Junior makes a man out of vegetables and enlists Seymour to help find a human brain. Meanwhile, Audrey decides to pursue a career repairing refrigerators.
Seymour and Paine are cast as the leads in the community theater's newest production of "Our Town," which Junior has secretly revised. Meanwhile, Audrey's latest passion is working as a stagehand.
Audrey gets a job at a used shoe store. Meanwhile, Junior uses his vegetable magnetism on a pair of rubber-soled shoes to give Seymour the ability to fly.
Seymour goes trick-or-treating for the first time, Audrey becomes a telephone operator, and Junior uses his vegetable magnetism to steal all of the pumpkins in town so he can give them a proper burial.
A reaper shows Seymour a future where the Mushnicks own a yogurt shop, Paine is winning awards, and Seymour is a politician. Meanwhile, Junior dreams that he runs a hotel for flowers.