I was looking forward to this film as I've been waiting for an SML movie for quite some time. So how was this film? Kinda disappointing. I might do a full review on YouTube as I did with Horrid Henry: The Movie, but simply put, this film tends to feel too fast at times due to it's short runtime. It's actually kinda funny since The MAFDOMiNUS Movie (from the same guy) was an hour and 30 minutes, and although I never watched that movie, it's a perfectly acceptable runtime. This movie wants to do a lot, but due to only being an hour overall, the film feels kinda rushed. Also, some characters don't appear as much as they should.
I was also quite disappointed by the lack of characters like Cody, Toad and maybe even Jeffy. The voices are hit-and-miss too. Black Yoshi and Shrek's voice actor does a supreme job as he sounds near-identical to Lance and some like Brooklyn T. Guy's actor do a pretty good job, but Mario barely sounds like he does in the real SML and I'm not fond of Junior's voice as it sounds a bit too obnoxious and whiny (but at least it doesn't sound overly high-pitched like he did in his earlier appearances in SML).
This film is also apparently supposed to be at the end of the SML timeline, so it's a bit strange to see that Mama Luigi is still alive without an explanation or how Rosalina and Jeffy are treated as they don't exist as the film never brings them up. I like to see this movie as instead it's own canon with some inspiration from pre-Jeffy SML, which to be honest, I'm actually perfectly fine with. I actually like how MAFDOMiNUS took more inspiration from the older SML, but created his own version of the universe to not seem like the movie is trying too hard to replicate Logan's style and still be it's own thing whilst staying true to classic SML.
I also liked the premise of Junior and Chef Pee Pee avoiding villains whilst going on a road trip. It honestly does feel in-line to something Logan would have done pre-Jeffy.
But overall, Maf's SuperMarioLogan Movie is a very middling movie to me. It's a shame because there are signs of what could have been a genuinely great movie. I won't be too harsh on this movie though as MAFDOMiNUS seemed very passionate about making an SML movie and it's still an independent production that was made for YouTube with a low budget.
I do definitely think that MAF tried, but there could have been more time to polish the film.