My Effortless Brilliance (2008) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
'Brilliance' is brilliant in its awkward intimacy
christin_asc13 April 2008
Lynn Shelton's "My Effortless Brilliance" is a study in the relationship between cocky, fussy, thoroughly-city-mouse author Eric (Sean Nelson) and his ex-best-friend, the tersely powerful journalist and wood-chopper Dylan (Basil Harris). Dylan, fed up with Eric's self-involved antics, dumps him and disappears to live in a log cabin in the woods of Eastern Washington; two years later, Eric arrives (sporting a Prius, white sneakers, and a fear of spiders) to mend the friendship.

The acting style, on the vanguard of the 'mumblecore' movement in improvisational film-making, works beautifully for the tension between Eric and Dylan in this film. Theirs isn't a "movie fight," with two handsome actors shouting witty insults and slamming doors. It's a quiet, painfully awkward, passive-aggressive, eyes-averted fight, no fireworks and no catharsis for the characters either. It's how people who aren't drama queens actually get angry at each other--quietly and seethingly.

The film style in which 'Brilliance' was filmed plays perfectly with the subject matter and acting: the camera is awkwardly and intimately and uncomfortably close, not just over the shoulder of the actors but breathing down their necks. You, the audience, are brought into the awkwardness of the rift between Eric and Dylan, you're part of the problem, you're holding your breath and walking on eggshells too.

Not that this movie is an mess of tension and closeness--all of what I've said aside, My Effortless Brilliance is genuinely funny. It's full of small surreal moments showcasing the absurdity of human interactions doused in Serbian brandy, anecdotes of bullfighting guitar riffs and suicidal house cats and Liv Tyler's derrière.

If you have the opportunity to see My Effortless Brilliance, do not pass it by. Lynn Shelton does a fantastic job studying the way friendships are broken and mended, and the relationships between Sean Nelson, Basil Harris, and Calvin Reeder throw into relief the best and the worst of male rapport.
23 out of 37 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Beefy & Jerky Friend
thesar-24 April 2011
Warning: Spoilers
I'm one sucker for improvised films, but the only other film (series) that I'm fully aware of , other than My Effortless Brilliance, is the Lethal Weapon films. As long as it can pass the director, such as unscripted dialogue fits and works, it's okay with me. It's a helluva better than the so-called "non-scripted" reality series plaguing our TV screens.

In addition to the made-up dialogue, I also like the small, simple and powerful movies that the mumblecore films once were. In which this thoroughly resembles. It helps that it was filmed in/around Washington state that I favor. Add in likable, though flawed and rooted for characters, all around, I really liked this movie.

Writer Eric ('Fro Sean Nelson) coaxes best pal Dylan (Basil Harris) to bring over dinner one night using the telephone, indictating this isn't the first time the guys hung out together. But when Dylan does drop off dinner he informs Eric that his huge hair isn't the only thing that's expanded above his neck – basically calling him an a-hole friend, this ends a long relationship.

Fast forward two years, Eric's gotten even bigger with his books and his loneliness while he misses his friend. On a business trip, he decides to drop by, unexpectedly, to Dylan's remote cabin in an undisclosed (literally) wooded Washington state area, and he tries to pick up where they left off a couple of years prior…as well as prior to Dylan's revolution that Eric's became a jerk as his writing career took off.

Dylan's obviously still hurt, but welcomes his friend with closed arms and the duo hangs out along with the movie's third (of only four) actor, Jim (Calvin Reeder) and hopefully Eric and Dylan can make up.

The movie's beautiful. It contains great landscapes, shots and overall nice cinematography. It's thoroughly real – it helps the actors were not following memorized lines. The two genuinely has chemistry and you root for a resolution and reasons behind the "heterosexual" breakup. Further, the score's nice, the production value, though obviously made as an independent feature, was well done.

As a slow-moving, but real-life account of friendship-lost, with humorous and authentic words coming from what would be a tense and broken male-to-male/non-sexual relationship, I will thoroughly recommend this movie.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed