"The Twilight Zone" Night of the Meek/But Can She Type?/The Star (TV Episode 1985) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
The Twilight Zone - But Can She Type!
Scarecrow-8827 August 2016
Warning: Spoilers
"Night of the Meek" is a remake from the wonderful 60s episode featuring Art Carney as a drunkard department store Santa - riddled with misery because the poor kids were not fortunate enough to receive the same gifts as the more blessed ones - who is allowed this magic bag that produces presents to those less fortunate. Casting that part which is identified so closely to Carney couldn't have been easy, but Richard Mulligan (I adore this actor; watched him every week on "Empty Nest" growing up) fit the bill wonderfully. His Henry Corwin, with such a giving heart but lacking in gainful employment, is given the opportunity to slip into the *real* Santa persona and opens the magic bag to all those folks who are often not so regarded by economic advantage. Mulligan is so appealing, I think his performance would bring a smile to the face of the most miserable Grinch among us. This 80s updating follows quite closely in spirit to the Carney version, with only the time it is set breaking from the familiar. William Atherton was always rather typecast as an asshole (he just did that so well), but this updating gives him a reprieve when he attempts to have Mulligan arrested for supposedly stealing gifts from his store and later realizes that the spirit of Christmas even has something special for him. Mulligan's only desire is to give to others so the Twilight Zone does him even better by allowing him to do just that. Good for Yuletide viewing, I think this update won't necessarily have you forgetting about the Carney version but it doesn't do it a disservice, either. 8/10

"Type" has the always delightful Pan Dawber (right before My Sister Sam) as a disrespected secretary stuck at work on Christmas Eve because of her unorganized jerk of a boss. Through the magic of a copy machine (!) Pam is teleported to a similar world, but one where the secretary is revered and a desired profession! She goes to a classy party with upscale folks attending and Pam is the admired arrival! Jonathan Frakes of Star Trek: The Next Generation is an attendee interested in her and Pam even receives a job promotion. Returning back accidentally to her own world leaves much to be desired so she hopes to return back to where she is more appreciated. Fun, imaginative premise with Pam representing all those secretaries mistreated over the years; Charles Levin is typical ungrateful dick calling her "kind" bubble-headed bimbos so we root for her. 6/10

"The Star" has Fritz Weaver and Donald Moffat as space explorers encountering what was once Earth, now resembling an asteroid since the sun went Nova. Weaver, besides a scientist is a Jesuit, and he has spiritual and philosophical discussions regarding God and the design of the universe with Moffit. Weaver's resolve is tested when he realizes that the Nova was best seen where the Star of David was when Christ was born. The effects of the ship, Nova/space, and the sets of the Magellan's bridge and the asteroid "cargo hold" where Earth artifacts are discovered are okay, but the script is more interested in dialogue than of a complex sci-fi story. 5/10. Good duo of actors deserving an entire thirty minute Twilight Zone. Still cool to see Weaver on both the original and revival of the TZ.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
The Star
Cristi_Ciopron25 September 2008
Warning: Spoilers
This episode--namely,THE STAR--was the one I enjoyed most in the whole series.Sir Arthur Charles Clarke used to propose his original takes on some Christian motifs--sometimes,even quite inspired--like The Star (a science fiction short story from '56),Encounter in the Dawn and the novel Childhood's End (1953) .

In THE STAR,the idea is extremely interesting,and well handled.I do not care much about Clarke's opinions as a private person about religion ;his works are worthy of interest.

I have seen this episode when I was 11 yrs..I already knew Clarke's novel aforementioned, and the idea of this short movie I liked even better.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A Classic Retelling/True Human Value/Religious Claptrap
Hitchcoc21 April 2017
I'm giving this one an eight because of "The Night of the Meek." The Art Carney version is superior, but this one still ignites the screen. A man who drinks too much works as a store Santa. When he destroys the Santa set, he is fired on Christmas Eve. Suddenly, what appears to be a large garbage bag takes on major powers. The second part is about a secretary, played by Pam Dawber (Mindy from Mark and Mindy). She is harassed by her boss and treated as a second class employee, under the gun at every turn. Then, one night as she makes copies, something happens to change her life. Finally, an utterly worthless, trite effort, not worthy of this series.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Nackles was nackled
safenoe17 December 2016
Warning: Spoilers
Night of the Meek/But Can She Type?/The Star is interesting because it was supposed to be Night of the Meek/Nackles/The Star. Nackles? What on the earth is Nackles? Nackles was a New Twilight Zone instalment ready to shoot until CBS expressed nervousness (and rightfully so) about elements of the Nackles script.

Ed Asner's character in Nackles was creating an anti-Santa Clause to scare minority kids, and in a comeuppance, it turns out the anti-Santa Clause is black! Oh dear. What surprised me was the surprise the New Twilight Zone folk had towards CBS's decision to pull the plug from Nackles. However if the Nackles script had a Nazi Santa Clause as comeuppance then maybe this would have been greenlighted.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Nice little Christmas treat with Night of the Meek!
blanbrn29 December 2006
This 1985 episode is special for it's episode "Night of the Meek" which is actually a remake of an original episode with Art Carney. This time around you have veteran Richard Mulligan who plays a lonely and depressed drunken Santa who works for a cruel store manager. After being fired this Santa receives a bit of Christmas magic and a miracle, a magical bag of gifts for the most needy and poor! A night to remember, certainly one of the best Twilight episodes ever because it brings good joy, and it was only fitting this episode aired right before Christmas in 1985 and Richard Mulligan done such a great job as Santa! The second little piece is nothing special, but just a glance into the future and it showed how technology came to help us! It stars Pam Dawber as an overworked and under-appreciated secretary who finds that magic can come from a copy machine and help with work! And finally the third story involves a space tale which is dull in my opinion with genre sci-fi legend Fritz Weaver as a space explorer who discovers an old planet. Really just watch this episode for the first story "Night of the Meek" it's heart touching and well done with Richard Mulligan, especially watch it at Christmas. This episode is available on the season 1 set of the 1985 series.
16 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Good storytelling
gritfrombray-14 May 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Enjoyed Night Of The Meek and it was a wonderful story with an impressive cast. Definitely one for Christmas viewing. The second was an uplifting tale of a pushed around secretary who'd just had enough of her boss and of what life had to offer, with a very early role for Star Trek The Next Gen's Jonathan Frakes! But I was intrigued by the last, based on a premise by the legendary Arthur C. Clarke. It was about a people who'd been consumed by the fires of their dying sun. They made it clear in their scriptures that they knew their death was lighting the way for a new world to be born and enlightened. The strange thing was, this occurred at the same time as it took for the light of their passing to appear in the sky above a small town in the Judean hills. Jerasalem, where the young child lay in the form of the beginning of a new world. Brilliant idea. One of the more intriguing of all the '80s show.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Heartwarming Christmas fable
Leofwine_draca26 April 2015
For this Christmas-aired episode of THE NEW TWILIGHT ZONE, viewers were treated to NIGHT OF THE MEEK, a heartwarming tale in which a department store Santa discovers the true meaning of Christmas. The tale, which is apparently a remake of an episode from the original series, sees a down-on-his-luck Santa Claus bemoaning the lack of gifts for poor children, only to be visited by a magical ability to give them the very best presents.

The episode is notable for the appearance of William Atherton, playing EXACTLY the same jerk character as he did in GHOSTBUSTERS and DIE HARD. Atherton is a hoot as the snooty boss, as always, although the twist ending sees his character thaw a little, which is great. Overall this isn't a particularly fantastic story and I usually hate the sentimental stuff, but NIGHT OF THE MEEK isn't bad at all.

The two following segments of the episode are less impressive. BUT CAN SHE TYPE? tells the story of a put-upon secretary who finds herself teleported to a remote planet where typists are venerated for their skill and prowess. It's all done as a humorous fantasy, probably to appeal to low-skilled workers stuck in similar professions, but it's very slight.

The final segment, THE STAR, actually has a huge back story about a dying planet and an exploding star. Unfortunately, the budget is so limited that the whole thing consists of two men standing in front of a screen and talking. It's not like the dialogue is Oscar worthy either; in this instance, it's a bore.
6 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Review of "The Star".
fedor821 May 2022
Warning: Spoilers
This episode was an excuse to pit a Christian against an atheist, but to have them argue in a friendly banter - as opposed to how these things usually play out in real life.

The plot-twist regarding the birth of Christ is a bit laughable. No matter how you spin or twist it or rationalize it, there is no justification in an entire advanced civilization getting wiped out for no good reason, randomly and brutally. The implication that they were "making space" for the birth of a new one - ours - is not only bird-brained because of the vastness of the universe in which trillions of civilizations can co-exist without in any way impeding one another, but the mere suggestion that humans were worth sacrificing a far more advanced species for... is just moronic.
1 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed