Supernatural (TV Series) Nightmare Logic (2018) User Reviews

Back at it!

[taraelaine87-677-550398 · 9/10 · 10 November 2018]

I love that the brothers are back to fighting individual monsters!

Different... but the same and drama

[shwetafabm · 7/10 · 9 August 2020]

I quite enjoyed the ep and Mystery. The whole monster thing is well good, we reached a stage where monsters weren't a threat at all especially after Dean came out of purgatory so the concept is sort of bringing newness. The thing i didn't like was the Mary and Bobby drama, i just don't care. I think the Kripke, Gamble era was very bold, even though we joke about how much Sam and Dean die if you remove the goof deaths of Dean in mystery spot and Sam's in wishing well episode, the deaths meant something very big each time. Carver was ok with it too. It just feels like Dabb is trying this sticking to old characters thing too much. It's honestly taking away from what grounded the show. Bobby and Mary are not good additions. They would have been great for nostalgia for a one time thing but not this...Cas was the main problem of not letting a character go, then Crowley but fine it was understandable, they were basically leads too... This is too much. Let characters go. Also seems to me that the thing had only one way of dying and it wasn't done... Strange.

I wish they developed these ideas more

[CubsandCulture · 8/10 · 22 October 2021]

Michael changing monsters and the few episodes they did around that concept help make the show feel fresh again. The Jinn here for example keeps you guessing what the plot solution is which after 14 years of this show is hard to do. I also like that Bobby 2.0 is given a radically different backstory and demeanor from Bobby. I wish the show explored both of those concepts more.

As it is this episode feels like the start of something great that never really goes anywhere and it ends up being an unsatisfactory tease.

Unreal episode

[ozsvart-karoly · 6/10 · 19 August 2019]

The fact that the alternate Bobby survived (not just survivde, took it out of his chest and fought afterwards...) this episode after a stab to his heart / lung... This is just ridiculously unreal. So sad.

Too Many Characters

[magnum-ajt · 5/10 · 9 November 2018]

Fan since episode 1. Mary has overstayed her welcome and fake Bobby isn't as good as real Bobby.

Boring and horrible fight scenes

[martatro · 3/10 · 1 December 2020]

God i was so bored watching this episode and the fight choreography was so bad it didnt look real at all

Way to Bata for a Alpha show.

[mm-39 · 4/10 · 12 November 2018]

What made Supernatural a hit was Supernatural was the red meat/Alpha male show it was. Mostly because Dean was so non P C that it hurt. Supernatural was a backlash to the Murphy Browns, and Ali Mc Beal's P C scripts which was forced feed in the 90's with almost every show. Almost no action shows back then. Supernatural was the back lash show of P C culture. A story of two brother who fight and love each other with cheap humor, and horror movie offensive stereo types which made a cheesy in a good way t v series. Nightmare Logic episode has too many characters, who have to share there feelings. The old Dean would say you share too much lol. Everyone including the hunters hugs each other at the end which would made the old Dean cringe. The cast looks like all Beta character the old series made fun of with the old Ghost Facers episode. New Beta Bobby character is into feelings and everyone has to relieve their emotional baggage ugh. The new Bobby fits in with what the old Bobby would call Supurnatural meets Vampire Diaries Soap Opera. The middle of Nightmare Logic had me watch for the conclusion, but lack the humor and the bite of previous episodes. 4 stars.