"McHale's Navy" It's a Mad, Mad, Mad War (TV Episode 1964) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
4/10
Movie spoof that fails
FlushingCaps13 February 2010
Warning: Spoilers
This episode was sort of a spoof of the hit movie It's a Mad, Mad, Mad, Mad World. Except Mr. Parker was too stupid in this show, greatly weakening the plot.

While Chuck is minding the boat alone in New Caledonia, with the crew given four hours leave by McHale (against Binghamton's orders) while McHale attends a conference, he gets a radio call from the Captain directing him and the men to pick up the base pay of $62,000.

Not knowing Binghamton plans on the crew stealing the money, as his latest plan to get rid of McHale and crew, Chuck picks up the money by himself, but panics when soldiers in town fire off the town cannon. He knocks himself out, and when he comes to, the money is gone.

All he can tell the crew is that the girl he saw when waking up has a heart-shaped birthmark on her ankle. The rest of the episode features the crew, in groups, running all around town looking for that birthmark. Binghamton and Carpy fly to New Caledonia to nab our heroes. They wind up chasing the boys, who find the girl and her male accomplice and chase them, with the guy finally hiding the money in that same cannon.

During an air raid, Chuck lights the fuse in the cannon, not knowing what is inside the barrel, and after the Japanese plane leaves, the cannon goes off and all the money floats back to the crew, just as Binghamton has arrested them all for grand theft.

This episode, to me, is ruined by Parker's blundering. I love Tim Conway, even liked some of his later, short-lived series that nobody else liked. Most of his blundering on this series was a big part of what made the show so hilarious. But in this episode, he was too dumb, at least for me.

Panicking on hearing the cannon, the way he knocked himself out was ridiculous, leaping over a park bench when he could easily have run around it. On coming to, there were several people around, one holding an overcoat over his arms. Of course, the bag of money was right under the coat and any normal person would have insisted on looking there.

During the chase, Chuck stumbles into the man, not only failing to recognize him, but he stoops to pick up the very bag of money he is seeking, and gives it back to the crook, never realizing what he is doing.

Right at the start, I thought he should have either waited, or gone to round up some of the crew to go with him to pick up the money. It didn't make sense to carry that much money around by himself.

McHale's Navy is one of the best series ever, but this episode relied too much on stupidity of one person to be one of the good episodes.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
This episode was painful to watch.
kfo949411 November 2014
After watching, this is going to be a difficult episode to review. The story could have been so entertaining but the writers inserted so much blundering antics that by the end of the show it became sad to watch. It felt like getting an early Christmas present only to find that the gift box contained underwear. What a disappointment.

The plot began when Binghamton gets a wire saying that the base payroll needs to be picked-up at the payroll unit in New Caledonia. It just so happens that the PT 73 is in New Caledonia for a conference but Binghamton believes that the crew of the 73 would somehow screw up the payroll and refuses for them to get the money. But after re-thinking, he lets them receive the payroll money hoping they mishandle the transaction and he will be rid of them for the rest of the war.

Of course, Ensign Parker gets the call to pick up the payroll. But on the way back to the boat, Parker loses the money and now the entire crew is out looking for the only evidence in the situation which happens to be a birthmark. Binghamton already has word something is amiss and is on his way to New Caledonia to arrest the crew for stealing the payroll. Unless the money turns up, the crew could be facing prison.

This makes the show sound like an interesting offering that could have been a heck of a show- and yes it could have been. But the writers made the character of Ensign Parker so much of a dufus that it was painful to watch. It was not so bad when Parker pulled a gun on a bush, nor was it so bad when heard a noise and ran around until he knocked himself out over a stationary park bench, but when he gave the money back to the crook that he was chasing (did not even recognize the person) it became so painful you just have to turn away. But it did not even end there. There is so much obnoxious behavior that the show was ruined. Tim Conway is an excellent comedic actor but sometime less is more. This time 'more' was utterly ridiculous.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed