Mistaken (TV Movie 2008) Poster

(2008 TV Movie)

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
The Red Scarf
lavatch6 March 2020
Warning: Spoilers
"The Double Life of Eleanor Kendall" (a.k.a., "Mistaken") is a slow burner that focuses on a woman seeking the culprit who has stolen her identity. Nellie Givens (née Kendall) travels to Montreal to confront the perpetrator. But the ninety-minute filmed seemed interminable in finally revealing what motivated the other woman to steal Nellie's identity and her life.

When Nellie meets her double, she is charmed by a dynamic woman and her young daughter Sarah. Nellie had lost a child in a miscarriage and feels a special bonding with the little girl. She becomes reluctant to report the woman to the police out of genuine human concerns.

In a subplot that bogs the film down even more, Nellie meets a dashing Englishman staying at her bed and breakfast in Montreal. There was not much chemistry between the two characters. Yet, the film strings out their affair with trips to the lake, a brief swim, and a not-so-torrid bedroom romp.

Things finally come to a head in the final twenty minutes of the film. Poor "Julie" once met Nellie mother at an airport, learned a lot about her, and, Nellie was only one of Julie's victims. She stole other people's identities because she was desperate to safeguard her daughter from a deranged husband. As Nellie was a sucker for a sob story, she bonded with Julie and eventually confronted the psycho husband.

Despite the good cast, including a stunning performer playing Nellie Givens, the artistic choices never really worked. There was a superstitious old woman from Hungary named Madeleine, who lived with Julie and Sarah and dreamed that the red scarf worn by Nellie portended death to Julie. But the old woman was wrong. The scarf, like so many other gimmicks used in this film, never really captured the viewer's attention.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Very good, mainly toward end
vchimpanzee10 August 2010
The movie starts with Nellie traveling through Montreal in a cab. This I don't really understand because nothing happens that would indicate why things were done this way. Then we see what happened one year earlier.

Nellie and Dave are splitting up. They still seem to be friends. Dave supports her emotionally when she needs it. But as Nellie gets started on her new life, she discovers she has bad credit. Someone else is using her maiden name Eleanor Kendall. She can't leave her apartment, which she wants to sell, because she has to have good credit to get a new one. For now, she has a business she can sell, but Nellie wants to find out what happened and get her life back.

The police won't help, but Nellie is quite resourceful and she tracks down enough information to tell her Eleanor is in Montreal.

Nellie goes to Montreal and checks into a bed and breakfast run by the perfectly lovely Doreen. What a nice personality and pleasant English accent she has.

Soon, Nellie finds herself sharing the upstairs bath with Christopher, who is in Montreal for a conference of some sort. Christopher is willing to listen and becomes a good friend. Maybe more than a friend.

Nellie starts her search and happens to discover a coffee place where the waiter has a crush on this beautiful single woman who comes in every day it the same time. For some reason, Nellie suspects this is Eleanor. After investigating, she finds out the woman tutors people in French. So Nellie goes to her and pretends she wants to learn French for travel. And yes, the woman's name is Eleanor Kendall.

Soon, Nellie and Eleanor are friends. Eleanor has a young daughter Sarah who likes Nellie a lot. Eleanor says Sarah's father died when the girl was very young. Madelaine is the suspicious and psychic Hungarian nanny. The Catholic school (with nuns) where Sarah goes is right next door. And Sarah needs a friend she can speak English with. She seems to speak only French with her mother for some reason.

The mystery takes some interesting twists, including some that would not be expected in a movie like this. Once the truth comes out (or is it the truth?) things get really exciting. And somewhat violent. The ending is pretty amazing. Well, for me, anyway. The person who claims he or she saw it coming a mile away might not be so impressed.

I think the leading actors all did a good job. Kathleen McAuliffe, as I said, was a delight as Doreen. Maéva Nadon was adorable as Sarah.

This movie had a TV-14 rating, though I'm not sure it was justified. The only content indicator was a V, but the violence here wasn't that graphic. I would have said TV-PG with violence and sex. There was more sexual content than actual violence. Still, this movie is probably kind of intense for someone Sarah's age, and maybe that was the concern.

It was a worthwhile experience.
11 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Excellent thriller romance
tshirleywa8 May 2023
I watched mistaken film today on Amazon prime and I found the tv film very entertaining and thrilling were nelly try's stop a French woman from using her name for fraud and I enjoyed lake love scene were Nelly makes love to a English man and I found that scene very sexy and i enjoyed the hotel b&b room love scene were Nelly wears some sexy red underwear and I found that scene very sexy and that and it had great French language in the tv film and I also enjoyed the scene were Nelly is out with the French to reveal a her true identity I found that scene very good and heart warming and i enjoyed it.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Entertaining movie with a great story line!
midnightwolf51825 October 2012
To tell you the truth, the whole reason I watched this movie was because Lana Parrilla stars in it. However, as soon as I started watching it, I was hooked! It had an excellent plot, great acting (esp. Lana, of course), and always had you wondering what would happen next. The second half of the movie was especially exciting and had me on the edge of my seat until the very end. And I was very happy with the ending as well! I'm not generally a fan of TV movies, but I definitely recommend this one! The ONLY bad thing about this movie is that it's not more readily available for people to buy. If you're a fan of Lana Parrilla, or enjoy a good drama/mystery/romance, you've got to check this one out.
17 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Not bad for 'bored housewife' territory.
EdinaJambo24 May 2019
This film was just shown here in the UK on the Sony Movie Channel. I usually avoid anything of this genre on any daytime soap/movie channel especially if it is Canadian (sorry Canada!). As a male Brit (Scot actually) I tend to think of this type of offering as 'bored housewife' territory, simply because they can often come over as insipid and bland. This one, however, I liked. I liked it not just because the lovely Lana Parrilla was in it, but it actually had a decent storyline and a good quality cast. Everything here ticked the right boxes for me and I am quite pleased that I was at home when it was on TV. No need for me to re-iterate the plot; that has already been adequately covered. If it comes on again I will make sure I record it, just for the lovely Miss Parrilla!
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Come on now
CranberriAppl1 February 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Pretty ridiculous storyline. The way she opened up to her neighbor was too ridiculous for words, that it made it so obvious he was involved. Not to mention that she's got a stolen identity, but sleeps with a stranger who asks a lot of questions in a place she's new to? Good grief. Who goes to another country to track down the person who stole their identity? Not only that, but befriends her and..."understands??" Yeah sure. She tanks your your name, your credit, endangers your life, but sure, let her get away with it while her murderous husband tracks you both down. No way on God's green earth or in hell. Her defenses were so low. I really expected (hoped) for a storyline similar to The Net. Not necessarily with the government aspect and intrigue, but this lady made so many mistakes.

I mean, the acting was decent, but this story is so far-fetched and crazy.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
I loved this movie!
alwaysarubino12 March 2018
I loved this movie. It had a great storyline and Lana Parrilla did a phenomenal job acting in it. I would most definitely recommend it to others.
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed