Having neither read the books nor seen the original television movies, I come to the series with unbiased (if ignorant) eyes. My wife and I, who lived briefly in Toronto, are both charmed by Murdoch and his slightly daft colleagues. "Charmed" is the word, for we find the actors, scripts, clothing, details and the City of Toronto itself charming. The bigotry faced by a Catholic detective in the city of the Family Compact rings very true as does Murdoch's gentle piety, a refreshing change in today's detective shows. It is a bit mystery, a bit soap opera, a bit character study and a lot of fun. We, at least, have been captivated by William Murdoch as portrayed by Yannick Bisson, a character who is a genuinely honest, gentle and quiet man of strength facing ethical, moral, professional and legal challenges in each episode. George Crabtree and the Inspector become more interesting as time goes on. The corruption of Toronto and Ontario politics hides behind several episodes while the turn of the 20th century fascination with science and "the coming thing", as Brisco County Junior would say, gives some lightness to the whole thing. In the final analysis it is the interplay of characters, centred on the troubled but charming Murdoch himself, that elevates the Murdoch Mysteries to the level of Midsomer, Taggert or Poirot. A fine series and not only for Canadians.
177 Reviews
Very well made and acted Victorian era set Canadian crime series.
WelshFilmCraze4 April 2010
'Murdoch Mysteries' stars Yannick Bisson as Inspector William Murdoch who solves crimes in 1890's Toronto, is an exceptionally well made and acted series, which makes a nice change from CSI/NCIS etc. staple of whiz-bang, FX laden crime shows
Bisson is likable as the handsome Inspector, with English Actor Thomas Craig suitably sceptical and at times dopey as his by-the-book boss and Johnny Craig is good as his rather naive partner and at times hindrance Constable Crabtree.
Helene Joy is suitably understated as the resident Doctor/Pathologist.
Now in its Third series, currently being shown on UK Cable channel ALIBI, (It surely deserves a wider audience on a Major British Channel)
The writing, set design and Photography is exquisite and convincing
Fans of well made and intelligent Mystery Series will find much enjoyment in Inspector Murdoch's cases.
Bisson is likable as the handsome Inspector, with English Actor Thomas Craig suitably sceptical and at times dopey as his by-the-book boss and Johnny Craig is good as his rather naive partner and at times hindrance Constable Crabtree.
Helene Joy is suitably understated as the resident Doctor/Pathologist.
Now in its Third series, currently being shown on UK Cable channel ALIBI, (It surely deserves a wider audience on a Major British Channel)
The writing, set design and Photography is exquisite and convincing
Fans of well made and intelligent Mystery Series will find much enjoyment in Inspector Murdoch's cases.
A fun, yet thoughtful show.
llawrance19729 April 2010
I caught 'The Murdoch Mysteries' by accident while drifting around the satellite channels and was instantly hooked. A well performed, touching and interesting show caught my eye. The characters are involving, are worth caring about and have a strong sense of purpose. Each one brings something to the mix and adds their own skills to the events of each episode. Each episode has a strong mystery to be solved, sometimes offering an intriguing moral dilemma to both Murdoch and the viewer. It is also very reassuring to not have modern day morality thrust into the past as happens so frequently with other shows (yes 'Dr Quinn Medicine Woman', I mean you), dealing with the nineteenth century. Instead we are allowed to explore the world as they see it, enjoying the discoveries and trying to find a way forward into a new century. Well done to all concerned and long may it continue.
Message from 'down under'
janice-lowing28 December 2012
There are so few shows that I thoroughly enjoy. Murchoch Mysteries is one of 4 particular shows that I watch regularly - and tape so that I do not miss them.
There are three main reasons that I like MM.
First, it is such a pleasure to watch something that does not have swearing, sex scenes, and gratuitous violence. Even though there are the odd (bordering on) romantic interludes the story line remains true to the theme of the title and they do not over-shadow the stories.
Second, I quite like viewing shows that depict times gone by and it is interesting to see how detectives'/police duties were (supposedly) undertaken in that time.
Third, the acting and story telling - as noted in a previous post - equals that of Midsummer Murders, Poirot (another favourite of mine), Judge John Deed (again, another favourite).
I like each character who has a distinct role and adds to the show as well as the enjoyment of watching the show. I do hope that there are quite a few new series planned.
There are three main reasons that I like MM.
First, it is such a pleasure to watch something that does not have swearing, sex scenes, and gratuitous violence. Even though there are the odd (bordering on) romantic interludes the story line remains true to the theme of the title and they do not over-shadow the stories.
Second, I quite like viewing shows that depict times gone by and it is interesting to see how detectives'/police duties were (supposedly) undertaken in that time.
Third, the acting and story telling - as noted in a previous post - equals that of Midsummer Murders, Poirot (another favourite of mine), Judge John Deed (again, another favourite).
I like each character who has a distinct role and adds to the show as well as the enjoyment of watching the show. I do hope that there are quite a few new series planned.
Murdoch Mysteries Show
Bmart-405-55610424 June 2012
Great Canadian show. Simple, yet top notch with a Canadian like atmosphere.Very realistic for the times. History is great. The clothing designs and artifacts is exceptional. It seems the times were simple back then. Well written with a touch of humour. The cast are all excellent. You can tell they all get along really well. The show reminds me of Sherlock Holmes and yet it also reminds me of Sue Thomas FB Eye and Due South which by the way it sure was nice to see Paul Gross (from Due South) appear in an episode as his brother, although not sure what episode it was. We didn't see his name on the cast list as a guest star. The guest appearances are outstanding and it sure is nice to see some familiar faces. We love and watch all the episodes. With each season the character story lines change as in the case of Helen Joy, Yannick Bisson which is excellent leaving us more curious with what will happen next. That is one of the reasons we like the show. Now that the show is in it's fourth year the plot lines are continually changing which goes to prove that Murdoch Mysteries is a true success. Keep up the excellent work.
Simply The Best Mystery
landew27 February 2010
I'm been watching mysteries for many years and never have enjoyed a series more than Murdoch Mysteries. The time period, set design and writing matches the great performances by the cast, who you can't help but appreciate. If ever a series deserved a wider audience and advertising, it is this one. The unfulfilled love affair between Doctor Ogden and Murdoch is so well written and performed perfectly by Helene Joy and Yannick Bisson. Also, top notch acting by Jonny Harris in his portrayal of Constable Crabtree gives just the prefect comic relief while Murdoch solves the case using every scientific method available. Thomas Craig is also marvelous as the cranky Inspector Brackenreid. I can't help wondering why this show does not have a larger audience base since it is the talk of so many people I know, both at work and socially. My wife and I eagerly await each and every episode. Please make many many more!
The Season 2008
slrehlau29 April 2008
The Murdoch Mysteries is like; The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes, with Jeremy Brett meets CSI: Crime Scene Investigation.
Yannic Bisson had made a master piece in establishing 'Murdoch's" character, which in my opinion, takes the best of William Peterson's role as "Gil Grissom" and Jeremy Brett's as "Sherlock Holmes". The feel of this show gives me the impression that these characters are believable, I actually care about how their relationships' enfold and in the exploration of the early sciences of crime scene investigation, it shows an appreciation for the intelligence of it's viewers.
For example, the episode: "Still Waters", where Murdock uses his "new fangled lie detector", show us a level of sophistication in helping the viewer, me, see how through science and experimentation these early "machines", might have actually looked like.
The production company, SHAFTSBURY FILMS, has created a "Canadian" show that doesn't look like any other "Canadian" show I've ever seen, way to go everyone!
S. Lucy Rehlau
Yannic Bisson had made a master piece in establishing 'Murdoch's" character, which in my opinion, takes the best of William Peterson's role as "Gil Grissom" and Jeremy Brett's as "Sherlock Holmes". The feel of this show gives me the impression that these characters are believable, I actually care about how their relationships' enfold and in the exploration of the early sciences of crime scene investigation, it shows an appreciation for the intelligence of it's viewers.
For example, the episode: "Still Waters", where Murdock uses his "new fangled lie detector", show us a level of sophistication in helping the viewer, me, see how through science and experimentation these early "machines", might have actually looked like.
The production company, SHAFTSBURY FILMS, has created a "Canadian" show that doesn't look like any other "Canadian" show I've ever seen, way to go everyone!
S. Lucy Rehlau
History and Morals
dkparent25 April 2017
A wonderful Victorian era show that highlights many of the issues they had at the time, though some reviews I see do not understand this. It goes without saying that the show is not for everyone, I appreciates history, even when it is lightly played with inventions and such as Murdock does. This is a show that highlights Canadian values and has some deep underlying moral questions that will tug at your mind. You may not agree with all of the politics and religion that a few shows have but they are true to the time. I only wished people had the same decency that many of these characters have as it appears in this century we have lost many of those values.
Regards to all those who review and enjoy.
Regards to all those who review and enjoy.
Great Series
hmflashgordon11 April 2008
I like this series as it has so much to offer. The scenes & locales are interesting & very real to life. The actors demonstrate their abilities to fit the characters & make the characters real. I've seen both versions of Murdoch Mysteries with the 2 different lead roles & find them both a credit to each of the actors. Yes, obviously, they present different aspects of the character but each brings quality to the part. I really enjoy this series & look forward to each episode. It's great to see a Canadian production of this quality on TV - such a rare gem. I do hope this series is kept on & is appreciated by both the public & especially by the TV providers - cable & satellite.
Rush to judgement - A series versus movies of the week
idenford27 January 2008
The inevitable comparisons are going to take place between these two actors, Peter Outerbridge and Yannick Bisson. Their interpretation of the material is different for one very important reason, the movies of the week were based on novels, the series is based on the characters with the exception of one episode which is an adaptation of Let Loose The Dogs. My feeling is that you should not rush to judgement or make comparisons until you are able to see the entire series of episodes and witness how the characters unfold. The series is excellent and I would urge viewers to form an opinion after viewing a number of the episodes and see how the actors nuance their characters as well as the different textures that are shown from story to story, episode to episode.
Where are the Murdoch Mysteries heading?
cpearce3747 April 2020
Series 1 - 11 were absolutely wonderful. William was inventing. Crabtree was hilariously naming stuff! Julia was moving with the times, as you would expect of a worldly woman. Everything was working, staying within the boundaries of the time they were living in. Series 12 comes along and things changed quite dramatically. William wasn't inventing very much. There started to be more attention to the main characters personal lives than murder or mystery. Now on series 13 and it just seems to be worsening. William hasn't invented anything, and, dare I say it? Yes, woke! Why are we suddenly putting today's social values in an early 1900s setting? I just don't get it at all. They'll all be using mobile phones and the internet next.
A charming series that winks at the audience. Strong characters are the strength of the series. Anachronistic with kind of a fantasy vibe.
reb-warrior5 July 2020
Warning: Spoilers
The series starts off around 1895 in Toronto Canada. William Murdoch is a detective that mainly uses science and charts in order to solve the mystery. The show is admittedly anachronistic. There's sort of a fantasy vibe to it, tho the show doesn't actually go there. I like to think of it as an alternative reality. It's lighthearted for the most part, tho it does delve into some dark and serious things. There's a really good balance. Bravo to the writers.
The strength of the show isn't actually "the whodunnit" part, but the main characters and their interactions with their quirky personalities. Murdoch is a nerd, introverted, religious, and on the straight and narrow, yet funny in a variety of situations due to his persona. Inspector Brackenreid is grouchy, charming, and cultured(he loves the opera and theater). He can be blunt most of the time, yet sweetly compassionate other times. George is sweet, charming, and funny. He sometimes thinks vampires, werewolves, or some other supernatural thing is involved. He's hilarious. But tho he gets carried away by flights of fancy sometimes, he's actually really smart and capable, and not written as a dumb sidekick to Murdoch.
Julia is the most forward-thinking character on the show. All the main characters are too, to some extent. She's a total geek with a bit of an oddball sense of humor. I love the way she kind of laughs off to the side at something funny. Mirroring how the audience might be laughing at that moment. She gives William her opinion about things, which he encourages and in fact asks of her, and he takes them seriously and truly listens. He respects her. They make a great pairing. These four characters(actors) are the strength in the show. Their interactions with each other(and others) make the show a delight to watch. You care about them. They give the show heart.
There are many other great characters that recur a lot and/ or become series regulars later, such as Higgins, Emily, Miss James, Terrence Myers, Watts, James Pendrick, and many more.
William is a devout catholic. For anyone thinking Murdoch will be unlikable because of this, think again. He is open-minded and is a very empathetic character. He questions his own faith at times, which leads to some good storytelling as a conflicted character. A good example of this is 'Til Death Do Us Part 'in season one.
There's a lot of humor on the show. George often sees great potential ideas for the future that he's right about, but Murdoch always downplays it. It's hilarious. Some winks to the audience include email, Twitter, TV, The Internet, reality cooking show competitions. There are so many more. Too many to mention.
As I said before, all the main characters are very forward in their ideology to some extent. Again the show is anachronistic. I don't think anyone in today's audience wants to watch a show where the four main white characters are a bunch of racists and bigots. I mean back then those attitudes would have been regarded as normal. But not today. Well, maybe a tiny few do want to see those attitudes, as I see sometimes in the reviews. But that's more telling of bigotry that exist inside some people than it is about the show. The show is not historically correct and is mainly in the light-hearted spectrum. That's why I think of it as an alternative reality, which to me, gives off a bit of a fantasy vibe.
Speaking of the four main white characters, the show does have series regular black characters, later on, Miss James, and Violet Hart. They also have a lot of diverse guest stars and gay characters throughout the entire series. Tho the show is mainly on the light-hearted side, it does delve into darker themes, and there are many episodes that I feel are making a statement about society. They do a great job of this. It's not preachy, yet gets it points through.
I said many times that the show is anachronistic, but a lot actual correct historical events are used in stories such as the "Great Toronto Fire" or the assassination of President McKinley, and a number of actual historical figures in the right time period, such as Edison and Alexander Graham Bell. Too many to mention, but there are a lot and especially of Canadian events and Canadian historical figures.
I feel like this show is underrated and doesn't get enough credit for being a great series with talented actors, writers, and directors. Especially for being very Canadian in content. It's one of the highest-rated Canadian shows in Canada and is going on its 14th season. Yet when I look at its awards and nominations, it seems rather abysmal. Especially when comparing to another Canadian show, Schitt's Creek. Fewer seasons, more noms and wins. I love this show too, but you can't even tell this show takes place in Canada. You can't even tell if any of the characters are Canadian as it's never mentioned where anyone is actually from. In fact, I guess they were dodgy about it due to its international popularity. It makes me feel like they thought Canada wasn't good enough. Almost like they're pretending it could be American. I suppose that helps sells it better to American buyers, but it turns me off. I can't help but think the "trendy train" which a lot of people got on, played a huge part in that show's popularity and award nods. Again, I love that show too, but the disparity in praise and lack thereof for MM is very blatant. Perhaps this comparison isn't fair, but these are the two main Canadian shows I've watched in the last few years. I'm glad Schitt's Creek has done so well, I just wish Murdoch Mysteries, which was there before, and will be there after, wasn't so ignored.
Thankfully Murdoch Mysteries keeps churning out quality material despite not getting proper recognition. The audience knows this is a diamond in the rough. I feel like I can write an entire book on my thoughts about the series, so forgive me my rather long review. It is after all 13 seasons and counting. 10/10
The strength of the show isn't actually "the whodunnit" part, but the main characters and their interactions with their quirky personalities. Murdoch is a nerd, introverted, religious, and on the straight and narrow, yet funny in a variety of situations due to his persona. Inspector Brackenreid is grouchy, charming, and cultured(he loves the opera and theater). He can be blunt most of the time, yet sweetly compassionate other times. George is sweet, charming, and funny. He sometimes thinks vampires, werewolves, or some other supernatural thing is involved. He's hilarious. But tho he gets carried away by flights of fancy sometimes, he's actually really smart and capable, and not written as a dumb sidekick to Murdoch.
Julia is the most forward-thinking character on the show. All the main characters are too, to some extent. She's a total geek with a bit of an oddball sense of humor. I love the way she kind of laughs off to the side at something funny. Mirroring how the audience might be laughing at that moment. She gives William her opinion about things, which he encourages and in fact asks of her, and he takes them seriously and truly listens. He respects her. They make a great pairing. These four characters(actors) are the strength in the show. Their interactions with each other(and others) make the show a delight to watch. You care about them. They give the show heart.
There are many other great characters that recur a lot and/ or become series regulars later, such as Higgins, Emily, Miss James, Terrence Myers, Watts, James Pendrick, and many more.
William is a devout catholic. For anyone thinking Murdoch will be unlikable because of this, think again. He is open-minded and is a very empathetic character. He questions his own faith at times, which leads to some good storytelling as a conflicted character. A good example of this is 'Til Death Do Us Part 'in season one.
There's a lot of humor on the show. George often sees great potential ideas for the future that he's right about, but Murdoch always downplays it. It's hilarious. Some winks to the audience include email, Twitter, TV, The Internet, reality cooking show competitions. There are so many more. Too many to mention.
As I said before, all the main characters are very forward in their ideology to some extent. Again the show is anachronistic. I don't think anyone in today's audience wants to watch a show where the four main white characters are a bunch of racists and bigots. I mean back then those attitudes would have been regarded as normal. But not today. Well, maybe a tiny few do want to see those attitudes, as I see sometimes in the reviews. But that's more telling of bigotry that exist inside some people than it is about the show. The show is not historically correct and is mainly in the light-hearted spectrum. That's why I think of it as an alternative reality, which to me, gives off a bit of a fantasy vibe.
Speaking of the four main white characters, the show does have series regular black characters, later on, Miss James, and Violet Hart. They also have a lot of diverse guest stars and gay characters throughout the entire series. Tho the show is mainly on the light-hearted side, it does delve into darker themes, and there are many episodes that I feel are making a statement about society. They do a great job of this. It's not preachy, yet gets it points through.
I said many times that the show is anachronistic, but a lot actual correct historical events are used in stories such as the "Great Toronto Fire" or the assassination of President McKinley, and a number of actual historical figures in the right time period, such as Edison and Alexander Graham Bell. Too many to mention, but there are a lot and especially of Canadian events and Canadian historical figures.
I feel like this show is underrated and doesn't get enough credit for being a great series with talented actors, writers, and directors. Especially for being very Canadian in content. It's one of the highest-rated Canadian shows in Canada and is going on its 14th season. Yet when I look at its awards and nominations, it seems rather abysmal. Especially when comparing to another Canadian show, Schitt's Creek. Fewer seasons, more noms and wins. I love this show too, but you can't even tell this show takes place in Canada. You can't even tell if any of the characters are Canadian as it's never mentioned where anyone is actually from. In fact, I guess they were dodgy about it due to its international popularity. It makes me feel like they thought Canada wasn't good enough. Almost like they're pretending it could be American. I suppose that helps sells it better to American buyers, but it turns me off. I can't help but think the "trendy train" which a lot of people got on, played a huge part in that show's popularity and award nods. Again, I love that show too, but the disparity in praise and lack thereof for MM is very blatant. Perhaps this comparison isn't fair, but these are the two main Canadian shows I've watched in the last few years. I'm glad Schitt's Creek has done so well, I just wish Murdoch Mysteries, which was there before, and will be there after, wasn't so ignored.
Thankfully Murdoch Mysteries keeps churning out quality material despite not getting proper recognition. The audience knows this is a diamond in the rough. I feel like I can write an entire book on my thoughts about the series, so forgive me my rather long review. It is after all 13 seasons and counting. 10/10
Too "woke" for its time...
elbonian00-218-88297115 April 2020
On its ascent into TV immortality, this unique detective series was about science, intellect, and innovation well ahead of its time. In recent years it has devolved into smug intersectional sermonizing. The writers appear to be attempting to rewrite the history of the North American cultural conscience, ascribing to it a woke perspective that wouldn't assert itself as a cultural seismic event for a century yet.
Has had its day
aislingdublin23 January 2021
Once upon a time was about quirky inventions that assisted a likeable detective and his colleagues. Also a nice bit of 19th century romance. Then more and more the detective work and inventions disappeared and the show became a lecture about social justice. Its bizarre. Minorities are always spoken about as being very badly treated while at the same time the show has minorities in very senior posts that they never would have attained. A very mixed message.
This is Mrs. Shullivan and my own "Go To" television series
Ed-Shullivan27 September 2015
When you get bored with everything else that is currently on television and you need a guaranteed hour of sheer entertainment that can whisk you away to a simpler time when the world was not as chaotic and confusing as it is now than may I suggest getting hooked on the CBC's (Canadian Broadcasting Corporation) television series Murdoch Mysteries which is now entering their ninth season of continued success.
This is a very unique crime/mystery series which takes place at the turn of the 20th century in the large bustling city of Toronto Ontario, Canada, which is served by the finest constabularies in the country, that being the Toronto Constabulary. There are three main characters who are employed by the City of Toronto Constabulary in the year 1899. The local police station is managed by the gruff (of Scottish descent) Inspector Thomas Brackenreid and he is played by Thomas Craig. The lead detective William Murdoch is played to perfection by Yannick Bisson. One of the constables who is usually chasing behind the clever detective William Murdoch with a slew of his own questions is the affable Newfoundlander born Constable George Crabtree, played with an endless supply of lovable smiles and charisma by actor Jonny Harris. Now George Crabtree does add a lot of comic relief but if you pay careful attention to the ingenious inventions that George shares with his peers you will note that he is usually talking about an actual discovery/invention that will come to fruition in the latter half of the 20th century. Thus the series provides some historical significance to many inventions/things we usually take for granted.
Detective William Murdoch also is ahead of his time with some of his newly created forensic science approaches to solving crimes, such as his underwater sonar device and his archaic night vision glasses. Murdoch has a near distant love interest in the city coroner Dr. Julia Ogden played extremely well by Helene Joy. The audience anticipates and is constantly teased that some day maybe they will be together. Between the two of them they assess the W5 (Who, What, When, Where and Why) of the current episodes latest murder victim(s), serious crime, and/or historical event that actually occurred in documented history and brought to life in this excellent crafted mystery/crime series.
Mrs. Shullivan and I have not only watched every single episode of this amazing series but we have also deliberately watched repeated episodes with as much interest if not more than the first time we saw the episodes as we always seem to pick up more interesting tidbits of not only historic events but of the development of the City of Toronto and its urban sprawl during the 20th century. The writers must have taken great pride in maintaining the accuracy of events such as the time line to build the Toronto subway line, and the evolution of fortune 500 companies such as the Ford Motor Company, IBM and General Electric.
Murdoch Mysteries cannot be taken for granted and should be on your MUST see list as there is so much punch packed in to each 60 minute episode that you rarely can determine how each episode will end. This is a series that is filled with mystery, suspense, historical events and great humour. The success of this excellent series continues into its ninth season with no diminishing return as each episode concludes. Mrs. Shullivan and I cannot wait for the next episode to be released as it is one hour each week of guaranteed entertainment. The quality of the cinematography and wardrobe is first rate.
A 10 for 10 rating without a doubt
Footnote: Actor Jonny Harris had his own weekly TV series launched in 2015 titled STILL STANDING in which he travels from one small Canadian town to another each week where the population is typically under 1,000 people and where the town is surviving based on the people and their small town pride. Jonny Harris meets with the local yokels and then he roasts the entire town in their local civic hall explaining to his hometown audience and we the television viewers what makes this town so special. It is a great 30 minute hooray for Canadiana heritage that is also sheer to entertain. Super job Jonny Harris and CBC!
This is a very unique crime/mystery series which takes place at the turn of the 20th century in the large bustling city of Toronto Ontario, Canada, which is served by the finest constabularies in the country, that being the Toronto Constabulary. There are three main characters who are employed by the City of Toronto Constabulary in the year 1899. The local police station is managed by the gruff (of Scottish descent) Inspector Thomas Brackenreid and he is played by Thomas Craig. The lead detective William Murdoch is played to perfection by Yannick Bisson. One of the constables who is usually chasing behind the clever detective William Murdoch with a slew of his own questions is the affable Newfoundlander born Constable George Crabtree, played with an endless supply of lovable smiles and charisma by actor Jonny Harris. Now George Crabtree does add a lot of comic relief but if you pay careful attention to the ingenious inventions that George shares with his peers you will note that he is usually talking about an actual discovery/invention that will come to fruition in the latter half of the 20th century. Thus the series provides some historical significance to many inventions/things we usually take for granted.
Detective William Murdoch also is ahead of his time with some of his newly created forensic science approaches to solving crimes, such as his underwater sonar device and his archaic night vision glasses. Murdoch has a near distant love interest in the city coroner Dr. Julia Ogden played extremely well by Helene Joy. The audience anticipates and is constantly teased that some day maybe they will be together. Between the two of them they assess the W5 (Who, What, When, Where and Why) of the current episodes latest murder victim(s), serious crime, and/or historical event that actually occurred in documented history and brought to life in this excellent crafted mystery/crime series.
Mrs. Shullivan and I have not only watched every single episode of this amazing series but we have also deliberately watched repeated episodes with as much interest if not more than the first time we saw the episodes as we always seem to pick up more interesting tidbits of not only historic events but of the development of the City of Toronto and its urban sprawl during the 20th century. The writers must have taken great pride in maintaining the accuracy of events such as the time line to build the Toronto subway line, and the evolution of fortune 500 companies such as the Ford Motor Company, IBM and General Electric.
Murdoch Mysteries cannot be taken for granted and should be on your MUST see list as there is so much punch packed in to each 60 minute episode that you rarely can determine how each episode will end. This is a series that is filled with mystery, suspense, historical events and great humour. The success of this excellent series continues into its ninth season with no diminishing return as each episode concludes. Mrs. Shullivan and I cannot wait for the next episode to be released as it is one hour each week of guaranteed entertainment. The quality of the cinematography and wardrobe is first rate.
A 10 for 10 rating without a doubt
Footnote: Actor Jonny Harris had his own weekly TV series launched in 2015 titled STILL STANDING in which he travels from one small Canadian town to another each week where the population is typically under 1,000 people and where the town is surviving based on the people and their small town pride. Jonny Harris meets with the local yokels and then he roasts the entire town in their local civic hall explaining to his hometown audience and we the television viewers what makes this town so special. It is a great 30 minute hooray for Canadiana heritage that is also sheer to entertain. Super job Jonny Harris and CBC!
Excellent TV, now turned to mush and beginning to rot.
bosporan5 April 2022
Murdoch was a superb blend of concept, plot, wardrobe and character. I enjoyed the first thirteen seasons. The cast is strong throughout and the stories interesting and believable in the context of the show. Some of the historical figures inserted into the story have added flavour. The relationship between Murdoch (Yannick Bisson) and Ogden (Helene Joy) works remarkably well with both of them contributing to cases and providing a spine from which to hang various plots.
Last season (14) the writers began to run out of steam and this year many of the episodes are poor and pander too deeply to modern-day sensibilities. Sad to say, it is time to be put out to pasture.
Last season (14) the writers began to run out of steam and this year many of the episodes are poor and pander too deeply to modern-day sensibilities. Sad to say, it is time to be put out to pasture.
Fantastic show!
jlkijijisales55814 September 2012
I have been watching Murdoch Mysteries since the first season and it just keeps getting better and better. I discovered it on my own and eventually my husband started watching it too. Now, it is something we watch as a family! My 14 and 10 year old sons are hooked too! There are many reasons why I love this show so much - it has so many great elements in it - humour, drama, mystery, romance....the writing/story lines are so creative and clever. I love how they tie in real historic figures into the program like Alexander Graham Bell, Harry Houdini and Henry Ford. The cast is incredibly talented. The 19th century period costumes are beautiful. This is a true Canadian gem of a program which every household should be watching!
Yannick Bisson
reginafrisbie28 January 2008
Yannick Bisson is a fine actor and does a Excellent job as Murdoch. I'm sure that Peter did a good job with the movies but TV shows are different. And if you read Maureen Jennings site you find out that she likes Yannick Bisson as Murdoch in the TV show as well as Peter in the movies. I know that some people can be fans of a certain actor and they are loyal to that actor so that might cloud there judgment.So a TV show can be good and the new actor playing the part very good but if someone is loyal to the other actor they may have a clouded judgment on the show. If you watch the TV show you will fine that it is wonderful show and that Yannick Bisson is a fine actor and does a great job as Murdoch. I also trust Maureen Jennings since she wrote the books and she is pleased with Mr. Bisson and the TV show. All you have to do is watch the TV show and you find out for yourself that its a great show, and Yannick is a great Murdoch. So watch and find out for yourself.
Love the show but....
superduperade-785-7257787 April 2020
I love the show, I'm currently on season 13, but for one thing. The longer the show has gone on and especially in the last few seasons, the show which likes to reference actual historical events and characters seems to be becoming the dreaded.... WOKE. The supporting cast and storylines are clearly pandering to modern social issues rather than reflecting the ones of the period.
One of the best
bucksix17 September 2012
Warning: Spoilers
A friend got me into this show via the DVD route. I will be eternally grateful. The whodunit components are excellent, but the characterizations are way beyond that. I find myself applauding at the end of every episode. The humor is top notch and totally in character. To me this show belongs right up there with Foyle's War and Inspector Morse. I realize that this is a tremendous accolade but Murdoch Mysteries deserves it. I have just finished seeing all of seasons 1 and 2 so I can hardly wait for season 3. By the way, I still think William should have stuck with Enid and Elwin, but that's just me. The last episode of season 2 where William meets his half brother was an absolute delight. Sorry about that spoiler.
No longer a 10 out of 10
phone-man-126-94028331 May 2020
The show started out great but over time the show focuses on social injustices. Don't get me wrong I understand the world has social issues that need addressing. But I watch this show to be entertained and not for a lesson in social justice.
From terrific to just ick
rightingwrong30 November 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Up until recently I would have given this show a solid 10/10, but it has become just insufferable to watch. It started out strong and well made. The characters were interesting and fun, the acting was excellent, and the consumes, sets, and scenery were so believable. It was like stepping back in time. I also thought it was really neat how they incorporated real historic people into the shows ( and inserted themselves into real history-what a hoot!). It gave l the audience a fun peek into the character and lives of so many prominent people in history, even if it was mostly fiction. I looked up a lot of what was going in the show and some of it really happened. I couldn't wait to watch it-until it became unwatchable. The show slowly morphed into a homage to social and political agendas. It got really old really quick. And what is up with the once funny and charming Watts suddenly realizing he is gay, and then wiggly waggling-practically air humping- around any man who he thinks might possibly be gay as well??? If I were a gay person I'd be insulted by this portrayal. Can we please have just one show that doesn't force social and political agendas down our throats???
An American's View
schelly-9472928 May 2019
I stumbled upon MM by accident, as others have written in these reviews. I was favorably impressed - so much so that, when my husband was channel surfing, looking for something we'd both enjoy, I suggested he watch an episode to see if he enjoyed it, as well. About us: Hubs was a history major in college and has a memory like steel trap I'm more focused on futuristic things and predicted many things in our college years which are commonplace today, 35 years later. So he loves the historic tone and tenor of the period setting and I love the "tinkering" the main character does that brings new technologies into forensic science. We both find all the characters believable, lovable and fun, to the extent that we cheer for Constable Crabtree when he finds love, and tear up when he loses it, etc. We ventured to Hulu and subscribed just so we could binge watch MM from the very beginning. Now I'm reading this is based on a book, so I must go find it. PLEASE follow these characters until they are old and full of days.
A wonderful show till s11, but declining since
MsDJH27 January 2022
Warning: Spoilers
If you like upbeat stories and are prone to a little bit of history, fantasy and old school mystery crime, Murdoch Mysteries is your go-to program. Don't mind the freedoms the writers are taking every once in a while. For 11 seasons, this show was targeted at viewers of all ages and vintage enthusiasts. It expressed a deep love for literature and music, included a quirky sense of humor and could best be described as Canadian to boot. It's always been progressive, but didn't fail to add viewpoints and issues of the times it's set in (1895-1906).
The main character is Detective William Murdoch, a devout Catholic in the very Protestant town of Toronto, who's trying to solve cases from a different point of view. He's self-educated and well-read on scientific procedures and progress of humankind. When presented with a problem he cannot solve by following established procedures, he's coming up with an idea that foreshadows future gadgets and possibilities. Throughout the seasons, his inventions have included everything from household gizmos to useful investigative tools and for 11 seasons, his mind never stopped inquiring.
ATTENTION: Spoilers ahead (s01-15)
Aside from Murdoch, Dr. Julia Ogden is adding wisdom to the weekly investigations, along with Inspector Brackenreid, Constables George Crabtree and Henry Higgins (for comic relief). Dr. Ogden started out as the city's Coroner, then became Murdoch's love interest, butted heads with him over the topic of abortion, left town, changed careers and married another man. Back in Toronto, she worked as a doctor, coroner and psychiatrist, and frequently stirred up trouble as a part-time suffragette while Murdoch tried dating other women and failed miserably at doing so. If it wasn't Julia, it simply didn't feel right.
If you are exhausted now, this is where I'm giving you a chance to take a breath, because we've only just reached the end of s5 and I didn't even get started on George's journey yet. But for the sake of simplicity perhaps let's focus on the titular character and say that after s5, things were looking up for William on the relationship front (although it took another two seasons for him to finally catch Julia for good). And when he did, the magic between him and newlywed wife suddenly vanished and didn't reappear until that moment in s9, when she was rising from a coma to rescue her husband from one of their lunatic nemeses like a female knight in shining armor.
When revisited in print, these developments might sound completely out there and a bit annoying perhaps. On screen, however, the characters keep pulling you in. They are just so entertaining. Up until s11 at least, when after a doomed adoption attempt, Julia was risking her life to become pregnant with her own child only to please her husband. (If that's not the story the writers intended to tell, well, that's how it came across to me and considering the treatment she volunteered to be a lab rat for) I wasn't exactly thrilled to see her getting pregnant quite so easily. Her miscarriage then, however, was handled believably well, so I was pleased in retrospect, although the friction that loss caused between her and William threw us right back to season 2 for a while. Their reconciliation and growth in the s11 finale then felt like a perfect wrap to a wonderful storyline though and I couldn't have been happier if the show had ended right there and then. Everything that's happened since, feels like a totally different show.
Granted, S12 and beyond still have their moments and I do appreciate the introduction of Llewelyn Watts, Miss Cherry and Ruth Newsome as more regular characters. I do like the humorous Halloween episodes they have added and even the very modern Murdoch mansion has grown on me over time (although I'm still mourning the omission of Murdoch's self designed dream house). What I don't like is the darker tone, Dr. Ogden's constant career changes, the introduction of Violet Hart as a borderline sociopath whose actions are constantly overlooked or pardoned, Rupert Newsome's weird wife, George's abysmal luck with women and the sudden appearance of surprise children for both Brackenreid and Murdoch. The latter has annoyed me especially because to me it feels as if Murdoch's son was introduced for melodramatic purposes only and now that Julia is pregnant again (simply because the actress who plays her was with child herself), his existence parches the last drops of what made this couple so special and uplifting to watch. After all the ordeals they have been through, embracing their childlessness would've been a refreshing perspective. But no: apparently only children bring true joy and fulfillment. No mention of Julia's traumatic miscarriage, her advanced age, the consequences of a pregnancy to her career or the constant threats they are living with. Nothing. Just happy smiles and the idea of a perfect life with baby Murdoch and William's "bastard" son (Harry).
That's not what Murdoch Mysteries is about. Give William, Julia, George and Brackenreid interesting crimes to solve and don't turn their lives into just another dystopian soap opera. We have enough of those already, so just keep it entertaining, Murdoch people, and stop writing juvenile fan fiction instead of decent scripts.
*Edited for clarity and structure (apologies for submitting too early by mistake)
The main character is Detective William Murdoch, a devout Catholic in the very Protestant town of Toronto, who's trying to solve cases from a different point of view. He's self-educated and well-read on scientific procedures and progress of humankind. When presented with a problem he cannot solve by following established procedures, he's coming up with an idea that foreshadows future gadgets and possibilities. Throughout the seasons, his inventions have included everything from household gizmos to useful investigative tools and for 11 seasons, his mind never stopped inquiring.
ATTENTION: Spoilers ahead (s01-15)
Aside from Murdoch, Dr. Julia Ogden is adding wisdom to the weekly investigations, along with Inspector Brackenreid, Constables George Crabtree and Henry Higgins (for comic relief). Dr. Ogden started out as the city's Coroner, then became Murdoch's love interest, butted heads with him over the topic of abortion, left town, changed careers and married another man. Back in Toronto, she worked as a doctor, coroner and psychiatrist, and frequently stirred up trouble as a part-time suffragette while Murdoch tried dating other women and failed miserably at doing so. If it wasn't Julia, it simply didn't feel right.
If you are exhausted now, this is where I'm giving you a chance to take a breath, because we've only just reached the end of s5 and I didn't even get started on George's journey yet. But for the sake of simplicity perhaps let's focus on the titular character and say that after s5, things were looking up for William on the relationship front (although it took another two seasons for him to finally catch Julia for good). And when he did, the magic between him and newlywed wife suddenly vanished and didn't reappear until that moment in s9, when she was rising from a coma to rescue her husband from one of their lunatic nemeses like a female knight in shining armor.
When revisited in print, these developments might sound completely out there and a bit annoying perhaps. On screen, however, the characters keep pulling you in. They are just so entertaining. Up until s11 at least, when after a doomed adoption attempt, Julia was risking her life to become pregnant with her own child only to please her husband. (If that's not the story the writers intended to tell, well, that's how it came across to me and considering the treatment she volunteered to be a lab rat for) I wasn't exactly thrilled to see her getting pregnant quite so easily. Her miscarriage then, however, was handled believably well, so I was pleased in retrospect, although the friction that loss caused between her and William threw us right back to season 2 for a while. Their reconciliation and growth in the s11 finale then felt like a perfect wrap to a wonderful storyline though and I couldn't have been happier if the show had ended right there and then. Everything that's happened since, feels like a totally different show.
Granted, S12 and beyond still have their moments and I do appreciate the introduction of Llewelyn Watts, Miss Cherry and Ruth Newsome as more regular characters. I do like the humorous Halloween episodes they have added and even the very modern Murdoch mansion has grown on me over time (although I'm still mourning the omission of Murdoch's self designed dream house). What I don't like is the darker tone, Dr. Ogden's constant career changes, the introduction of Violet Hart as a borderline sociopath whose actions are constantly overlooked or pardoned, Rupert Newsome's weird wife, George's abysmal luck with women and the sudden appearance of surprise children for both Brackenreid and Murdoch. The latter has annoyed me especially because to me it feels as if Murdoch's son was introduced for melodramatic purposes only and now that Julia is pregnant again (simply because the actress who plays her was with child herself), his existence parches the last drops of what made this couple so special and uplifting to watch. After all the ordeals they have been through, embracing their childlessness would've been a refreshing perspective. But no: apparently only children bring true joy and fulfillment. No mention of Julia's traumatic miscarriage, her advanced age, the consequences of a pregnancy to her career or the constant threats they are living with. Nothing. Just happy smiles and the idea of a perfect life with baby Murdoch and William's "bastard" son (Harry).
That's not what Murdoch Mysteries is about. Give William, Julia, George and Brackenreid interesting crimes to solve and don't turn their lives into just another dystopian soap opera. We have enough of those already, so just keep it entertaining, Murdoch people, and stop writing juvenile fan fiction instead of decent scripts.
*Edited for clarity and structure (apologies for submitting too early by mistake)
Historical revisionism isn't good
Ashitaka13724 May 2020
I really love this show, but as a black man i can't get past when period fictions portray the history part of their shows inaccurately, especially when it comes to rewriting the discrimination of some groups during those times and for like in this show, placing black people and women in a position of power, like normal, everyday considered detectives, doctors, or coroner in the early 1900's! How will the historical pioneers's struggles who fought and died to open doors for future generations would be remembered and be relevant if shows and movies like this, confuse people especially young people by rewriting History! Shows like The Knick are far better, because more authentic.
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
