Het hart van Hadiah Tromp (2018) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
4/10
Badly acted romcom
vampierusboy17 February 2018
Warning: Spoilers
In the Netherlands there are the so-called telefilms, films made for television all around a certain theme, sponsored by the public television. There are a total of six films. This year the theme is romcom, so prepare yourself. Romcom is by far the genre most Dutch commercial movies are made in. Big sponsored movies with the same plots and mostly the same actors even. Although there are of course some funny moments to be had, nothing really stands out. A nice try for the more indepedent and new filmmakers in the telefilms cycle to brush up the genre. This movie is the first installment in this cycle.

The concept is quite ok. Hadiah Tromp, a rebellious lady, signs up for the strict navy, mostly to please her father, a high-ranking navy officer. Although she doesn't want to return after her first training, she does return for naval training on the North Sea because of a break-up. Here she meets Paul Borremans, her junior officer and very strict follower of rules, and you never believe what happens next.

This movie works on certain levels. The setting in a navy ship, with many crew members and small hallways, is quite original and makes the romance part a bit more interesting. The other characters are nicely done and live up to romcom-tropes. The uptight fellow cadet, the strict captain, the jealous fellow officer and the funny friends of the main character. The story is as romcom as you can get and there is also a musical theme to it, with characters breaking out in sing and dance but done in such a way that it doesn't really count as a musical in my opinion.

Where this movie gets his low rating from me is the acting and script overall. Chloé Leenheer's acting falls flat almost every time. Lines are delivered flatly and feel almost forced. 'The line is in the script, so I have to say it' It seems they where trying to go for a quirky girl which combines the strict navy moral of her father with the easy free going spirit of her deceased Jamaican mother. This actually results in a spoiled brat which motivations are never clear. Which is strange because the movie results in mostly stating the emotions instead of acting. The other characters, as mentioned mostly consist of tropes, have the same deliverance. Peter Heerschop, although a funny comedian, doesn't really fit well as the dad. A lot of the actors looked mostly chosen for their navy fysique than their acting abilities. Although there are some actors who did a good job, Jacqueline Blom as the strict captain, Mike Weerdt as the jealous officer and mostly a shout-out forKorneel Evers for the stoner guy, which I found one of the most funny characters in the film.

To go on about the script/screenplay, this movie tried in my opinion to hard to be a romcom and the script tried to incorporate to many tropes in this movie. This resulted in half written story-lines for characters, who sometimes totally disappear from the movie. Hadiah had a onshore black friend who appears in one scene and is never seen again. The same goes in the final part of the movie for the uptight fellow-cadet who the last half hour is nowhere to be found, only to return briefly in the ending credits. The motivation and deeds of Hadiah are weird in the latter half of the movie, even ignoring the bad acting job. It is weird she protects the officer who tried to sexually harrass her over Paul Borremans who tried to protect her but she had a fall-out with. Maybe there is a director's cut where the movie is more fleshed-out but now it felt that the script was only half done and tried to much in the time it was given. In short. Movie with a cool concept in the romcom scene, but looses itself in bad acting and a screenplay which wants to much but can't deliver.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
It failed on the script
Arconada18 March 2018
Watching this movie I got the impression that everybody wanted to make a good movie. The idea was a lighthearted romantic comedy with a few song and dance interjections. However, a good movie starts with a good script, and it looks to me it failed because of that. Unrealistic dialogues, implausible twists and cardboard characters made me loose all willingness to follow this story. To bad, because you can notice the effort everyone made.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
funny
tataubaby25 August 2019
This movie funny, the character of Hadiah, a half Jamaican girl likes oldskool ska. Eventhough it was quite lowbudget made according to this page, it had some nice musical sequences, even on a sailing navy ship on open water! We liked the funny and sometimes surreal twist and the parodical navy chats. Chloe Leenheer plays a memorable role and the soundtrack with all the ska songs on it was very well done!
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
wonderful film
senizege8 September 2022
I Like it, this Film it a Musical Romance. The actors was also good. I found the beginning to be funny, Chloe Leenheer is amazing in the movie but it is cringeworthy to see her romancing Valentijn Benard, I just did not see them as a couple in this movie, post interval you can barely tolerate it, there is unnecessary drama, a movie that could have easily ended in 90 minutes is dragged and dragged. Watching this movie I got the impression that everybody wanted to make a good movie. The idea was a lighthearted romantic comedy with a few song and dance interjections. However, a good movie starts with a good script, and it looks to me it failed because of that. Unrealistic dialogues, implausible twists and cardboard characters made me loose all willingness to follow this story. To bad, because you can.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed