"The Lucy-Desi Comedy Hour" Milton Berle Hides at the Ricardos (TV Episode 1959) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Lucy gets in on the celebrity bandwagon again, much to their detriment.
mark.waltz22 January 2016
Warning: Spoilers
Desperate to get Milton Berle to perform in their PTA production (much like Tallulah Bankhead in "The Celebrity Next Door"), Lucy visits him at his New York office and manages to convince him to come out to Connecticut to finish his latest book in peace where nobody will interrupt him. But of course, Ricky forbids such a plot, knowing that Lucy's machinations would cost him getting a gig as a bandleader on Uncle Miltie's T.V. show. So Lucy does it on the sly, hiding Milton even from Fred and Ethel. But once Ethel maneuvers her way in, the naive Fred tells Ricky that Lucy's been hiding a man on a daily basis, and the jealous Ricky socks the unknowing Fred Keating, who happens to be Milton's publisher. Milton ends up in drag thanks to Lucy's attempts to get him out of the house, but when his wig falls off, Ricky (still not knowing who the man is) slugs him, and Lucy's attempts to get him to appear in the PTA play seems shot. She tries one last ploy, coming up in a cement lifter, and ultimately creating a stunt gag that would have every silent comic envious that they hadn't thought of it first, with Milton hanging onto the cement lifter, Lucy hanging onto his legs, and ultimately Ricky hanging onto his wife's legs.

That sketch alone is worth the price of admission, but the plot takes time to get rolling before the hilarity really starts. The concluding musical number is an almost disaster, pretty much totally unfunny, with only Ethel as a saloon girl and Fred as the lovable old bartender really making any impact. Little Ricky makes a cameo as the sheriff, with Uncle Miltie as the bandit, Lucy as a Native American maiden (a performance that might be considered offensive to some), and poor Ricky locked up behind the horse's costume. It reminds me of those novelty numbers shoved into sitcoms of the 1960's that were instantly dated. While Lucy and Ricky had some great musical moments on "I Love Lucy", this is perhaps the weakest of the bunch. Still, with the cement truck sketch, watching the three of them hanging onto each other 24 stories above ground, that sequence alone is a total classic.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
This is one of the weakest of the Lucy-Desi Comedy Hours
mgmstar12828 July 2020
Warning: Spoilers
I have watched all the episodes of the original I Love Lucy series and the 13 Lucy-Desi Comedy Hour episodes. At its zenith, I Love Lucy was brilliant. That's why we still watch and laugh at the series decades later. However, the show worked better with its half hour format, instead of stretching it out to an hour. Like The Twilight Zone, it was better when it was thirty minutes, not sixty. Adding extra minutes just seemed like extra padding.

The episode starts off well enough with Lucy trying to figure out a way to get Milton Berle to host a P.T.A. benefit. However, instead of telling Ethel, her best friend and partner in crime, that Milton is hiding out there finishing up his latest book during the day, the viewer has to watch Lucy smoking Havana cigars and demonstrating her masculine fashion sense wearing Milton's hat and overcoat in an attempt to fool Ethel that the cigar and clothes belong to Lucy. Even in 1959, I don't think this sequence was funny to audiences.

Then halfway through the episode, a sequence where Lucy, Ricky, and Milton are swinging hundreds of feet off the ground from a skyscraper in the air is ridiculous. The obvious use of body doubles in certain shots makes the sequence boring and tedious. I found it more uninspired and predictable than funny.

Watching this episode made me think how the show had reached its time to come to an end. The writers, as wonderful as they were, really had probably exhausted most of the plot lines that they could have come up with for Lucy's antics. What could have been a great episode with Milton Berle was rather mediocre at best.

At the end, there is musical sequence for the P.T.A. benefit which is pleasant but not very memorable. As a previous reviewer stated in these more politically correct days, some might be offended by Lucy playing an Indian squaw.

So, in the end, this episode, to me, was one of the weaker installments, despite its having Milton Berle as its guest star.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed