Missy refuses to go to school, and forces Molly to let her stay home. Dolores, a nosy neighbor, comes over to complain about cigarette butts on her lawn.
Henry confronts Molly about Jennifer's death after the surprising discovery on their front door. Detective Elliot attempts to get Molly to tell her who killed Jennifer.
In 1995, Molly makes a tough decision about Jennifer. Meanwhile, in 2012, Dolores returns with more evidence about the mysterious neighborhood smoker. Molly receives something disturbing in the mail.
In 1995, Henry and Molly discuss their lives in the park. In 2012, Molly and the children prepare to leave to visit Aunt Trudy. Coco, the family dog, goes missing.
In 1995, Molly brings Henry to her apartment for the first time. In 2012, Henry meets up with Molly as they continue searching for Coco. Missy confronts Molly about the pink box.
In 1996, Henry receives his results from his bar exam. However, he has some surprising news for Molly. In 2012, Missy confronts Molly about who Jennifer really was. Henry contemplates telling someone else about the murder.
In 1996, Henry proposes to Molly. In 2012, Henry decided to tell an old detective friend about what is happening in hopes she can help. In 2044, Molly reveals something surprising to Detective Elliot. The Solloway Family get a surprise visitor.