- Sister Meg Costello: [she and Father Vale are sitting in Joe's office, talking to him about the man who visited her before he died] I told Father Fain that I had to do something. That poor dying man haunts me. He was trying to erase his sin against this other man- an innocent man that he had put in prison. With his last dying breath, he was trying to tell me the man's name.
- Father Vale: What do you think, Joe?
- Joe Mannix: I don't know. It's not going to to be easy to find the man. I mean, I've never talked to a convict who wasn't innocent.
- Sister Meg Costello: Mr. Mannix, Al Murphy was a dying man. He was pleading his guilt before God. He was saying that he had sinned, that he had borne false witness.
- Joe Mannix: I understand, Sister. I was only trying to warn you. The odds against finding that particular innocent man are a little frightening.
- Sister Meg Costello: But you will try?
- Joe Mannix: Uh, please don't expect a miracle.
- Father Vale: Joe, we're always expecting miracles. That's our bag.
- Joe Mannix: Yeah. You proved that on a golf course.
- Lyle Grandt: As a matter of fact, Sister, I remember Mr. Murphy very well.
- Sister Meg Costello: Then his testimony at the Kilgore trial was a decisive factor?
- Lyle Grandt: No. I'm sorry.
- Joe Mannix: What convinced you that Kilgore was guilty, Mr. Grandt?
- Lyle Grandt: Well, my client himself. He made a full confession to the police and refused to retract a word of it. I took all the delays I could reasonably ask of the court, hoping he'd change his mind, but he didn't. Believe me, it was a battle all the way. Even to convince him that he had to make an initial plea of innocence so that we could see the prosecution's case.
- Sister Meg Costello: Are you saying that you had doubts about Mr. Kilgore's confession?
- Lyle Grandt: No, Sister. I believed it. But an attorney has a special obligation to a client. Not to turn the guilty loose on society, but to be certain that the person standing trial has every opportunity to present mitigating circumstances.
- Joe Mannix: In other words, you were hoping that during the prosecution's presentation, something would want to make Kilgore fight for his life?
- Lyle Grandt: Yes, I was. However, that wasn't to be. Poor Kilgore. Imagine his temptation. Not only was Alyce Taggart a devastatingly beautiful woman, she was the wife of the world's wealthiest enigma - C.W. Taggart, man or myth? Kilgore's love affair was... a secret within a mystery. The danger alone... exciting.
- [sighs]
- Lyle Grandt: I'm really sorry, Sister.
- Sister Meg Costello: That's all right. I... I think I understand.
- Lyle Grandt: Well, it comes down to this. Kilgore went into his trial wanting the gas chamber. At least I was able to talk him out of that.
- Joe Mannix: Well, I guess that about covers it. You agree, Sister?
- Sister Meg Costello: Yes, I suppose so.
- Joe Mannix: Thank you for your time, Mr. Grandt.
- Lyle Grandt: Not at all.
- Sister Meg Costello: Yes. You've been most considerate.
- Lyle Grandt: My pleasure.