"Matlock" The Fatal Seduction: Part 2 (TV Episode 1993) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
I think the villains, the murderers really made this 2-parter compelling
reb-warrior13 June 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Billy's sister, Lucy passes away. Yes, that Lucy. Ben, Cliff, Leanne, and Billy, are off to her house and funeral at a beach location. A murder takes place and here we go.

I think Ben was out-of-character here in the two-parter and in the episode before that, the season premiere. Ben seems almost disinterested in being a lawyer. He seems more interested in doing other things. Leanne and Cliff take the lead and do the investigation for the most part. Leanne is the one that represents Clyde. She has to pull hairs to get Ben to take an interest in the case and take action. It seems odd they wrote it this way. I mean, I could totally see it from Leanne and Cliff's pov because of Tim's questions. Then Tim "drowns" and the lifeguard that tried to save him is suddenly murdered. I could definitely see how that intrigued them and made them know something wasn't right. Anyway, just not the Ben I know.

In this one the audience knows who the murderers are, ala Columbo. It becomes an investigation and then a how-to-catch-em for Leanne, Cliff, and Ben. The two young women, Carrie and Ashley, were meticulous. The setup took up the entirety of part 1. Tim being set up, him trying to get proof, him being killed by making it look like a drowning, and then Mike(who was the one to drown Tim at Carrie's behest) being killed by Carrie, and then setting up poor Clyde for it. This was all actually compelling. Carrie and Ashley were psychopaths and it was interesting watching their plan unfold.

Carrie is played by a young Jerry Ryan from the Star Trek franchise. I almost wasn't completely sure if that was her or if it was someone who looked a lot like her. But I saw her name in the credits in part two, which I didn't notice in the first part.

I thought maybe the syringe cap which Carrie removed with her mouth and tossed would come into play as part of the gotcha evidence by Ben and the gang later on. But no, it never did, and Carrie must have removed it I guess.

Ben was funny at times but mainly seemed uninvolved and uninterested as Leanne and Cliff seemed to lead this. It really wasn't until about the second half-hour of part two did Ben get involved with the case. The villains and the whole premise of the murder story were pretty good. 8/10.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Pure stupidity
mttiro10 May 2019
The deficiencies written into Ben Matlock's character during the last few years of this otherwise great series are literally stupid beyond words. The writers, normally clever and agile in producing exciting and meaningful scripts, generated a character in their writing of Ben Matlock who was little beyond a demented, robotic senior citizen incapable of anything except for brilliant legal thinking.

And that, brilliant legal thinking, is what he morphs into every time he's working on a case, both in and out of a courtroom. He becomes an unstoppable investigator and a Perry Mason-like courtroom wizard who defeats every effort of the bad guys to thwart justice.

But in every other area of life, Matlock is a silly, neurotic, miserly old jackass who is so inhibited and emotionally constipated that he can't even tell his only child, his grown daughter, that he loves her. He spends all his free time playing gin with his daughter or playing horseshoes with his hateful cousin Billy, and fighting ferociously when he thinks either one of them is cheating him, which is constantly. His behavior parallels the behavior of a 6-year-old fighting over whose turn it is to bat in a game of wiffle-ball--immature and constantly screeching "No fair!" Except he's not 6 years old. He's a 60-something supposedly grown man.

It doesn't get any better when Matlock deals with women. He is completely incapable of expressing his feelings for a woman, especially the assistant DA Julie Sommars, who throws herself at him and does everything except ask him to marry her. And even then, he is unable to say the word "love."

This character portrait, of a stunted, under-developed psyche that stopped somewhere around age 12, is a foolish and stupid way to portray a man who is as successful in his career and profession as Matlock is. It's not entertaining in the least, and it's off-putting to the max. And such a shame to ruin this great series by portraying the character this way. The series didn't start this way. Somewhere after the first year or 2, someone got control of the production and steered the show in a different direction. It's too bad. They ruined it.
11 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Typical Matlock made better by Jeri Ryan
BSS28 January 2004
This wasn't a bad movie at all. It was definitely typical Matlock, though. If you're looking for that one that breaks the formula, you won't find it here. This is worth checking out at least for Jeri Ryan, whether you're a Matlock fan or not. 5/10
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed