I've watched this movie a few times before I read or even knew of the book/books, and I still enjoy it for it's adventure and fantastical themes. I recently finished the novel for the first time, finally! It takes a long time for it to get going and there's quite a bit of a stopping and starting in it's length, which delayed me in finishing it. People say this movie is very unfaithful to the book but I disagree, some of it is altered or rearranged yes but otherwise it's actually cleverly carved out. Now there are some big changes like a certain characters death, and the final battle being different in the book but in my opinion is more exciting in this film; though the only main casualties are that the characters are not developed enough due to certain elements being cut out.
Murtagh for example is not developed enough, which is a shame as his character is very interesting in the novel. The bond between Saphira and Eragon is also shrunken in this film, which is a shame as Eragon comes off as less compelling in this film then he is in the novel; for the most part anyway as there are chapters where I groaned at him. In the novel his experience with raising Saphira are some of my favourite moments in the book so it's disappointing that some of that wasn't extended into the movie; but that's a minor thing.
As I said earlier this film isn't as inaccurate as some would claim, as some parts of it are just not narrated upon; for example Arya's imprisonment at the hands of Durza. I loved Durza in this film!! Robert Carlyle did a fantastic job in the role and all though he's in this more than he should be based upon the novel, I think it would've been an equal crime to waist such great casting and talent. I also loved Saphira in this movie, she and Durza are the highlights for sure.
If this movie had been 15-20 minutes longer I think it would've been better received, as another casualty with the run time is that the relationship between Brom and Eragon is rushed and a lot of the heart and bonding between the two of them is missing from this film.
Murtagh for example is not developed enough, which is a shame as his character is very interesting in the novel. The bond between Saphira and Eragon is also shrunken in this film, which is a shame as Eragon comes off as less compelling in this film then he is in the novel; for the most part anyway as there are chapters where I groaned at him. In the novel his experience with raising Saphira are some of my favourite moments in the book so it's disappointing that some of that wasn't extended into the movie; but that's a minor thing.
As I said earlier this film isn't as inaccurate as some would claim, as some parts of it are just not narrated upon; for example Arya's imprisonment at the hands of Durza. I loved Durza in this film!! Robert Carlyle did a fantastic job in the role and all though he's in this more than he should be based upon the novel, I think it would've been an equal crime to waist such great casting and talent. I also loved Saphira in this movie, she and Durza are the highlights for sure.
If this movie had been 15-20 minutes longer I think it would've been better received, as another casualty with the run time is that the relationship between Brom and Eragon is rushed and a lot of the heart and bonding between the two of them is missing from this film.
Tell Your Friends