Josh receives a letter from a girl at the St. Elizabeth Home for Young Ladies. Expecting a young woman, Josh finds a young orphan girl wanting him to find the parents she insists are still alive and with whom she yearns to be reunited.
Josh arrives at the St. Elizabeth Home for Girls based on a letter he received expecting to meet a young woman name Dolly Cleary. Sister Clavina introduces Dolly who turns out to a young girl who tells Josh she wants him to find her parents because she knows they are alive. Sister Clavina asks Dolly to wait outside and then explains to Josh that Dolly receives an unmarked package every so often but she believes Dolly is better off to assume her parents are dead. Josh tries to leave without seeing Dolly but she catches him outside and the soft hearted Josh can't refuse her request. With no clues he turns to Craig the bartender who knows no Clearys but calls over old timer Hardrock Johnson who recognizes the name. The father Matt is alive but a drunk who left Dolly at the school after her mother was killed in a buggy accident due to his drinking. Josh decides to visit Matt Cleary but finds a large obstacle besides the fact that Matt is a drunk and unfit father.—Anonymous