The Safety Curtain (1918) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Talmadge in Women's Weepies
Cineanalyst18 December 2009
Warning: Spoilers
"The Safety Curtain" is one of the few Norma Talmadge films that have been in home video circulation (so far). It's one of her earliest pictures made under her own production company with the supervision of her husband-movie mogul Joseph Schenck and is the first of only two I've been able to find--the other being "The Forbidden City" (1918). By that time, Talmadge was becoming one of the movies' most popular stars, and, at least, by the 1920s, her appeal was comparable to Mary Pickford and other top-grossing actors, which may be surprising to some today. "The Safety Curtain" seems to be a good representation of the kind of melodrama Talmadge became famous for. A somewhat more derogatory term for them has been "women's weepies", a term which Jeanine Basinger ("Silent Stars") used, as one assumes Talmadge's audience was disproportionately women, and the melodramas are from the perspective of a female protagonist facing significantly domestic and romantic issues.

In this one, Talmadge plays a music-hall dancer abused by her strong man husband. After a fire during her performance at the music hall, her and her husband are reported dead. Talmadge's character then marries the officer who rescued her from the disaster. The narrative is sensational, with a few convenient twists (the plague was especially opportune), while treating heavy issues of abuse and bigamy. Regardless, Talmadge did well to hold interest in following her character's emotional highs and lows. Overall, it's a decently made production for 1918. The film's title is very appropriate, and I liked the curtain motif. The "safety curtain" explicitly refers to the music hall drape that protects the crowded theatre from the fire. Implicitly, it also suggests the security Talmadge's character finds in the officer, from the fire and her first abusive husband.

(Note: The recording I saw seemed to be at much too fast a pace, perhaps, at sound projection speed, rather than the slower rate silents tended to be shown at. A couple scenes (Talmadge's can-can dance and maybe the fire episode) seem to have originally been under-cranked, so this unnaturally fast projection furthers their effect. It ran approximately 51 minutes, which, indeed, is probably too short for a six-reel production. There was also an annoying, constant logo from the video distributor in the left-hand bottom corner.)
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Puck in Bombay
richardchatten11 June 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Director Sidney Franklin does his usual elegant job on this well appointed star vehicle for Norma Talmadge that enables us to enjoy her handsome face in closeup and those lovely eyes looking up imploringly as the story pursues a fanciful arc from a music hall in London to Bombay in the throes of a cholera epidemic. Anders Randolph at his most overbearing is Miss Talmadge's brutish husband who defies reports of his death and goes to the trouble of pursuing her all the way to India only to obligingly keel over dead almost as soon as he arrives.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Norma Talmadge as a Dainty Dancer
drednm23 August 2010
THE SAFETY CURTAIN (1918) stars Norma Talmadge as Puck, a "dainty dancer" married to a brutish strong man (Anders Randolph) who starts a fire in a theater during which the safety curtain drops, containing the fire. Talmadge is rescued by a visiting military man (Eugene O'Brien), who falls in love with her and takes her away to India. Of course she thinks the husband is dead after reading an article in the newspaper listing the victims (which includes her). She goes off and lives a happy live in India until a gossipy guy she new in the States (Gladden James) recognizes her at a social function. And who should show up next?

Talmadge and O'Brien are quite good in this neat little film, which has a surprisingly intricate plot for a 60-minute film. The intertitles are very talkie and the florid script used is sometimes hard to read. Talmadge and O'Brien starred in 11 films together between 1917 and 1925.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Norma Talmadge Shines in Gripping Melodrama!
JohnHowardReid28 April 2008
Way back in my university days, I happily served on the film selection committee for the uni film society. Just about every term, we booked The Covered Wagon, The Lost World and Hands Up! from the local Kodascope Library. Thinking that the Library might have other features to interest our members, the committee took a look at The Moonstone, The Wonderful Chance, The Safety Curtain, Captain January, Flesh and Blood, Are Parents People?, The Pony Express and Ella Cinders.

Needless to say, although we were blown away by the special effects in The Wonderful Chance and loved Colleen Moore's Ella Cinders, the movie that impressed us the most was, unexpectedly, The Safety Curtain, which we booked simply because the title aroused our curiosity. If we had read a synopsis of the story beforehand, we wouldn't have considered it at all, because the plot reads like pure melodrama. But that's not the way it is played or directed. The acting from all four principals is so natural and life-like that the taut story itself seems absolutely true-to-life.

Furthermore, Norma Talmadge radiates an undeniable charisma. And she and the other players are well served by Sidney Franklin's surprisingly inventive and skillful direction, which is further enhanced by entrancingly attractive sepia-tinted photography. A large budget also helps keep interest at the highest level. In all, a masterpiece of movie artistry!
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed