How to Create a Sex Scandal (TV Mini Series 2023) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Quick binge about greed and Puritanism in a small Texas town.
vandalz8 June 2023
Warning: Spoilers
TIghtly packed, three episode docuseries about the people involved in an alleged child sex ring in a small, conservative Texas town in 2005.

Twenty years before the Mineola case, a moral panic over alleged child sex abuse in day care centers sprung up in Kern County, Ca, and quickly spread to other towns across the United States, as well as Canada, New Zealand, Brazil, and various European countries. The Mineola, case has similarities to those cases, and some important differences. Primarily, the allegations were not made against a daycare center, but rather BY a foster mother, who appears to have used her control over the children in her care to fabricate sensational charges of grooming and abuse of very young children. It is similar to the earlier daycare cases in that there was basically no evidence, just the testimony of very young children. Interviewer bias, manipulation and peer pressure was used to extract "testimony" from the involved children. And, as is too often the case in coerced confessions, only the end result of several hours of grilling and emotional blackmail was shown to jurors.

In a small Bible belt towns, Puritanism is a powerful force. A small "swingers club" of consenting adults had raised the ire of townsfolk who could not abide the fact that some people enjoy the company of others outside a traditional marriage. The townsfolk tried a number of ways to shut down the "swingers club" without success. So when a foster mother linked that group to alleged child molestation, it was ridiculously easy to find a sympathetic prosecutor to take up the case.

It is not a feel-good story. There are plenty of victims and very few heroes. Still, if you have an interest in prosecutorial over-reach and manipulated police interrogations, this will likely interest you.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A Lot of Unanswered Questions
Erik-Movie-Reviews25 May 2023
This was a good documentary that presented a story that was beyond belief. Based on the three Episodes, a number of Adults were convicted of serious crimes due to what was presented as what possibly was the fake and coerced testimony of children.

The Documentary did a good job of presenting the background of the incident and interviewing many of the people involved. They all came across as credible and believable.

While it seems more than likely the accused criminal acts did not take place, it would have been a stronger story if they had:
  • Interviewed someone from the Prosecutors Office, who still believed in the convictions (if any)
  • explained why the older daughter still stood by her original testimony / accusations and explained whether she had reconciled with her parents and siblings
  • explained why only one of the Foster Mother's huge number of foster children, in addition to the two in the documentary, accused her and her husband of abuse.


Even with the questions, the Documentary provides an eye-opening insight into small town / backwoods "Just Us" vs Justice......
12 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
a deception lair...
ops-5253524 May 2023
Warning: Spoilers
En masse', a major case on grooming children, using children as a tool to undermine the sexual acts of adult swingers in the name of god, or was it...???

Well its a story taken out of the text book of the deepest red of redneck rural neighbourhoods of the midwest, eastern texas conseva-tive/tory bible beltish ''feel home''and feel groomed'' lifestyle, where the word of some may weigh hundredfolds the others, in this case adult grown ups being accused for pedophilic acts. The judicial system has only one goal in cases like this , and many lifetime sentences where issued, by the word of children, groomed by and coerced by the ''parent''and the law, using interwiev techniques used in the witch processes of europe 16th century.

I might sound hard and sleasy when writing this, and i do not know what to believe after watching this minitvserie, other than claiming that use of additional help from other fields of judicial operators in the field that has the real knowledge base on interviewing children with parents or fosterparents adjacent, couldve saved quite a few living destynies and soles.

Productionwise they make this a multitude of U-TURNS of feelings, youll feel just as decepted as the ''culprits'' was, so well done there crew and production team. What i do not see or hear though is input from all the other justice departments that mustve been reeled into an investigation like this, with such a booming media coverage this case got and all the trail of disaster and human agony that mustve come out of it, cause being accused for sexual crimes must be the harshest thing in the world if theres nothing in it.

This is a perfect binge and eat kind of ''true'' crime production, the angling of the issues couldve been better, cause they use far too much emotional ,crying and sobbing input from all the parties, in a close up facial manner, never giving you a strait answer what the hevlete happened here...

so just a 7 stars outta 10, the scandalousity screams on top of their lungs, instead of lunging after/towards the system and public mindset of the crimes. Allthough my criticism, its still a recommend, from the grumpy old man.
7 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Difficult watch for the right reasons.
propertoga25 June 2023
Warning: Spoilers
This is one of those documentaries that I decided to watch having zero background knowledge on the topic and leave feeling appalled. Each episode strikes a cord. I do, however, agree with some of the other reviews that say that this feels somewhat exploitative and sensationalized. This case covers very difficult subject matters in the interviewees lives and at times you can tell there were some words twisted for the sake of a plot twist. (i.e. How the kids describe Margie in the first episode as a "motherly type" when it's later revealed that she had manipulated them.) The series ends without any real resolution, and instead feels more like a call-to-action and a way to scrutinize the Texas criminal justice system. Rightfully so. It sheds a damning light on the way that poor people, specifically those viewed as "white trash," are treated by the legal system.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Worth watching
asc857 August 2023
Warning: Spoilers
When I first read about this show, it immediately reminded me of the McMartin Preschool case that rocked California in the 80's. I think that's apt to describe what happened here. I still hesitated to watch this documentary though because it was so lightly reviewed.

But because the few reviews that it received were so positive, I decided to give it a shot.

One of the things I most liked about this series is that it was a lean three episodes. As so many know who watch these true-crime documentaries on Netflix, Hulu, Max, etc., so many of them try to stretch out for as many episodes as possible. Not this one, which I appreciated.

I would have liked to have seen more of the aftermath involving the Cantrells, but I have a feeling there were legal issues and the threat of being sued if the producers said what they really wanted to say and/or showed what they really wanted to show. But other than that, I was glad I saw it.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Twists and Turns Galore in This Scandalous Whodunit!
natmavila29 September 2023
How to Create a Sex Scandal (2023) is a rollercoaster of a documentary that left me equal parts shocked and entertained. Who would have thought that the sleepy town of Mineola, Texas, could be the setting for such a jaw-dropping story? The film's plot unfolds like a true crime mystery, complete with more twists than a pretzel factory. You'll be on the edge of your seat, trying to piece together this scandalous puzzle.

The cast of characters in this real-life drama is so bizarre that you'll think the filmmakers must have created them themselves. It's like a bizarre mashup of a soap opera and a crime thriller, with moments that will make you gasp and laugh in disbelief. How to Create a Sex Scandal had me questioning everything I thought I knew about small-town America, and it's an unforgettable ride that you won't want to miss. Give it four stars and prepare to be utterly captivated by this stranger-than-fiction tale!
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Confusing, exploitative
HlenSki22 June 2023
Warning: Spoilers
I really like a good crime documentary. This was not one. The phenomena is interesting and it's a sad story of manipulation, exploitation, corrupt justice system, small USA rural communities, malicious gossip and a million other things, but the style was not to my liking.

The documentary is telling it's story through dramatic shots of people looking into the distance deep in their thoughts.. There's clips of actual interrogation tapes with old fashioned visual effects to make it seem - shocking and outrageous? I guess that's done in order to emphasize the plot twist later on. But I found it just looks cheap and it's bad taste. I wish they treated the subject with more respect and toned it down a lot. I'm amazed at how people are willing to let cameras into their homes and talk so openly about private matters. I see that the people are quite poor, so there's always a risk of exploiting people's need for money with this type of documentary. I hope ethics were followed. And I wish nothing but the best for the actual people that had to go though these traumatizing experiences.
4 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Pretty clear from the start.
redbaran36030 January 2024
Warning: Spoilers
As soon as I started watching this I put my finger on everything that was wrong from the way the kids were interviewed by the police, they were being lead to tell the story the foster "mother" wanted the police to believe and it's what the police wanted to believe. The idea that the foster parents weren't held accountable for their disgusting actions and helping ruin others lives is beyond frustrating. They just get to live their happy retirement while the kids who were abused under their custody will suffer well pretty much the rest of their lives. Ffs they helped convict their blood parents of these things.

Over all not a bad documentary and idk if everyone figured it out from the moment you see the foster dad's dead eyes and just the many clues in the first episode (especially midway through) but damn. Just sad. So much corruption between prosecutors and the cops, this is just more evidence.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed