Cast (in credits order)
| Kevin Clash | ... | Elmo / Benny Rabbit (voice) | |
| Michael Jeter | ... | Mr. Noodle | |
| Rest of cast listed alphabetically: | |||
| Stephanie D'Abruzzo | ... | Wisdom Tooth (voice) | |
 |
Ron Marshall | ... | TV Announcer (voice) |
| Andrea Martin | ... | The Tooth Fairy (voice) | |
|
|
Jim Martin | ... | Computer (voice) |
| Jerry Nelson | ... | Count von Count (voice) | |
Animation Department
| Joey Ahlbum | ... | animator |