"Pioneers of Television" Science Fiction (TV Episode 2011) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
"Oh, and, by the way, you'll be wearing pointed ears." - Gene Roddenberry to Leonard Nimoy
classicsoncall9 March 2013
Warning: Spoilers
Having watched and been disappointed in the 'Westerns' entry of this 'Pioneers of Television' series, I was somewhat apprehensive in checking out this episode dealing with the early days of Science Fiction. At the height of the Golden Age Western boom, there were dozens of shows that could have been selected to represent the genre, and that was simply impossible in an hour long format. Here, the choices boiled down to three - 'The Twilight Zone', 'Star Trek', and 'Lost in Space', though quite honestly, the bulk of the show was taken up by Gene Roddenberry's space saga that lasted three years on the NBC network.

Back in the day I didn't know it, but 'The Twilight Zone' would wind up being my favorite TV series of all time. Rod Serling was a master story teller and he wrote about ninety of the series' one hundred and fifty two episodes. Though the sci-fi label fits a lot of his stories, I would argue that a lot of them also verged on the realm of fantasy as well. Clips of Serling interviews are inserted into this Pioneers episode, and it's cool to hear his take on coming up with creative concepts for the show.

Where 'Star Trek' broke new ground was in the way it took on issues of race, gender, war, and even such diverse topics as drug abuse and nuclear proliferation. A neat trivia question involves the Trek episode called 'Plato's Stepchildren' which featured TV's very first inter-racial kiss between Captain Kirk (William Shatner) and Lieutenant Uhura (Nichelle Nichols). Groundbreaking at the time, it almost didn't happen when NBC execs were summoned to the set and weighed in against the idea. In a flamboyant move, Shatner and Nichols re-shot the scene with Captain Kirk crossing his eyes to ruin the effect. The original scene stayed as is, and remains somewhat controversial even to this day depending on who's telling the story.

With 'Lost in Space', you've got a whole different animal. The show was a campy adventure series right out of the gate, and producer Irwin Allen was more interested in appealing to youngsters than tackling social issues like Roddenberry. Though I watched the show when it originally aired, I never did quite like it as a teenager, although Angela Cartwright had me show up week after week. I never could figure out how Jonathan Harris took over the show as the villainous Dr. Zachary Scott, but it turns out that was the main reason why - he was so over the top that you wanted to see him get his butt kicked by any monster of the week they could come up with.

Interestingly, when I used to watch 'Star Trek' and 'Lost in Space' in the mid-Sixties, it never occurred to me that they were filmed in color - I only ever saw them in black and white. With the passage of time that puts all of these early shows in perspective, I can only echo the word of my favorite Trek character Dr. Spock when he calmly states - "Fascinating".
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Groundwork for most of science fiction which came later
IClaudius717 July 2011
Warning: Spoilers
Early T.V. had its detractors, to be sure, because of the lack of faith of network bureaucrats, of course, and because they thought the genre should appeal to the lowest common denominator, the "uneducated" public.

While Norman Lear was pushing the limits with humor that made social commentary, "The Twilight Zone" and "Star Trek" was also making social commentary and there was a lot more input from the actors than you might think. Rodman "Rod" Serling found that the job was extremely frustrating because of interference of sponsors, censors, network bureaucrats. Is it any wonder he died at age 50 (largely from tobacco products) but after having made signature episodes which are part of our national psyche.

Likewise, "Star Trek" was pushing the limits with morality scenarios in the artificial environment of the future. Gene Roddenberry was doing something like what Serling had done in "The Twilight Zone" but with a little more science.

"Lost in Space", however, went in the opposite direction and could be likened the worse of the genre because of the cost cutting antics of Irwin Allen, who presumably tried to show the network how much money he could save on costumes by recycling from his other shows such as "Time Tunnel" and "Voyage to the Bottom of the Sea." You WILL learn some things by watching this program and will enjoy the origins of popular science fiction.

The bottom line is that these shows were inspirational as models for young people who later decided on careers in science and for NASA. Enjoy the show !!!
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
train wreck in space
steven-22226 January 2011
Season 1 of Pioneers of Television struck a tone of nostalgia and thoughtful insight that was really special. Season 2 begins with this absolute train wreck. This could be a primer on how not to make a documentary.

With so much great footage to work with, and endless promotional and publicity materials to illustrate the narration, why on earth is so much of the doc made up of hokey, completely unconvincing "re-enactments"? These boring intrusions really break the mood. They're an embarrassment.

The writing is also off, nowhere near the quality of Season 1. The background music is often ridiculously inappropriate. And perhaps some of these talking heads (Shatner, Nimoy, et. al.) have already told their anecdotes one time too may; they seem stale.

This show does not have the stature of PBS programming. It feels like something from a third-tier cable outfit with commercials for Chamwow. This is out of my TiVo queue.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed