Scott Pilgrim Takes Off (TV Mini Series) A League of Their Own (2023) User Reviews

I won!

[Trey_Trebuchet · 7/10 · 2 January 2024]

Man... what a totally different turn this series is already taking. At this point I don't even know what to expect going forward.

And that's not a bad thing. I loved the comics and while this has so far captured the tone and look to a near T, it's not at all the same story. I enjoyed this episode though. The fighting sequence was exceptionally directed, and I love the animation and voice cast.

Scott Pilgrim is pretty absent from what I thought was his show (?), but I don't feel like being too harsh about that yet. This is a series I'm just going to have to trust will get REALLY good, because I've so far only heard really good things. I trust you Bryan!

The dude above me really likes using big words

[ethancurtis2006 · 17 December 2023]

This isn't a review of the show, I think it's kinda fascinating taking an entirely different take of the same material. I love both the comic and the show (I've been meaning to re-read since I haven't since middle school) but goddamn does the only review on this episode, this person really just likes using big words to make themselves seem irrefutable. I would go as far as to bet that the fact that I'm not putting gender to the pronouns I'm using for them would also cause an outrage. Blah blah blah, the show looks gorgeous, all the voices are fantastic and its great that they are doing something different as opposed to just trying to make a tv show that is frame for frame the comic book. If you want that, just get off your ass and read the story for yourself.

Unnecessary? Political correction?

[cgaraned · 2/10 · 22 November 2023]

When delving into Scott Pilgrim's second chapter, you immediately confront with plenty of frames that seem superfluous, contributing little to the overall narrative. Trimming these excesses could undoubtedly enhance the flow of the storytelling, allowing for a more concise and engaging experience.

Regrettably, the chapter's shortcomings extend beyond mere verbosity. Essentially, it fails to make a compelling case for its indispensability. You could skip this chapter without sacrificing the coherence of the series, potentially leading to a more enjoyable experience overall. The narrative, at times, meanders without adding significant depth or nuance to Scott's character or the overarching plot.

Moreover, the fight sequences in Chapter 2 are marred by a sense of childish absurdity. While a touch of whimsy can inject life into a storyline, the exaggerated and seemingly purposeless movements in this chapter verge on the nonsensical. Instead of contributing to the development of the characters or advancing the plot, the fights come across as gratuitous displays of physicality, lacking the finesse and meaning that make action sequences truly resonate with the audience.

In scrutinizing the chapter's artistic choices, it becomes evident that a more judicious approach to framing and choreography could have elevated the storytelling. Cutting down on unnecessary panels and refining the fight scenes to convey a more mature and purposeful tone would undoubtedly benefit the narrative.

Ultimately, Scott Pilgrim Chapter 2 falls short of its potential, burdened by redundant details and juvenile fight sequences. For those seeking a more immersive and coherent experience with the series, skipping this chapter might be a prudent choice. A discerning edit to streamline the storytelling and infuse greater meaning into the action could transform this installment into a more integral and enjoyable part of the Scott Pilgrim saga.

I don't know if this is one of the many episodes of political correction of Netflix screwing up a perfectly good serie.