Professor Layton and the Diabolical Box (2007 Video Game) User Reviews

Weakest of the Original Trilogy, But Still Good

[jordyntsmith · 7/10 · 12 April 2022]

The professor and Luke board a train in hopes of uncovering the mystery of the Elysian Box.

This game is a technical improvement over the first - however, the overall story and mystery itself feel disconnected and jumbled. The characters are still fun, but it feels like there is less connecting them together. Flora is practically written off part way through; Don Paolo appearance makes no sense; and the whole train element is abandoned halfway through. The 'villain' on the box art does not make an official appearance until the third act.

The puzzles, artwork, and characters are still a delight - but it feels like they have even less of a reason to be together than they did before. Nevertheless, I still recommended this game to puzzle fans. Ironically, this was my first Professor Layton game growing up, and it was the one that got me hooked.

"Gee professor why did the name change from devil to diabolical box"? "Because my young apprentice Americans are uptight morons about things such as that".

[Aaron1375 · 7/10 · 25 September 2009]

This game is a step up from its predecessor, as the game manages to incorporate a little something called the memo pad to really help you figure out the puzzles. The story is more interesting too, but still it has those puzzles that just want to make you stab that stylus right through the screen. This time around the professor and his young apprentice are on a train after they discover the professor's old mentor apparently murdered at his home. He had been studying something called the "Elyision" box. Well everything points to this train so off they go. The game is really fun there for a while as you ride the train, and stop at a little farming type town. Then you end up at the primary location and even more mystery awaits you here as you hear of ghosts and vampires that may or may not be lurking here. The puzzles are a bit better incorporated into the story, but they could still work on that for another game, and there is a nasty little stretch where the puzzles are nearly all math related and were driving me crazy. However, for the most part I enjoyed them and solved them rather easily. My favorites usually the visual ones. There are also extra things to be done such as the hamster mini game, the putting together the camera game, and a tea game that is rather interesting as well. The game is better than the first one, though I may have had an easier time with this one because a lot of the puzzles are the same just worded differently. Still, the story progresses nicely and it has a rather good ending too and it features one of the best disguised persons ever.

Some improvements over the original, but has new issues too

[robotbling · 26 November 2012]

(www.plasticpals.com) Professor Layton and his peppy sidekick Luke are back in their 2nd grand adventure for the Nintendo DS. This time they're hot on the trail of the Elysian Box, an ornamental artifact said to (gulp) kill anyone who dares open it. The Professor gets a letter from an old colleague about the box and, sensing something is amiss, he and Luke soon discover the old man's body – with the Elysian Box nowhere to be found. The letter included a mysterious ticket (destination unknown) aboard the Molentary Express, which is where the investigation starts to pick up steam.

The Layton games are based on the puzzle books created by Akira Tago, who also designed some brand new puzzles for the video games. They use stylus input only, with the player tapping on characters to begin conversations and on arrows on the map to move around. It's a very simple control set up that just about anyone should be comfortable with, including people who normally never play video games. And thanks to the game's simple progression (talk to characters, solve puzzles, move around, repeat) the game is easy enough for anyone to complete from start to finish. As usual, if you get stumped you can buy hints using hint coins hidden like Easter Eggs in the storybook-like background illustrations.

While the game does present the player with an enjoyable mystery story and a fun cast of characters, the real meat and potatoes are the game's 150 puzzles. They range in difficulty, with many having immediately obvious solutions, while others can be truly vexing requiring a mixture of trial and error and dumb luck. There's a couple of puzzles with trick questions that were slightly annoying, but on the whole the puzzles are well done. There seems to be less logic puzzles in this one compared to the first game, with more puzzles that require you to move pieces (be they pegs on a board, chess pieces, or block mazes).

The Diabolical Box throws a few new ideas into the mix with some mini games you play on the side, that are generally more enjoyable than the furniture arrangement in the first game.

If there's one thing I didn't enjoy as much about this game compared to the first, it would be the story's conclusion, which didn't quite add up. That said, the game leaves you with a warm feeling and takes you to more places than the first (you won't spend much time on the train), and it lasts longer as a result. The production values are also top notch; the artwork, music, and animated cinematic scenes are simply fantastic. Some of the puzzles are based on classics which have been around for centuries which were cool to see. All things considered, Professor Layton & The Diabolical Box is an enjoyable and relaxing game to play.