The Rival (TV Movie 2006) Poster

(2006 TV Movie)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Crazy as a loon
caa82123 May 2007
Tracy Nelson's character is nuttier than the proverbial fruitcake. Of course, these Lifetime flicks largely rely upon a whacked-out lead character who makes others miserable, commits mayhem and murder, and provides a dark shroud which largely dominates the story.

Tracy and her hubby need a surrogate, and finally find one who suits them and is willing to live in their spacious house during the nine-month pregnancy. Tracy seems to be obsessed with this live-in arrangement, and then makes everyone miserable with her jealousies, and the musings of her aunt, who is as crazy and sociopathic as she is. She offs Auntie, as well as her therapist, who becomes suspicious -- but the aunt continues to push her even further into total lunacy from the dreams and visions which appear throughout.

As par for these flicks, the husband, while apparently a successful and authoritative businessman, schleps around like he has doubled his dose of downers, and as perceptively as if he possessed an IQ in two digits.

All-in-all, it's hard to care an iota about any of these folks, and Tracy's paranoiac and bipolar rantings, interspersed with whiny pleadings, are about as annoying as anything ever put on film. The rest of the cast does little or nothing to lessen this annoyance. In fact, the aunt only compounds it.

The only minor positive aspect in watching this flick was a minimal fascination from its awfulness overall, coupled with watching Tracy and the aunt gnaw the scenery like a bevy of hungry beavers, amidst their thoroughly laconic fellow cast members.
18 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
One of the worst TV movie I've ever seen !
jocedeg2 March 2007
Warning: Spoilers
After an assault, a pregnant woman loses her unborn baby and her soon-to-be-ex husband. Jump 7 years later: she's remarried and trying to find a surrogate mother to finally have a baby.

But this woman is a total nut-case: she has visions of her murdered aunt who tells her to do very bad things.

And she does.

This (totally unbelievable) story of a psycho has more than one problem...

I'll be brief: Bad acting from each of the unknowns cast in this poorly written story... next to zero budget... convoluted story... illogical character development... I've seen daily soaps on American TV with all that, but at least the bad actors in these soaps are kinda attractive.

All in all, a totally horrible viewing experience.

Skip !
7 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Like a long soap opera... Canadian style
randy_kay14 July 2012
Warning: Spoilers
I didn't think much of this film at all. To begin with, it was filmed in Ottawa -- although I must say they did a good job of hiding the fact. BTW, just to get it off my chest, the black cop detective has slicked back hair in a little pony tail, a la Miami Vice circa 1984...uh, producers, 20 years have past since then -- time to wake up.

Tracy Nelson was good at being a clingy annoying nut bar woman who spends the entire film freaking out. She thinks a young hotty surrogate mom her and her hubby have hired to have their brat wants to steal him away. In fact she's so upset at the thought of losing him that she stabs him to death instead. Yep, that's what people who are deeply in love do -- they kill each other -- nice writing there fellas.

Everything falls into place just the way you would expect any boring dumb film to. Honestly, if you watch this piece of &^%$, you'll feel sorry you wasted your time when it ends. I know I did.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Tracy Nelson and Heather Tom, 1, 2 Knockout punch
aocsincher24 September 2020
Gripping from the start to the finish. I was on the edge of my seat the whole time. The story was also very twist filled. An easy 10er.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Not a Good Idea to Bring a Surrogate into Your Home for 9 Months
lavatch26 September 2019
Warning: Spoilers
"The Rival" turns the tables on the film formula about a devious surrogate, who plans a dastardly deed against the parents who are paying for the adoption. In this film, the surrogate is angelic, and the monster is the would-be adopted parent, a woman whose life has been filled with violence in which she is on the giving end more than the receiving.

After an exhaustive search, Alice and her loving husband George finally locate the perfect surrogate, Sarah, who moves in with them during the gestation period. Unbeknownst to both the husband and the surrogate, Alice had set fire to her home at age twelve, murdering her father intentionally. Later, she will kill both her aunt Estelle and her kind shrink, Dr. Linda Zeller.

With Sarah in residence, Alice instantly becomes insanely jealous, convincing herself that George will fall in love with the surrogate and take their baby away from her. Although it is a stock device, Alice has a recurring dream that is dramatized on multiple occasions in the film. While the psychiatrist Dr. Zeller tries hard to understand the dream, she is slow in figuring out all of the symbols pointing to a violent streak in Alice.

Two of the most interesting characters in the film were George and Sarah. Both were patient and devoted to Alice, but incapable of reaching her. The actress playing Alice was convincing in portraying her character's sudden outbursts, especially a show-stopping scene in a swanky Italian restaurant where she confronts Sarah and her cousin Jennifer. The reactions on the patrons' faces were priceless.

The filmmakers began the picture with a scene that led the audience to empathize with Alice, who is shot by an assailant at an ATM machine. At the time, Alice was pregnant with a child from her first husband. She lost both the baby and the husband in the attack. The first husband fatefully told Alice that he would not be a good father and wanted her to raise the child on her own. His realization about his own inadequacies could have equally applied to poor Alice, who desperately wanted to be a mother, but was ill-prepared for the challenge.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed