Eleanor considers Michael's belief that he is the neighborhood's problem and, thus, should abandon his experiment of an architect living in a neighborhood he designed (effectively meaning he would leave the neighborhood forever) as a win-win situation, as Michael will get the retirement he so rightly deserves and needs, and she will no longer feel the stress of getting caught by him as a fraud and the true cause of the neighborhood's problems. Chidi, on the other hand, disagrees, as Eleanor's reasoning is built on a lie. Eleanor concedes that she has to reconsider Michael's move after they all learn what retirement for a being like Michael means, it being called the eternal shriek. Eleanor comes up with another solution to the problem, but it would require a sacrifice. Chidi is conflicted by Eleanor's solution, as he vowed to help her but still feels the sacrifice is morally wrong despite it not hurting "anyone". Through the process, Chidi remembers back to a lie he said on Earth, one that consumed his inner soul as wrong despite, much like the sacrifice, its negative impacts being somewhat minuscule in the grand scope of life and which, conversely, made its recipient happy.
—Huggo