I went into this episode with a lot of high hopes, given the great things I'd heard about it from reviews and aggregators. The episode is... OK, to my mind. The first 10-15 minutes are not particularly funny, with the exception of the intro. But this is really only buildup to what happens in the last ten minutes, which is I believe what everyone focuses on.
The episode telegraphs its shocking event early on, hoping we will go "oh please no" through the episode. But there is no real tension to my mind - the writers of Bojack Horseman always take the harshest/worst option and knowing that robs the episode of the tension I've heard so many describe. It's going to happen so there's no surprise and no payoff. It's expertly bleak and dark and it shows the worst of our protagonist, but it doesn't make it the classic I'd heard that it was.
I think Bojack nails it when the dark, depressing stuff comes out of nowhere - compare this episode to The Telescope, Downer Ending, Brand New Couch, Hank After Dark, Yes And or even Let's Find Out (which to my mind are the best episodes of the show and superior compared to this).
All of these episodes do something dark, to varying levels, but it's unexpected or surprising and it's more expertly mixed with comedy, and that's where the emotional depth kicks in. I think, however, that the writers become more predictable when they try to set up something so obviously in this way and this episode, sadly, did not work for me for that reason.
This episode is in the "emotional powerhouse" slot that Downer Ending was in and the show's season 2 F-bomb appears here, unsurprisingly given which character used it last season and who uses it this season (mild spoilers ahead).
At the risk of being meta, this made the episode more predictable in terms of where it was going and robbed the usage of the F word of its power. When Herb says it in Season 1, I was astounded. Hearing Charlotte say it in this season was not surprising because I expected it from a character close to Bojack from the past, like Herb was. It's copying a previous trope, which is a bit unimpressive.
That said, this episode is really well made and artful and it's amazing to see animated TV go to the places it goes to - so this still gets a 7. But it shows the dangers of hype: I watched this episode expecting something sensational, and I was disappointed.
15 out of 78 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink