Eggheads (2003– ) User Reviews

Good premise poorly executed

[pugmilamber · 5/10 · 18 August 2006]

I am quite a fan of TV quiz shows, they allow you to test your knowledge and shout abuse at contestants for getting easy questions wrong. Nowadays it seems the shows presenters are more interested in either getting to know the contestants or verbally abusing them (see "the weakest link" hosted by the most irritating Ginger since Cilla Black) This particular show could have and SHOULD have been much better. I agree completely with the comments above and would like to add that if that baldy smartar*e Chris forces us to listen to the complete history and every bit of his knowledge about an answer again i will get in my car, drive down to the BBC studios and beat him until his eyes bleed. I cannot emphasise enough how much he irritates me with his arrogance and bookworm like sadness. We know u know the answer Chris, just give the correct response and stfu.

/end rant

Boring host asking too few questions

[frank-gibbard · 6/10 · 29 May 2006]

Dermot Murnaghan the host has I think helped to spoil what could have been a better quiz format than it sadly turned out to be. I find him irritating, too cosy and avuncular with his patronising air and repetitious phrases you've heard in every programme ad nauseam and his chuckle and the implied siding with the underdogs efforts against the "dream team" although he knows full well they have little if any chance. He generally talks too much twittering on to fill the gaps because there are not enough questions per programme to keep interest levels up IMO. Other problems inducing exasperation if one watches it a lot is the "dream team" wins too often and their opponents rarely compete on anything like a level playing field.

Formulaic Weekday Time-Waster

[tojeem · 6/10 · 28 November 2013]

You get home from a long day at work and want to watch something that doesn't require too many brain cells or attention. What do you turn to?

Eggheads is your average, slow-paced multiple choice pub-style quiz show. Right from the get-go you get a formula: The presenter uses the same words and phrases each episode, and each time there is a different group of contestants who are connected in some way - graduates from the same college, nuns from the same convent, worm charmers from the same worm charming club. You get the point. The questions are all very similar, but are all very difficult, with the exception of the first question in each round. Don't expect to know most of the answers. The topics range from Food and Drink to History to Film and Television.

The points system is also formulaic. Four of the five challengers get to face head-to-head their choice of one of five Eggheads, a team of expert quiz winners who rotate from a larger selection of Eggheads, which ranges from about six to eight depending on the season. Each head-to-head winner gets to compete in the final round, and each loser has to sit outside. By the end of the show, it's usually three against two, or one against four, usually with an advantage for The Eggheads, because, well, they're better than the contestants. If the constants win their set of three questions (followed by a Sudden Death round if there's a tie), they win the prize money, which increases by one thousand pounds for every episode the contestants lose. The prize money often gets to around, but rarely over, 20-ish thousand pounds.

The Eggheads are all amiable, with the exception of the know-it-all CJ, who is always pulling faces when the head-to-head challengers get their answers wrong. Still, they're a joy to watch and their personalities are all memorable. The first host, Dermot, was a bit dry. The co-host in the later series, Jeremy, is more fun, but still sticks heavily to the formula.

The show is a good time-waster, but it lacks the suspense of its competitors like Who Wants to be a Millionaire, not only because the prize money is less, but because it's quite dull by nature. Nevertheless, I watch it every weekday simply because it's something familiar, routine, and regular.

6/10

"So tune in next time to see if a new team of challengers have what it takes to beat The Eggheads! Twelve thousand pounds says they don't. Until then, goodbye."

Average as quiz shows go, but it has its good points.

[robert-jalberg7 · 11 September 2004]

As a big fan of general knowledge quizzes, I tune in to Eggheads even though I am not totally swayed by it. Even so, it is probably better than most BBC quiz shows, and that includes the irritating and past its sell-by-date Weakest Link.

Let's be positive to begin with and state the good points:

1. It has two of the best quizzers in the country, Kevin Ashman and Daphne Fowler.

2. It shows how lucky Judith Keppel got with her Millionaire win. She is well above average for her general knowledge, but if she had to go through the 15 questions on WWTBAM again, I'd place money on her not winning - even if she had another ten attempts. But fair dos and congratulations to her.

3. You can join in with the fun and answer questions before the rest of your family. Well, usually.

4. Occasionally the opponents really do have the Eggheads on the ropes, and there is a smidgen of tension as we await the outcome.

Now, since I'm struggling to think of the good points, here are the bad points.

1. Most of the questions are pretty easy, just to give the opponents a chance, and then hope one of the Eggheads will slip up. Also, the caliber of people on the public side is pretty poor sometimes.

2. The people going on to the show should really sort out their tactics better. Play Kevin on entertainment, Daphne on sport, although these pair are pretty good on everything anyway.

3. Judith and CJ are strange choices. Their general knowledge is well below the other three, but like I've said before - they are well above average.

4. Will Chris stop going on about trains and railways - and why do so many questions regarding his pet subjects keep coming up? Is he the question-setter?

5. The set is horrible - too much like the Weakest Link.

6. Kevin and Daphne are not given the opportunity so show their talent.

7. There are not enough questions, and too much talking.

I 'ate those bass tuds!

[thomas-hardcastle-2 · 5/10 · 31 August 2008]

The questions are of a decent enough difficulty not to exclude people like university challenge does, but there are two problems with this show One is the fact that it takes too long to do anything (they need to get on with it sometimes). Everything takes place so slowly.

The largest problem is the fact that I can't help but want to punch the TV screen when I see the Eggheads' smug little faces - especially CJ, who is aim assiv tw@, not only in my opinion, it seems.

That's the problem with this premise. Sure, it's interesting and challenging to take on some of the smartest people in the country, but in watching this, you know you're massaging their egos all the way, huffing under your breath that you hate them.

Innovative, very laid-back yet sadly a poor, predictable and unexciting follow-up to "The Weakest Link"

[chrisbishop5000 · 4/10 · 15 April 2007]

Although 2003's "Eggheads" is relaxed, chatty and doesn't put half the amount of pressure "The Weakest Link" puts on its contestants, this really is quite a dull, predictable show and very incompetent when compared to "The Weakest Link" which still takes the nation by storm to this day - 6 and a half years on from its original broad-casted episode in 2000.

The presenter Dermot is nice and encouraging and everything but does he ever stop wittering on?!!! He can't keep his mouth closed for longer than 10 seconds at the most! He cannot get through a single show without dramatizing the fact that the eggheads have won again... and again... and again. Why can't he just see the simple fact that these are just ordinary people - he talks about the prim and proper Judith Keppel, the rather stuck-up, "O riff-raff, do be qwaht" smartypants CJ De Mooi who doesn't make himself look clever at all but just plain cocky, the somewhat dreary Chris Hughes (who looks as if he might fall asleep at any moment), the sweet, gentle Daphnie Fowler and Kevin Ashman as if they are all superheroes, as if they know absolutely everything, as if they are even royalty sometimes! The eggheads are seldom beaten as well! I'm sure that if this debuted in the late 1980s or something then it would look perfect upon the screen but this is 2007! Meaning it's at least 18 years out of date! Having said all of that, mind you, the youngest egghead, CJ De Mooi, would've probably been a young child back then wouldn't he? I do mildly admire this show (lifeless, predictable and exaggerative as it is), depending on what mood I'm in but it simply cannot reach the enormous standards and amazing quality of "The Weakest Link" even if they are different shows!

Eggheads - a very good way to spend half an hour of quizzing

[naseby · 8/10 · 2 December 2013]

As a personal 'must see' in the early evenings here in the UK, I catch Eggheads when I can. The show at the time of posting has now been going ten years. The format is easy-going. A team of 'challengers' take on what is commonly described as 'Possibly the best team of quizzers in Britain' as the Eggheads team consists of those who have become champions in former TV quiz shows in the UK. The two 'strongest' members it has to be said are Kevin Ashman and Daphne Fowler. The show has lost CJ De Mooi who was a regular on the team.

The team(s) consist of five members, but the Eggheads team has its standard five, but others who alternate leaving two others off the team when on in the 'five'. This 'alternating' team also consists of Barry Simmons, Pat Gibson, Judith Keppel, Chris Hughes and Dave Rainford. There is talk of CJ De Mooi returning after pursuing an acting career.

The challengers' team will be asked which of their number wants to take on which Egghead as long as that one hasn't already been on (after first being asked if your team wants to go 'first or second'). If you lose the multiple choice answers (3) to the question, well you lose! If at the end of three it's a draw, then a 'sudden death' shootout takes place without the 'multiple choice' help, so the winning answers in that case have to come from the depths of your knowledge. Series have been hosted by Dermot Murnaghan and Jeremy Vine (Brother of comedian Tim vine).

The show offers a prize, per show of £1,000 but this rolls over if the challengers fail to win, by another £1,000. As mostly is the case, when the Eggheads win, this will then mean tens of thousands of pounds further down the line to a team that does beat them.

As can be seen on the message boards about Eggheads, many have their pet-hates of the Eggheads team or particular members and some are asking if it's fair, that, some of the challenging teams aren't really from a broad perspective of knowledge and thrown in to the arena without a real cat-in-hell's-chance of winning - but some have won in spectacular fashion. A team of students were once all knocked out leaving just one challenger to continue in the final against ALL the Egghead team. This challenger won through and a total of £75,000! My favourite persons are probably Judith and Pat. Others have described Chris, Daphne, Kevin, Barry and CJ as unbelievably smug and a few of that number do indeed seem to sulk at losing or show extreme annoyance! Dave seems morose but I think that's just his manner, he's not really! Chris and Barry do remind you somewhat of the dodgy uncle tucking you into bed at night Daphne can be sickening in pretending, I believe, in not knowing the answer when she does and CJ often lost his round, only to be flailing his arms around when the rest of the Eggheads don't get a question right (even though, as I say, he's often already been knocked out). A good show, just to see them lose - hee-hee-hee!

I think it's a brilliant show !

[brianof · 10/10 · 6 October 2006]

I love quizzes, and I presume anyone reading this does too. The premise of the show is that a pub team of 5 people goes up against the quiz show's Dream Team of 5 quiz boffins. There are 5 rounds. The first 4 are a one-on-one between a contestant and an egghead. The winner goes thru to the final round, the loser goes out. The more eggheads you can knock out in the first 4 rounds, the fewer you face in the final general knowledge round and thus have a better chance of winning.

I think the combined knowledge of the Eggheads is fascinating. I love how they not only know the answer but know every scrap of info around the answer. The pub team very rarely win but it is worth watching regardless a) for the rare occasions when they do and b) just to see how ridiculously easy the questions are to Kevin & Daphne. To those who think "just challenge Daphne on sport" - you do know that Sport is her strongest category. Judith is undoubtedly the weakest of the 5, so facing her can get you thru easily, but you wont win if you don't knock out Kevin & Daphne ! It's one of the few programmes I really enjoy watching, although I admit it could have been better if there were more questions involved.

Unmissable entertainment!

[opsbooks · 8/10 · 14 January 2013]

This is a show we never miss; it provides both entertainment and a degree of enlightening knowledge.

Sure, there are irritating aspects in the annoying blue set and occasional robot-like host Jeremy Vine. Currently (January 2013) we are viewing 2009 episodes in Australia and Dermot Murnaghan is a far better host. He shows far more empathy for both the challengers and the Eggheads and seems not bound to a fixed script.

The Eggheads themselves are pretty much a cross section of humanity. Chris, down to earth, shooting straight from the shoulder; Daphne, always cheerful, but with a memory like a steel trap; CJ, playing a part totally unlike his real self; Barry, a bit of a mystery with what often appears to be a forced smile; Kevin, similar to but not as forceful as Chris and finally, Judith, who also has a mighty memory but seems off her game in these 2009 episodes.

Overall, this is a show worth watching and long may it continue to grace our screens.

Good programme, poor mix questions

[chris-3611 · 18 April 2006]

A reasonable quiz in that it is better than many now available for entertainment. Mastermind has become rather boring, the question subjects are so mundane,(TV programmes, pop groups.) Not quite the selection of intellectual specialities it used to have.

Anyway, Eggheads is quite entertaining with a touch of added humour (always good in my book) Some of the visiting teams do appear to have been vetted for little other than novelty value. The questions do seem to vary in their difficulty quotient rather, especially in the head-to-head extra questions.

There are always 3 stronger cast members, Chris with his trains, Keven (had to be) who looks as if he would rather not be there at all, Daphne, CJ's surrogate Mum(Tell him to sort out his hair, he looks more like Widow Twankie as the weeks go on!) Then there is The Posh Traveller, Judith, and the non-conformist CJ 'Do I look good in this' Da Mooi. They seem to hit on the right answers more by luck than judgement. Anyway 'A nice little earner' Passes the time. Thanks

I absolutely like this show

[artmargo · 10/10 · 6 April 2010]

I like this show very much. I watch it everyday. very enjoyable. Judith and Daphne are very charming ladies.

I come from Lithuania but live in the Netherlands and I must say it is the best everyday show for me.

My favorite of this show are: Judith, Daphne and CJ DE Mooi.

I like that you can play together with some of the family members and to check the knowledge. My favorite subjects are geography and music. It is always fun to watch this show and good there are no advertisement, so 30 minutes enjoyable show.

Well done, well cast, well host, well made.

Missing the point

[joejacksonj · 9/10 · 25 March 2009]

I do feel that some of the comments made are missing the point. The programme is for entertainment and bears more relevance to Question of Sport which is an excellent quiz show mixed with lots of comical quips, and for the most part the competition become irrelevant. "Who cares who about the sport? and who cares who wins?"

I can understand that they are playing for money, but if money was the issue there more lucrative quiz shows they could appear on, one thousand pounds increase per day is not really a significant amount compared to Millionaire.

The main plot of the program is to win against the best quiz team in the country (I agree with the comments about CJ attitude as a smug little know all when compared to the quality of the rest of the team especially Daphne and Kevin), but to lose gracefully to the Eggheads is also an achievement.

All I can say if you want a quiz program then watch Mastermind or University Challenge, but if you want entrainment mixed with a quiz show with some humour after coming home from work to chill then you would find it hard to beat Eggheads and Anne Robinson quips in the Weakest Link Joe

Sad to see Eggheads cancelled

[glenn-aylett · 8/10 · 2 January 2021]

I know there are too many quiz and game shows in the teatime slots on television, and Eggheads had run its course after 16 years, but the show was a straightforward 30 minute quiz show where pub quiz teams took on a team of expert quizzers, including Millionaire winner Judith Keppel and the eccentric and amusing CJ De Mooi. Unlike the flashing lights, loud music and overbearing hosts om other quiz shows, Eggheads was a straightforward quiz show with no gimmicks and a likeable presenter in the form of Jeremy Vine. I am sad to see it go as it provided a decent alternative to the news and was well liked by the viewers.

Can't be Beaten

[auntiequated · 10/10 · 14 November 2020]

Best program on the TV or at least it was until someone mistakenly thought that Richard Osman could do better. Some of us like to exercise our brain cells and Eggheads provided the ultimate challenge.