In 2014, Danielle Gelehrten - "Penny Dreadful" for "Shilling Shockers", was inducted into "The Official Horror Host Hall of Fame".
In 2019, Rebecca Paiva for producer of "Penny Dreadful", was inducted into "The Official Horror Host Hall of Fame", Behind the scream induction.
In 2022, Danielle Gelehrter - "Penny Dreadful" received an honorable mention in the 2021 category of Favorite Horror Host of the 20th Annual Rondo Hatton Classic Horror Awards.