"Gunsmoke" Alarm at Pleasant Valley (TV Episode 1956) Poster

(TV Series)

(1956)

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
The Grass Isn't Always Greener
wdavidreynolds16 December 2021
The first season of Gunsmoke closes with an episode highlighting the perils of homesteading in the immediate post-Civil War Midwest. Matt Dillon and Chester Goode are on horseback away from Dodge City. The find an encampment of people that have been killed by marauding Kiowa. While they survey the situation, a U. S. Calvary unit rides onto the scene. The Lieutenant of the unit tells Matt and Chester they are looking for the Kiowa, and they will take care of burying the dead.

Matt and Chester ride on and soon encounter a homestead in a beautiful valley. The people there - the Fraser family - are packing a wagon preparing to leave. The patriarch of the family died recently, and the oldest son, Tad, has decided to move the family to California. He fears trying to survive in a remote area and thinks they can find a better life farther west.

Ma Fraser, Tad's mother, is still grieving the loss of her husband after forty years of marriage. She is openly skeptical of Tad's plans to move away from the place her husband named "Peaceful Valley." To further complicate the situation, Tad's wife, Alice, is very pregnant.

Marshal Dillon tries to convince Tad to stay in the valley. He argues the Frasers are not likely to find a better place, and if they try to traverse the open country between Kansas and California, they are likely to encounter more danger.

The cast of this episode contains several actors known for minor roles. Helen Wallace makes the second of her four Gunsmoke appearances in this story. She portrays Ma Fraser in this story. She had previously appeared as the vengeance-seeking woman that puts a bounty on Matt's head after he kills her husband in self-defense in the episode "Reward for Matt."

Lew Brown makes the first of twenty-one appearances in the series. He plays the Tad Fraser character. Brown often appeared in dramas during the 1950s, '60s, and '70s. He frequently played policemen.

This is the third of four appearances in the series for Dorothy Schuyler. In the previous roles, she played one of the women that work in the Long Branch Saloon with Kitty Russell. She portrays Alice Fraser in this story.

Dan Blocker appears for the first time in the series as the Calvary Lieutenant. He would appear one more time in Season 4. In a couple of years, Blocker would become famous for playing Eric "Hoss" Cartwright on Bonanza.

Writer John Dunkel delivers a fairly standard western script with this story. It provides a look into the challenges faced by homesteaders of the time, but it uses the "cowboys versus Indians" trope without providing any kind of insight into why the renegades are attacking. This isn't a bad episode, but it hardly ranks among the better series installments.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Nice story to end the first season.
kfo949426 May 2013
In the last show of season one we get a story that reminds us that Dodge is getting to be a nice place to settle down and start a family. Yes there will be problems but if you stand up to your problems then everyone can make this land home. And since they already knew that the series was picked up for year two, they leave us with a nice message so that we will keep watching when the new episode start airing.

This really is the simplest of stories as we get a family on the prairie having a rough time. The Indians are on the warpath and the father figure has just died, so the eldest son believes things will be better somewhere else.

Matt and Chester happen to ride in and find that there is discourse among the family members. But when they finally decide to leave the land, they find themselves returning when Indians attack. Now they are going to have to fight just to survive.

There really is not much to this episode but at the end we feel better than when we started watching. A nice story to gets us by till season two begins.
13 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Clippy Cloppy
darbski3 July 2017
Warning: Spoilers
**SPOILERS** I know it sounds corny (or stupid), but I like the theme music; I can remember it from when I was a kid. Just a couple of things to mention, or wonder about. The burning of the wagon was because they wanted to send up a smoke signal? Kinda like reversing iconography, isn't it? Kiowas, like ALL horse culture Indians, were masters of NOT being seen, and yet, here they are, virtually committing suicide by Dillon (I just thought that up). The cavalry is a day late and a dollar short, and Dan Blocker is just WAY TOO fat to be cavalry or mounted infantry. There aren't any babes, and Matt and Chester (the perennial slow burning cinder) had just parked their horses in plain view of any sneaky redskin to get his sticky paws on. Come, ON. Give the Kiowa a little credit, at least. They would've had those horses and been gone before anyone knew they were there.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Home is Where the Dead Are
dougdoepke27 August 2007
Good story concept (John Dunkel) and well-honed script. Frontier family has decided to move west after hardships of homesteading in Kansas. Their move is complicated by a marauding band of Kiowa and a pregnant family member. Dillon and Chester happen by, and encourage them to stay and tough it out, since that's what they'll have to do wherever they settle on the frontier.

Though the real settings are the unmistakably scrubby hills of southern California, the dirt dugout of a farm house helps compensate along with good performances from a no-name cast as the family members. The care-worn grandmother's (Helen Wallace) little graveyard scene with Matt also lends a poignantly authentic note. Good thing for settlers (and the movies) that Indians never learned the military techniques of small-unit tactics. Here, once again, they attack as a mass target that can hardly be missed by defenders with repeating rifles, no less. Look fast for the beloved Dan Blocker of Bonanza fame as the rather thick-headed cavalry officer.
16 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Decent season ender
chchurch3 August 2023
Just a glimpse of Dan Blocker makes this a treat. He will star in Bonanza three years later in 1959. However, I note this last episode from season one, number 39, aired on Aug 25, 1956. The first episode aired in early Sep of 1955. How did nine months of episodes stretch to almost an entire year? Did they take a break in November and December?

In the 1950s and 1960s half hour shows usually aired 39 episodes, a full nine months worth. Hour long shows more typically did thirty episodes a season which would fill up about seven months. By the 70s and 80s a full season of half hour shows was 24 shows. I guess deflation is the best description for television output.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Sometimes Less is More, even Plenty. (Oh, and Welcome Back, Dear Reader!)
redryan6429 December 2010
Warning: Spoilers
WE RECENTLY VIEWED this half hour GUNSMOKE Episode on the all classic TV Station, WWME,or "METV" as it is popularly called. It is one of those early episodes from the first or second season, long unseen on the Television Rerun scene; owing to its half hour length and black & white filming.

ALTHOUGH WE ARE reasonably certain that we saw this when it was originally aired, we now view it and make certain observations that were unheard of on those happy, quiet and uncomplicated days by the then 10 year old viewer, namely me!

THIS EPISODE, ALONG with all of the other half hour GUNSMOKES were packaged, given a rather innocuous theme, instead of the very familiar "Gunsmoke Theme". This music had served the series so well on both the first run Saturday evening installments and on the GUNSMOKE Radio Show. The one final highly observable concession to render the half hours more salable was the rechristening of the reruns with a new moniker.

THIS PRACTICE HAD already been in use for several years by both NBC and CBS and others; CBS being GUNSMOKE'S copyright owner and producer. Hence, we saw such title transformations as "DRAGNET" to "BADGE 714", "THE LINE-UP" to "SAN FRANCISCO BEAT" and "MAN AGAINST CRIME" to "FOLLOW THAT MAN"; all done in order to make the old episodes more attractive in syndication.

OUR OLD EPISODES of "GUNSMOKE" thus became MSARSHALL DILLON" and were dispatched far and wide; bringing local station managers suitable and familiar faces and characters in series that would be inexpensive and profitable to the local station's efforts to stay in the black ink.

AS FOR THIS show, titled, "Alarm at Pleasant Valley", the half hour installment packs a lot of storyline and action into its alloted half hour. This has been true of all of those "MARSHALL DILLONS" which we have seen recently; and is certainly a positive overall quality exists that runs throughout these 30 minute dramas.

REGARDING THE PARTICULARS of this episode, the writers manage to bring us a story with Matt (James Arness) and Chester (Dennis Weaver) returning on their way to Dodge City, when they run into the aftermath of a raid on a ranch; which had been the work of a band of outlaw, hostile Indians. They also meet up with a unit of Cavalry, commanded by a Lieutennant (Dan Blocker-the future Hoss Cartwright, himself!)

THE PLOT LINE manages to weave so much into this half hour, that we found ourselves checking with our trusty Mickey Mousewatch to see if it had been actually been a full hour's worth of story. They even managed to throw in enough twists, turns and suspense to make us wonder if the Cavalry were actually bogus; being renegades who also impersonated Indians. (Possible Spoiler: They weren't!!)

THIS EPISODE, ALONG with the rest of the GUNSMOKE Body of Work that falls under the umbrella of MARSHALL DILLON, is truly a fine example of the finest in series drama; also being the type of TV which we should see a lot more of coming out of Tinsel Town and the Big Apple.

CONTRAST THIS WITH so much of the watered down and padded work that passes for an hours' worth of televising.

NOTE: We have been remiss in our writing duties, but Schulz and I both promise to be much more prolific with our time at the old typewriter during 2011.

And here's wishing You and all of Our Loyal Readers.............. A Very MERRY Christmas and a HAPPY NEW YEAR!!

.
4 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
It's A Tough Life Warning: Spoilers
"Alarm At Pleasant Valley" was first aired on television August 25, 1956.

(*Marshal Dillon quote*) - "A man with a family out here has gotta be prepared."

Anyway - As the story goes - When his wife goes into labor, a settler is forced to fight the renegades who have murdered several homesteaders.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed