2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Many old ideas mixed with a few new ones. Watch if you don't want to be left out of potential future plotlines.
1 September 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Beginning with the merits of this episode, 1. The unique style of shading, design is eye catching. Some moments are quite wallpaper worthy.

2. Voice acting was good I suppose, but people do have mixed reactions to it. Many original actors have reprised their roles.

Many things could have been done better, but I feel the main culprit here is the runtime. Marvel stories work quite good when we have good pacing and character development to help us root for the characters.

My main issue here was so many plot points one after the other, which end up not mattering in the end. 'Heartless Doctor Strange' here wins over his better self, and is still trapped in the pocket universe.

The first 10 minutes have a standard time altering storyline- hero loses girl, makes a lot of effort (disproportionate I must say) and finds himself unable to change the past. We then see the Ancient One here, who tries to stop him and eventually uses Dark dimension magic to split Strange into two selves, one who moves forward with saving Christine and one who stays behind and comes to terms with Christine's death. The heartless Strange then finds himself at the Lost Library Of Cagliostro. He spends centuries there trying to reverse an Absolute point in time (Christine's Death). A gatekeeper at the library is there just to be alive for those centuries and tell Strange he is just half of a life.

Good Strange battles Bad Strange, Good Strange is defeated, Christine comes alive but disintegrates. The Watcher talks with Bad Strange, denies help. I think they are just juggling a lot of moving pieces to keep us interested.

Also, why does the Ancient One in this world not know about other universes? Or Evil Strange after centuries of study for that matter? This episode is the most like the old Twilight Zone episodes, just made to show us a dark but pretty concept.
10 out of 53 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
What If...? (2021– )
Good animation, poor pacing, quite disappointing really.
11 August 2021
Warning: Spoilers
I was very excited about the What If series, on a level similar to LOKI.

The first episode has Agent Carter becoming Captain Carter, and the episode feels as if someone was describing a movie to me in a rushed manner. Obviously there are references to the original MCU for YouTubers to microanalyze, but it almost comes off as a simple kids show with characters fighting and blowing stuff up.

The show could have had a much better story, because after all, we are dealing with the multiverse here. Instead Captain Carter still returns from the inter dimensional void after 70 years, and has not aged much here ( Tesseract was the space stone, not the time stone right?), Bucky and Steve are dead probably, and Nick Fury and Clint Barton still end up in 2012 working on the Tesseract. The writers must have skimped on the brainstorming part here. And how did WW2 era Stark design the Hydra Stomper so fast? Or how did Red Skull have the portal machine for Tesseract ready and waiting, when just a while back they discovered it?

The animation is good, though the characters reach quite close to the uncanny valley, as you keep comparing them to the live actors. The facial features which look quite good in stills and feature art seem unnatural animated. The charm of the respective actors on screen is lost in this.

At this point I am just hoping they do Chadwick Boseman justice here.
113 out of 216 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed