"Murder, She Wrote" For Whom the Ball Tolls (TV Episode 1993) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
"It's a Dutiful Day in this Neighborhood, a Neighborly Day for Gunfire Would"
WeatherViolet11 December 2009
Real Estate Developer Walter Gillrich (Robert Pine) and his brother and partner Eugene Gillrich (Kevin Kilner) acquire an historic New York City brownstone apartment building, which they propose to demolish to construct a modern complex in the event that they manage to purchase the neighboring building containing a tavern. Upon receiving many protests, Walter considers other possible locations to construct the complex, while Eugene and his wife, Lee Gillrich (Susan Walters) firmly intend to proceed with the demolition.

Nolan Walsh (Jeff Conaway) owns the tavern next door to the brownstone, he refusing to sell to the Gillrich firm, while enlisting staunch heavy-handed supporters, as Victor 'Vic' Barton (Alex Courtney) and Mike LaRocca (Ray Abruzzo).

Carol Collins (Barbara Babcock) presides over an historic preservation committee to enlist supporters, as Margaret Johnson (Hallie Foote) and Nurse Josie Miles (Lela Ivey), to retain the status quo. After all, Ernest Hemingway once rented a small suite at the brownstone to author manuscripts toward his future literary classics, such as "For Whom the Bell Tolls."

But in this case, the question on everyone's mind seems to be "For Whom the (Wrecking) Ball Tolls," so, while Carol holds a fund-raising benefit, Margaret enlists the assistance of her dear friend Jessica Fletcher (Angela Lansbury) to resist the intent of demolition. After all, J.B. Fletcher has become by now a famous author in her own right.

Jessica makes the rounds, discovering that understanding landlord Walther Gillrich has instituted the policy that tenants' rent rates never be raised during their stay. But an elderly lady leasing a fourth-floor apartment has neither been seen nor heard from after four years' time except by care-taking Nurse Josie Miles, who also handles her mail deliveries.

Meanwhile, over at the tavern next door, altercations constantly erupt among Nolan Walsh, his heavies and the brothers Gillrich.

Young married brother, Eugene Gillrich, schemes to romance Carol Collins in an attempt to dissuade her civic organization's efforts, to the dismay of her partner, Margaret, and his wife, Lee.

But when a body is discovered in an office, Jessica joins forces with NYPD Lieutenant Artie Gelber(Herb Edelman) and his capable assistant, NYPD Detective Henderson (Leonard Lightfoot), to derive differing theories as to the identity of the intended victim, after chairs have been moved around from one office into another.

So, after the authorities naturally arrest the wrong suspect, Jessica intends to steer them correctly, while actively participating in the historic preservation effort.

During a conversation with Nurse Josie about the missing elderly tenant, Jessica receives a sudden burst of logic regarding a parking space in front of the tavern, to realize the identity of the perpetrator of the gunfire slaying has to be, "For Whom the Ball Tolls."

The cast is rounded out by John Dennis as Pete, Jodi Russell as Peggy, Lisa Dinkins as Female Reporter, Wendy Hoffman as Evelyn, Walter's Secretary, and Alexander Folk as Al, the Mailman.

This episode marks the sixth of ten "MSW" guest star appearances by Herb Edelman, including this among his last seven as NYPD Lieutenant Artie Gelber, the first of five appearances by Leonard Lightfoot as NYPD Detective Henderson, the third of five guest star appearances by Robert Pine (differing roles), the fifth of five guest star roles by Barbara Babcock (differing roles), the third of four by Jeff Conaway, including his first two as Howard Griffin, the husband of Jessica's niece Victoria, the seventh of seven "MSW" supporting appearances by Alexander Folk (differing roles), the second "MSW" episode each for Lela Ivey, Hallie Foote and Kevin Kilner, as well as the only television role thus far by John Dennis (XII). Herb Edelman has since passed.
10 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A quality mystery.
Sleepin_Dragon6 May 2023
The Gillrich brothers plan to have a Brownstone building demolished to build a fancy set of apartments, but they face tough opposition from a Preservation society, including Jessica. One of the brothers is murdered, Jessica is in the case.

What a thoroughly rewarding episode this is, I really did enjoy it. A very pleasing mystery, with good characters, and a really interesting storyline. I still associate this era with ruthless businessmen, and this episode doesn't disappoint. Expect dodgy dealings, ruthless businessmen, duplicitous do gooders and china tigers.

There are definitely a couple of clues to look out for, you really can piece the mystery together, and work out the identity of the killer.

Very well produced, this episode looks terrific, as do all of the later episodes.

Always great to see Herb Edelman, we'll be seeing more of him this series.

Enjoyed this one.

8/10.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Melancholy ending
xbatgirl-3002916 September 2022
Warning: Spoilers
This episode was pretty solid relative to the rest of these later seasons, although the ending left me a bit sad. Hallie Foote and Robert Pine were so well cast and cute together, the moment it was obvious their characters liked each other, I wanted them to end up a couple. Him in his bow tie and well worn jackets. Her playing the quiet, skilled assistant. I didn't see it coming that their happy ending was not to be. Perhaps it feels unsettling because of a lack of closure, since we never get to witness much reaction at the end from Margaret, who must have been devastated.

Per TV mystery tropes, it did seem the brother would be the victim. Although once the deed is done, the killer's motive is pretty obvious, since Walter was against destroying the building and stood in Eugene's way. There are couple other obvious clues early on about certain other plot points, especially if you know NYC's housing market, but the exact identity of the killer and how it was done were good twists. Additionally, I liked that Eugene was truly shaken by the loss of his brother. Too often on tv, the trope is that when families are bickering over large amounts of money, they also feel no love for each other and don't mourn their losses. (Not that I'm on the side of millionaire developers)

I could have done without the corrupt, unethical Geraldo knock off. I guess the writers wanted to have another red herring swimming around. He never is a serious suspect and so is just an annoyance. On the other hand, part of me got a real kick out of how mercenary and sex positive Barbara Babcock's character was revealed to be. Very progressive for 1993. I also continue to enjoy the relationship Jessica has with Lieutenant Gelber. He's no Mort or Amos, but I like when local police aren't constantly yelling at the main character about being annoying and underfoot. After all this time and all the mysteries Jessica has solved, the police would have to be blockheads to underestimate her.

The show's not the same when it's not based in Cabot Cove. But after a pretty dismal season 9, this feels a bit more like the MSW we all love.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Death in the brownstone
TheLittleSongbird9 November 2017
Have always been quite fond of 'Murder She Wrote'. It is a fun and relaxing watch that makes you think as you try to unwind in the evening. If one wants more complex, twisty mysteries with lots of tension and suspense 'Murder She Wrote' may not be for you, but if you want something light-hearted and entertaining but still provide good mysteries 'Murder She Wrote' fits the bill just fine.

When it comes to Season 10 episodes (it's only the second episode of the season and it's already a much higher standard than the very shaky start Season 9 had), "For Whom the Ball Tolls" in terms of the guest cast and the entertainment value is towards the top. Its mystery generally is a good one where one believes one thing initially and then it's revealed cleverly that it was something completely different. There's not a whole lot wrong really, though for my taste while the identity of the killer was surprising the denouement was a little vague and not as clear as it could have been.

Angela Lansbury is spot on as Jessica, as is Herb Edelman. Their chemistry is both tense and charming. The acting is well done with no real weak links, even Jeff Conaway is not bad (he was in his Howard Griffin appearances). Barbara Babcock, Hallie Foote, Robert Pine and Kevin Kilner are particularly strong and just seeing the cast having a good time is reason enough to see the episode. Ray Abruzzo and Susan Walters hold their own too amongst the large group of recurring guest stars.

The mystery, as aforementioned, is very nicely done despite reservations for the ending. It's not a dull one and it's neither simplistic or confusing.

Production values are slick and stylish and the setting and scenery looks beautiful. The music has energy and has presence but also not making the mistake of over-scoring, while it is hard to forget or resist the theme tune. Writing is thoughtful and amiable.

In conclusion, well done episode. 8/10 Bethany Cox
4 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
This one surprised me.
planktonrules26 July 2023
When the show begins, you learn that a building near Jessica's apartment in New York City is possibly going to be demolished. However, a group of locals are trying to stop this, as the place apparently has some historical significance. However, everything grinds to a halt when a man is found murdered...and Jessica, naturally, investigates.

Most of the time, it's not all that difficult to figure out who committed the murders in "Murder, She Wrote". However, here the identity of the killer that wasn't obvious...which I really appreciate. Additionally, the show is entertaining and well worth seeing.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
For whom the ball tolls
coltras3518 March 2023
Jessica and an old friend investigate the mysterious death of the owner of three brownstone buildings in New York. The city's on-street parking laws provide Jessica with the key to solving the case.

Standard MSW episode with some good suspects, a nice cast featuring the Grease actor Jeff Conaway, and a nice build-up to the murder, though expect this character to become a victim. I thought it would be his ambitious brother who is determined to demolish brownstone buildings, and has no doubt rubbed people the wrong way. It's an entertaining episode, and ends typically and satisfactory with Jessica getting that eureka moment that helps her nail the murderer.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Ernie parked here
bkoganbing4 February 2019
This episode is probably most beloved in my city of Buffalo where preservation is practically a religion. In this episode JB Fletcher is joining her friend Hallie Foote in preserving a brownstone where rumor hath it Ernest Hemingway once resided. There's a local bar on the ground floor where it is said that the bodies of several victims of Dutch Schultz were buried that is owned by Jeff Conaway.

A building like that must be saved, but not if developer Robert Pine has his way. When he's shot to death there as in my city there are a host of suspects.

Sometimes there's a lot of good housing stock destroyed for greed's sake. There are also a lot of buildings that cost more to repair than build anew.

As for historic value, the famous White Horse Tavern in Greenwich Village will never get torn down and the bar in the story is clearly based on that. It was not a prohibition era slaughterhouse, but rather the ghost of the famous poet Dylan Thomas is seen there. It was his favorite watering hole.

I'm not sure you'll solve this one so readily.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed