"12 O'Clock High" The Hotshot (TV Episode 1965) Poster

(TV Series)

(1965)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Some folks just are lone wolves and not team players...the Lt. Colonel is one of them.
planktonrules4 September 2021
Up until this episode, you never saw fighter escorts for the B-17s on the show. Well, there were.... P-38s and P-47s did such duty BUT had limited range so that they couldn't follow the bombers during their entire mission. As a result, they were left unprotected and lost many bombers. Later in the war, the P-51 Mustang was the first fighter with a range long enough to escort the bombers completely. This episode is about the beginnings of such combined missions.

The General had designated that Colonel Gallagher and Lt. Colonel Troper (Warren Oates) work together to formulate tactics and coordinate the bomber/fighter combined missions. However, early on it becomes apparent that although Troper is talented, he's not exactly a team player and the sees little value in working with bomber crews. Regardless, it's the mission and orders are orders. But again and again, Troper is insubordinate and tries his best to make his fighter pilots equally resentful of the bombers. Will he succeed or will Gallagher put Troper in his place? Or, is there some other possible option?

This is a very good episode of "12 O'Clock High". I am sure some fighter pilot did resent having to guard bombers instead of racking up more victories by flying fighter-only missions. My only complaint is a common one for me....the P-51 Mustangs they showed in the episode were the wrong model. The early Mustanges had a swept back canopy and only the later D models sported the bubble canopy you see in most of the show. I say MOST because in one scene, a P-51B becomes a P-51D in mid-flight due to a sloppy use of stock footage. Although they both were Mustangs, the planes really did look radically different. Still, only nutty history lovers like me would probably notice!
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Episode belongs to Warren Oates
Guad4224 August 2023
Warning: Spoilers
If a show has an episode of conflict between the hero and a villain, the villain needs to be good in the role. Fortunately, Warren Oates was made for such roles. As Lt Col Troper, he understands his orders but doesn't agree with them so is largely on his own agenda. He comes across as a rebel who is successful at his job so others follow him. A clash with the tightly wrapped Gallagher was inevitable. Of course, Troper is winning at first but Gallagher gets Troper's pilots to see the light and the new method of operations is proven successful. A sequel episode would have been interesting.

This episode was preceded by an outing with Jack Lord as Gallagher's brother. Lord had a series named Stoney Burke a few years earlier and Oates played his sidekick in that series. Coincidence of course but I thought I would mention it.

Warren Oates had a great career cut short by his untimely death at 53. He went back and forth between TV and movies and was a favorite of Sam Peckinpah who used him a lot and gave him lead roles. Many character/supporting actors suffer from "I know the face but not the name" syndrome. You definitely knew who Warren Oates was. He stands out in every scene regardless of the movie or TV show. He reminds me of Strother Martin in that regard. It's a shame he never got a role that would have gotten him a best supporting actor nomination for an Oscar. When you look at actors who did get nominated from that era, you see names like Nick Adams, Richard Jaeckel, Mako, Ben Johnson, and Robert Stack. Johnson even won for "Last Picture Show". There are others so Oates would have fit right in with no problem. So would have Strother Martin. Alas, it was not to be. Too bad. Maybe the role would have happened if Oates had just lived longer.

This is a good episode. Do see it.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed