"Great Performances" Sondheim! The Birthday Concert (TV Episode 2010) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
A glorious tribute to a Broadway legend
TheLittleSongbird22 June 2014
Warning: Spoilers
Count me in as somebody who is very fond of Stephen Sondheim, his melodies are always melodically rich and inventive and the lyrics witty and in instances quotable. A lot of his songs, like Send in the Clowns, are classics and stick in your head for days without being too repetitive, there are songs that rouse the spirits like Ladies Who Lunch and others like Losing My Mind and Not a Day Goes By that have a lot of meaning. This concert and tribute to him is just glorious and a must for any die-hard Sondheim fan. Some may miss the likes of Send in the Clowns or Epiphany, and wish there was more of A Little Night Music and Into the Woods in a programme that is Follies-dominant(not a bad thing, Follies is one of his greatest), but there are still a lot of favourites here and it was also refreshing to hear lesser-known numbers. And performed by performers either of the original cast or have years of experience in Sondheim.

Regarding the concert, there is very little to complain about actually, though the camera work definitely could have been more intimate and less of a at times frenetic music video. The venue is very inviting and gives the performers plenty of space and interaction, nobody looked as though they were stifled. Throughout the music is magnificent with not a single "bad" song, A Glamorous Life is my personal least favourite of the lot but even that song has its charms. The orchestration gives the music the richness it needs and the orchestra not just play beautifully but also know when to be rousing and when to be understated to give the appropriate amount of power and pathos. The conducting doesn't disappoint either, neither does David Hyde Pierce's nimble and amusing hosting or Lonny Price's intelligent direction that never comes across as too busy(even in the showstopper that is America) or too static.

There is so much to like about the performances, though there is a little fatigue in Bernadette Peters' vocal production, one wishes for more of George Hearn- another one of my favourite Sondheim interpreters- and I think something like Another Hundred People or Take Me To The World would have perhaps suited Audra McDonald more, this said she still does a fine job with A Glamorous Life. These come across as minor blemishes, if even that(call it small personal taste) because everything else is as outstanding as it is. America is a showstopper vocally and choreographically, A Little Priest was interesting if strange to have two Sweeney Todds with one Mrs Lovett, Chip Zien and Joanna Gleason are charming in Into the Woods, Mandy Patinkin's Finishing the Hat is done with much emotion and Nathan Gunn gives a haunting rendition of Johanna. In the first half Too Many Mornings stood out and was a huge surprise, McDonald and Gunn are very talented performers but not ones you'd normally associate with Sondheim and they are more than up to the task.

Highlights of the concert were Patinkin and Peters singing Move On, which was heart-wrenching and an extremely close runner-up to the highlight of the first half. Peters is not in her best voice but her rendition of Not a Time Goes By shows her understanding every word and meaning them, she looks like she is really living the emotion of the song and she sings very musically. So regardless of whether she has been better or not, having those things are just as important and more so actually and Peters's artistry really shines through. The second half is even better than the first, mainly because of the "sing-off-of-the-6-divas-in-red". Four of the 6 give among the 5 best performances of the night, the other going to Move On. Marin Mazzie's Losing My Mind was sublime, beautifully sung and incredibly heartfelt, the one time of the entire concert that left me deeply moved. In contrast Patti LaPone's Ladies Who Lunch is genuinely exciting, she is pitch perfect and seems to be really enjoying herself which allows us to do the same. Her consonants are clearer than they can be too. Donna Murphy's Could I Leave You is deeply-felt and quite powerful as well as sung with such passion. And Elaine Stritch closes the concert with I'm Still Here, it was a real crowd pleaser here and it is more than easy to see why, a tad over-acted in places but it is a song where it can be(big emphasis on that) easy to do so.

Overall, just glorious, it was clear that Sondheim himself loved it, the audience did and so did this viewer. 9.5/10 Bethany Cox
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Stereophonic sound made me feel like I was there!
mark.waltz13 October 2016
Warning: Spoilers
A fantastic overture introduces all of those wonderful Broadway performers there to honor Stephen Sondheim on the occasion of his 80th birthday. It seemed that practically every season, Sondheim was represented on the New York City in one way or another, whether it was in a concert of his sings or a revival of one of his classics. Between two productions of "Company", "Follies", "Gypsy", "Sweeney Todd" and "Into the Woods", single revivals of "West Side Story", "Anyone Can Whistle", "Do I Hear a Waltz?", "A Little Night Music", "Pacific Overtures", "Merrilly We Roll Along", "Sunday in the Music", "Sunday in the Park With George", "Passion", " The Frogs" and "Road Show" have all been seen in one way or another in New York. Oh, and all over the country....over and over and over, to the pleasure of many.

There have been many variations of compilation concerts over the years, and although I saw two of them just in the past 10 years, this one I had to settle for on PBS. I was not disappointed, because every one of his shows are represented, plus a few surprises as well. Obscure songs, many standards, and a real party atmosphere to kick things off. Some people complain that Sondheim songs aren't often singable, but for somebody who prefers to listen, that's where the challenge comes in. I like the opportunity to think when I'm at the theater, whether it's a musical play or an Albee or Pinter drama.

The stars, here, are phenomenal, and all you have to do us give a first or last name, their faces come into your mind, the song they are most identified with, and the history of modern musical theater passes through your memory. LuPone, Stritch, Bernadette, Marin, Murphy, Audra. You get the idea. I can never hear enough of "Follies", and even a flop like "Do I Hear a Waltz?" has been added to my list of favorites. I love the similarities between "We're Going to be alright" from "DIHAW" and "Love Will See Us Through" from "Follies", thrilled the first had the original lyrics that were deemed too "controversial" for 1965.

Now with the 86 year old legend preparing for another show, I long to hear what's in the mind of a man who constantly seems open to refresh his shows for changing times. The themes remain the same, simply because they ARE universal AND timeless. I would be thrilled even with a symphony of his instrumental interludes, such as the openings for "Follies" and "A Little Night Music", because he twists the music in ways that no other composer could dream of that are a surprising delight to the ear. Sadly, we've lost two of the performers here, the regal John McMartin and the unsurpassable Elaine Stritch. So many legends in a span of two hours makes for a marvelous party.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed