My husband and I saw this movie last night. Both of us for some reason were
expecting a comedy -- and it wasn't until about halfway through the movie that I was able to completely give up on it turning into one. There were perhaps three moments at which the audience laughed (one of which I found quite sad and not funny at all!)
First I will say that I thought the acting was very good and the casting, except Matthew Modine in a strange role, was well done. However, I can't recommend
the movie overall because I didn't find it compelling and almost completely
devoid of real emotion.
The plot involves two sisters, one visiting the other in Paris, and while most of the action focuses on one sister and her romantic adventures, the other sister is kind of left in the background, even though her story might have provided more emotional depth to the story. Weighty events occur but are treated pretty lightly - - I don't want to give anything specific away, but let me say that if these kinds of things happened to *my* family, there would be a lot more uproar and reaction!
I gave the movie a 6, only for effort, and for casting and acting ability. I guess the overall disappointment we felt stemmed from the movie not seeming to be a
comedy, nor a tragedy, nor a romance, nor a drama, nor an adventure movie. It contained elements of all of these, but they didn't hang together well at all. If you like watching Kate Hudson smiling adorably, you might enjoy the movie, since
she does this frequently. If you want a movie that successfully blends emotion, drama, and levity, may I recommend "Lovely and Amazing" instead?
expecting a comedy -- and it wasn't until about halfway through the movie that I was able to completely give up on it turning into one. There were perhaps three moments at which the audience laughed (one of which I found quite sad and not funny at all!)
First I will say that I thought the acting was very good and the casting, except Matthew Modine in a strange role, was well done. However, I can't recommend
the movie overall because I didn't find it compelling and almost completely
devoid of real emotion.
The plot involves two sisters, one visiting the other in Paris, and while most of the action focuses on one sister and her romantic adventures, the other sister is kind of left in the background, even though her story might have provided more emotional depth to the story. Weighty events occur but are treated pretty lightly - - I don't want to give anything specific away, but let me say that if these kinds of things happened to *my* family, there would be a lot more uproar and reaction!
I gave the movie a 6, only for effort, and for casting and acting ability. I guess the overall disappointment we felt stemmed from the movie not seeming to be a
comedy, nor a tragedy, nor a romance, nor a drama, nor an adventure movie. It contained elements of all of these, but they didn't hang together well at all. If you like watching Kate Hudson smiling adorably, you might enjoy the movie, since
she does this frequently. If you want a movie that successfully blends emotion, drama, and levity, may I recommend "Lovely and Amazing" instead?
Tell Your Friends