So you can look at Saving Private Ryan as two movies. First, we have the invasion of Europe. I watched this movie the day it came out. Nothing that realistic had ever hit the big screen prior. A movie that showed the true horrors of war was a concept that earlier war movies never came close to portraying.
Next we have the search for private Ryan. This becomes purely Hollywood. To truly understand why the last 3/4 of this movie is really fiction, I believe you would've had to have served in the military. In each of the major scenes in the search for private Ryan, it shows troops willfully being disobedient to orders. That just doesn't happen in the military, especially with elite units such as the Rangers. In the military, you are given an order, you say yes, sir, and you carry out the order. Captain Miller allows the disobedience to occur over and over. In the actual military, he would've been relieved command.
That being said, the second half of the movie is still a good Hollywood version of warfare. If I could rate the invasion separately, I would rate it at 10 and the second half, for reasons mentioned above, I would rate it a seven.
Next we have the search for private Ryan. This becomes purely Hollywood. To truly understand why the last 3/4 of this movie is really fiction, I believe you would've had to have served in the military. In each of the major scenes in the search for private Ryan, it shows troops willfully being disobedient to orders. That just doesn't happen in the military, especially with elite units such as the Rangers. In the military, you are given an order, you say yes, sir, and you carry out the order. Captain Miller allows the disobedience to occur over and over. In the actual military, he would've been relieved command.
That being said, the second half of the movie is still a good Hollywood version of warfare. If I could rate the invasion separately, I would rate it at 10 and the second half, for reasons mentioned above, I would rate it a seven.
Tell Your Friends