Sister Smile (2009) Poster

(2009)

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Sister Smile jumped the gun.
dbdumonteil4 September 2010
"Soeur Sourire" aka "the singing nun" was a one hit wonder but she achieved the incredible feat of taking the one and only French language song to number one on the billboard charts (the whole month of December 1963);the album did even better than the single,with a total of six weeks at the top (dislodged by "meet the Beatles");there was even a movie feat Debbie Reynolds ,but no follow up to the golden start with "Dominique" .

Soeur Sourire ,after her short moment of glory , was despised, shunned, bullied, ridiculed and persecuted or at least treated with suspicion .A -very mediocre - Neo Nouvelle Vague flick called "Les Idoles featured a caricature of the singer;we could follow the fall of the ex-nun in the tabloids ,the only 'refuge" for the has-beens in Europa.

Soeur Sourire,as depicted in the movie,was actually a woman ahead of her time ;influenced by Vatican II and ...Elvis Presley and rock and roll (we see her performing "Be Bop A Lula" in her convent),she was not prepared for the austere reactionary life among the nuns of the early sixties.Abetted by a young priest,she thought that pop music was a brand new way to get the Christian message across .She did not realize that she was adored as a "singing nun";even without the convent's disapproval ,she would never make it as a laywoman;and the fact that she left the holy orders to live with another woman did not help ,in th sixties when homosexuality -she only reportedly accepted her sexuality at the end of her life-was a taboo subject.(She became a nun just because she was ashamed of feeling like kissing another girl).The first sequence is revealing: a tomboy playing football;her attempts at "femininization" ,notably in Canada ,(making up,trying to have an affair with her manager) are doomed to failure.Her latter songs had nothing to do with the candid sanctimonious "Dominique" and dealt with modern subjects such as the pill,woman's lib,macho men,and the Church itself.

Cecile De France gives an outstanding performance as this unfortunate Belgian woman whose fall was hard.

Anachronisms : in the records shop ,circa 1963-64, you can see a France Gall sleeve which is actually from 1966;a man uses the verb "Niquer" (F....) whereas this word did not become "trendy" before the eighties.
11 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Sister act
jotix1003 December 2010
Warning: Spoilers
The popularity of the "singing nun" was a phenomenon that took the world by surprise. Only on the strength of her internationally famous rendition of her song "Dominique", Jeannine Deckers became an overnight sensation. Little was known, or perhaps we never heard the end of her story, something Belgian filmmaker Stijn Coninx decided to present as a document about the famous nun.

Jeannine Deckers came from a working class family. She was a sort of a tomboy. When we first meet her, she is a girl scout. Jeannine grew up in a catholic environment, typical of the Belgium of the late 1950s. She always adored music; rock and roll was sweeping the world at that moment, so she felt attracted to the genre. Jeannine Deckers decided to dedicate her life trying to help poor Africans. When she joins a religious order, her family is completely baffled.

Ms. Deckers only had a good friend, Annie, who loved her in a different way. Jeannine tried to suppress her lesbian side by hiding in the convent. She had always a rebel streak in her, so it is a miracle she survived the life inside where the nuns were expected to work, pray and prepare themselves to do good. When her beloved guitar, that was confiscated as she entered the seminary, is given back to her, she begins to compose melodies, to which she made lyrics as she worked, based on the actions of the founder of the order.

The success of "Dominique" served to benefit the religious order where she belonged. She went to be a sensation because of her charisma and the way the song resonated with audiences. That same popularity will come back to haunt her. Because of the constrains of convent life, Jeannine decides she must leave to try to make it in the world. Little did she know the world was not ready for her kind of music.

Since her family repudiated her, the only possible solution was to go back to Annie's apartment. Her love for the young woman became a passion. Ultimately, the catholic church was the one that decided Jeannine was now someone they could not promote anymore. In other words, she could not earn the money she was making for the church. An American tour turned out to be a disaster. Jeannine got heavily into drugs and alcohol. When it was evident she had no way out, Annie and her decide to end it all.

The film is documentary style, as many biographies are. The director must be given credit for getting right the atmosphere of the times in which Jeannine lived. Casting Cecile De France in the leading role proved to be a stroke of genius. Ms. De France gives an amazing performance by transforming herself into Jeannine. Sandrine Blancke has some good opportunities in which to shine as Annie. Filip Peeters is also effective playing Antoine Brusson, the man that believed Jeannine had a chance to make it as a singer.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Not a bad movie . . .but still a missed opportunity to kick some asses!
deboraey27 May 2009
Warning: Spoilers
Well, honestly, I must admit that this biopic, based on the life of Jeannine - The Singing Nun -Decksters, is not a bad movie altogether.

Stijn Coninckx has done an excellent job in re-creating the time period - the '60 - and the the day-to-day life in those days. The acting also is quite good, especially Cecile De France (who in fact is a Belgian actress, she was born in Namen, but at 17 she went to Paris to study acting and afterward stayed there) is astonishingly superb as Jeannine. And also Chris Lomme (as mother superior), Jan Decleir (as Jeannine's father), but quite remarkable also is Sandrine Blancke in the small but extremely delicate part of Annie, Jeannine's lover of almost 20 years.

Not a bad movie . . . still it could have been great: Coninckx did his utmost not to step on too many toes!

Decksters was a lesbian - at that time a big problem - and she had a hard time coping with it. After being exploited by the church, she left the convent to go live with her lover Annie, but was in a way pursued and kind of punished by the church, the authorities, the media, . .

She left the convent in '67 and after almost 20 year - in '85 - Jeannine and Annie were totally disappointed, depressed and financially completely ruined . . . and saw no alternative but to commit suicide.

Coninckx doesn't go into all that!

He obviously didn't want to do so because he wanted to make a film for a broad audience! In fact the suicide-scene in the movie is more like a feel-good hallelujah kind of thing; totally absurd - I truly hated that scene!

Well . . .Coninckx made a choice, but also missed an opportunity to make a GREAT movie just by . . showing the TRUTH about Soeur Sourire!

A pity to say the least!
6 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Quite good, but it also feels like a long summation at times.
punishmentpark27 January 2016
Warning: Spoilers
Cécile De France is a lot prettier than the original singing nun, so the film instantly loses some credibility with that. De France does play her part with verve, though. Sandrine Blancke, Marie Kremer and the actor who played her manager (I'm not able to trace his name) are worth a mention as well. Visually, the film is quite fine, and the music (it may be a love it or hate it-thing) is terrific.

The story is a roller-coaster ride of events (not in action sense of the word, but there is just a lot going on with hardly any time to breathe), in which all parties (the main character, her girlfriend, her parents and sister, the nuns, the Catholic church) get their shot at sympathy, even if the Catholic church (rightfully) comes off as a stern institute that will (ab)use its influence every which way it can and feels it must.

Jeannine Deckers herself is a somewhat naive young woman, but with her background and the powerful institute that she takes on, she must also be considered a fighter who deserves a lot of respect. She took her chances, but she was right to get angry with the priest who basically set her up to get hurt. Would she have listened to him if he had advised against her plans to spread her wings? I doubt that, also.

This could have been a very good film if it had taken more time to elaborate on certain aspects of Deckers' life, now it is a pretty good film that tells a remarkable and important story about the struggles of a young female in a society that was at that time severely under the influence of a religious institute. And, considering the fact that this institute (and other religions) is still out there and essentially has not changed much, makes things all the more poignant.

A good 7 out of 10.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
best foreign picture 2009, go for it, Stijn C!
mrdonleone8 May 2009
what a beautiful picture! what a great cast! what a fantastic soundtrack! what a tragic loss! certainly because this world needs songs with lyrics like those of soeur Sourire, here fantastically portrayed by Cecile de France. congratulations Stijn Coninx! I know I keep repeating myself, but this movie is one of the best Belgium has ever made. I can't understand how it was possible to be made, this movie must have cost a lot.

I had no idea this movie was about being gay, so it surprised me. but the peaceful message put me back on the right track: peace and love is the most important thing in the world. yes, I can say this movie has changed my political thoughts completely.

I can't write very well, so I'm going to shut up, but I just want to end with telling how much this picture has got into my heart... no, I can't, you just have to see it for yourself. so bad luck for America, the chances they will see this movie gem are very... hey, wait a minute, let's nominate this with an academy award for best foreign picture 2009!
29 out of 42 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Make the movie or don't make it
m_ats22 July 2011
Warning: Spoilers
Many great works recently have shown us it is possible to create a movie about someone while taking liberties and not telling a factual and linear story. Such is the case of "I'm not There", which is about, or around, Bob Dylan.

Soeur Sourire is not one of those movies.

The movie begins as very linear and conventional, very Hollywoodized; notice how every scene serves to make us understand she is such a free- spirit.. a pseudo-deaf and dumb nun even provides comic relief. Cécile plays the role of Soeur Sourire wonderfully, this could nevertheless have been a great film, until..

well.. until the director, or one of the producers, decided that "post- Ed Sullivan Show" Soeur Sourire's life story was a bit too long and boring and needed to be accelerated and even radically changed.

From that moment in the film, everything goes down hill. When she commits suicide, though in real life she would still live well into the mid-eighties, I didn't care anymore.

Did anyone notice the modern hotel doors with magnetic keys in Montréal ? Very advanced for such a land of medieval backward bigots it is made to be (whereas Belgium and the rest of Europe were of course very liberated in 1967).
2 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A gorgeous, stylish, moving film.
rasputin-231 June 2015
This film was obviously a labor of love... it's perceptible in every frame. I'm surprised it's not better known, because it works in every way. Truly Jeannine Deckers was a woman ahead of her time, even if that world wasn't ready for her. A gay icon, avant-la-lettre. And people ahead of their time sometimes must go through hell, and Jeannine did.

Exquisitely, stylishly photographed, elegantly and suavely edited, and superbly acted and directed, this will be a must-see for those immersed in Catholic theology, women's studies, sexual politics, those immersed in GLBT issues and history, 1960's history, and those who simply loved her 1962 hit, "Dominique" (even though her record was presented maniacally, as a source of bizarrerie in the recent episodes of American HORROR STORY, perhaps unfortunately.) The period details are stunningly accurate throughout... Belgium in the 1960's is flawlessly rendered... every prop, fabric, automobile and hairstyle is note-perfect.

The character obviously representing Ed Sullivan has been given a similar-sounding pseudonym in this film, almost surely because of permission rights in using his name. But anyone with any wit at all recognizes him and his TV show.

This is a film of great subtlety and emotion, and the tour-de-force performance given by the lovely and amazing Cécile de France is stunning. In fact, I feel slightly in love with her after seeing this.

Highly recommended. It is my hope that many GLBT folks worldwide will watch this, especially my sapphic sisters, even if they are less-than-comfortable with watching a foreign film with subtitles. See this! A magnificent gem of a film.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Astonishing character played in a fine movie
lange60017 November 2009
Warning: Spoilers
The story of Soeur Sourire was not familiar at all to me before I saw the movie, so I had no expectations when I went to see it. The story was astonishing but what struck me the most was the amazing character of Jeannine. She was too passionate for this world en destroyed everyone around here searching for this passion. The fact that she was loved and adored till death by Anne gave the movie another, more touching character, which remained with me for several days. In the other comment I read Stijn Coninx somewhat distorted the real story, but this did not spoil my tender feelings for the way the characters of Jeannine and Anne were portrayed. Jan Decleir, Jeannines father, was great in silence. Respect.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed