There is a school of thought that says all movies should be compared on an absolute scale. It would say that movies must have a high level of credibility or familiarity in order to be "good" movies. People who fall into this category simply should not watch Top Gun. They won't enjoy it. Other people take the opposite, but no more valid approach of looking a each movie individually, disregarding all else but the movie. For these people, no outside reality or credibility is important, because for them, a movie exists to entertain in whatever way it chooses to. These people would enjoy Top Gun very much. It is extremely doubtful that the producers ever even considered making Top Gun as a portrait of a fighter pilot's life, and this is why it is entertaining. It is a rare type of movie, one that no one dares to make today, one that not only transcends reality, but wears it as a mask into the world of fantasy. Everything from the wild dogfights to the fake love to the over the top glamorized (or should I say canonized) characters lets you know that this is a good old American hero drama. That is why it is a horrible and fraudulent portrait of reality, and that is why I love it.
Reviews
2 Reviews
Battlefield Earth
(2000)
Flawed, but good fun. 3 of 5 stars
15 May 2000
Battlefield Earth suffers from two primary flaws: horrible dialogue, and a touch of predictability. The dialogue seems childish, and often overuses modern cliches, which seems painfully out of place in the future setting (e.g. an alien saying "don't blow a head gasket") Predictability is limited to a lack of anything you wouldn't expect when going to see the movie. There are no unexpected plot twists to keep you on the edge of your seat. Nothing unusual, however, does not imply that there is nothing cool. The whole harrier jet sequence and the visual effects in general almost justify the ticket price themselves. All in all, the ticket price is made worthwhile by the simple escapist fantasy fun of the movie.
Tell Your Friends