes it outstanding for its genre.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
ending ruins it for me
clock_me8 June 2017
Warning: Spoilers
first of all i watched this movie because of Reese Wither spoon and it had to do with cancer now for the first hour and 35 min it was really really good had good emotions characters story but then came the ending that ruined the movie right then and there I mean how can you not show Reese Wither spoon in the hospital getting the transplant and the affects after that should have been the climax but instead it ends with her and her brother showing off that he can ride a bike on his own I mean come on that was a low blow I love to cry in movies but this did not do it for me next time you make a movie about a family fighting to save there daughter show them at the end standing by here to see if she pulls through the movie should have run about 2 hours tr 220 i will not be seeing this one again
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Quick comment...
sher57648 March 2004
This film was incredible. I was only 7 when it came out and I recorded it from tv and I just watched it again now, 11 years later. It's so much more than a sappy disease movie. It really makes you think about what you would have to do in their situation. It describes the situation between the step-mother, the father, and the brother. A huge part of the movie is whether or not they will allow their son to be a bone marrow donor. The whole time, I sided with the father, because the risks were small that he would be affected by it and he shouldn't have to grow up knowing that he could have saved his sister's life. A+++ I guarantee it to anyone who doesn't mind crying.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Pretty good movie
alliesmom9726 July 2003
Warning: Spoilers
This was different from most TV movies about "disease" in a couple of ways. In most movies like this the victim and the family are so brave and uncomplaining and all get along so perfectly all the time that it is rarely believable, even if it is a "true story". And secondly, these movies usually focus mainly on the victim.

Possible spoilers, but I don't give away the ending!!

In "Solomon's Choice" the focus is more on the parents of Cassie, the teenager suffering from leukemia. And circumstances are such that they are not a perfect, wonderful and always upbeat family. When Cassie is diagnosed the doctors feel her only chance at survival is a bone marrow transplant and want to test her younger brother, Willy, as a possible match. Willy, however, had been involved in a serious auto accident a year or so before, and among other things, had a problem with the anesthesia during surgery. Mom is totally unwilling to allow him to undergo the procedure that could save his sister's life unless the doctors can guarantee he'll be OK, which of course, they can't. She wants to look for another suitable donor. Dad is willing to accept the doctors opinion that he would probably be fine, and wants to have the procedure done to save Cassie before it is too late. The situation gets even more ugly because although Mom has raised Cassie for many years and is very close to her, she is the girl's stepmom, and Dad comes to see her refusal as choosing Willy over Cassie because he is her "real" child.

One thing I liked about the movie is that it managed to present the feelings of both parents well enough that you had a hard time just leaping to the defense of either one--you could sort of see both sides.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Excellent
Laidlaw0034 February 2005
I have seen the movie and I thought it was sad towards the end of the movie. Reese Witherspoon as Cassie has Leukemia and the only way it might help Cassie to get better is from Willy for a bone donor. And at the end of the movie I was looking for something more like Willy went through the surgery and knowing thats what would of happen and known for sure if she got all better because it skipped through the bone donor I did not like how it ended well it tells you if you love someone you would do whatever the cost is. This is an excellent true story about the movie.I think you would enjoy watching it. I give it an A if you haven't seen this movie I would encourage you to buy it you might watch it over and over a couple of times

Michael
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed