Hannah Montana (TV Series) I Am Hannah, Hear Me Croak (2007) User Reviews

great

[math_drama · 10/10 · 1 May 2007]

Although Miley recently moved from Tennessee and her mom died three years before, Miley never really shows that she is upset or even cries a little. One might expect it, but Miley never seems to show any emotions; she's always happy. But in the Hannah Montana episode "I am Hannah, Hear me Croak," Miley finally seems to actually remember her mother.

I like how this is the first episode after the third episode in the third season where Miley even seems to remember her mother. When she has the dream about her mom giving her advice, it really shows how she misses her mom. Also, when she watches the old tape of her, her mom, and her dad at Christmas when she was younger, it shows how she misses her mom. And, the last part that shows that Miley missed her mom was when Miley lay down and looked at the picture of her mom.

I think that there should be more Hannah Montana episodes where Miley or Jackson shows that they miss their mom. I mean, I like to write scripts for Hannah Montana, and I wrote one which was all about Jackson missing his mom during his story while Miley and Lilly did something else. Although there are very few episodes about Miley missing her mom or even remember her, "I am Hannah, Hear me Croak" has great quality and really focuses on Miley's life before what happens on the actual show.

Very touching, as well as hilarious

[sandrafahmy · 10/10 · 12 July 2007]

During this episode, Miley loses her voice twice and needs an operation to fix it. This scares her so much, so one night her father brings her some 'hot choco loco' to comfort her.

This makes her whole mind go weird and so she has a dream about her losing her voice forever and being hated by her family and friends. After they leave (in her dream), her Mother visits her.

The following scenes are so touching, because it actually seems like Miley is reunited with her dead Mother, even though it's just a dream. She soon tells Miley that she can change her dream easily, and soon her Dad, Jackson, Lilly and Oliver come back and tell her that they'll love her way after she's Hannah Montana.

The video of the Stewart's Christmas that Miley watches on her laptop was also very sweet as it showed how happy they were, and still are.

The acting in this episode was great, and you can really see how each character has developed from the first few episodes.

Overall, I'd give this episode 10/10 because of the great plot and acting.

Haha! Hilarious!

[stephneko10 · 10/10 · 1 May 2007]

Yes! This is one of the episodes where Oliver has really, REALLY funny lines. I think it's really awesome. The dream part with Brooke Shields didn't interest me the most. It was good but, it could have been better. No offense. I like the song that they sing together in the end. Anyway, Oliver's part is hilarious. Here it is, "Wow! A week without talking. You know that's gotta be tough for a girl, now guys... we're different. I don't need to talk. I could not talk for a month, wouldn't bother me at all but, girls talk, talk, talk, talk, talk. Hey, Sally nice capris. Oh, I love your purse." I re-watch it and re-watch it and re-watch it so much! It's hilarious! You have to see it!

Funny Episode!

[tnr129 · 10/10 · 10 May 2007]

This is a really good episode. It is about how Hannah Montana looses her voice from doing so many encores are a concert. To heal her voice Robby Ray advices not to talk. Miley doesn't talk for a weak. When one week is up she can talk, and she starts singing her new song "Life's What You Make It." She is accompanied by Robby Ray, Oliver, and Lilly. She goes to another concert and looses her voice again. The doctor tells her that the only way for this to stop happening is to have an operation. Miley becomes very scared. One night she has a dream the surgery doesn't go well and shes stuck as a maid, while Jackson is a rock star named Bucky Kentucky. Her mom appears (Brooke Shields) and tells her that everything will be alright. In the end the operation goes fine, and her voice is normal.