Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Star Trek: The Way to Eden (1969)
Season 3, Episode 20
1/10
Lost its Way
31 October 2007
"The Way to Eden" begins a string of episodes that almost makes Trek fans glad the series ended when it did. The premise is laughable (helping space hippies find their paradise), as is the story. Very little of what made the series such a groundbreaking one was evident as it limped toward cancellation in the final episodes, and this one is a good (or bad) example of a show that had simply lost warp capability.

Leonard Nimoy, as usual, brings some humanity to Spock, as we see in him a genuine desire to help the hippies in their quest. He seems to empathize with their plight of a search for meaning in a cold universe, and it helps us understand a little more about his human/Vulcan dichotomy. There's nothing really enlightening about this quest, however. No high-minded values or flights from persecution are evident to help the viewer sympathize with the hippies.

And while no series hits the mark every time, and one as far-reaching and ambitious as Trek deserves some forgiveness in criticism of those ideas that simply don't work, these final few episodes are just hard to watch.

With the exception of the interesting Spock regression in "All Our Yesterdays," "Way to Eden" clearly marks the beginning of a very disappointing end. When you review this episode together with the others that follow: "The Cloud Minders," "The Savage Curtain" (I mean, really, a talking rock! Possibly the second-worst Trek episode just ahead of "The Lights of Zetar") and the final episode, "Turnabout Intruder," it becomes obvious that Star Trek's creative resources were in full retreat. As they say in the TV world, the series had jumped the shark.
27 out of 53 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Star Trek: Requiem for Methuselah (1969)
Season 3, Episode 19
7/10
Requiem for a series
2 February 2007
Arguably the last good episode of Star Trek ("All Our Yesterdays" features an interesting plot line with Spock and Mariette Hartley), "Requiem for Methuselah" is among the more literate scripts the series offered. Jerome Bixby demonstrates his considerable science-fiction writing ability in his well-drawn Flint character, adeptly brought to life by veteran TV actor James Daly. While this episode is almost farcical in its accelerated Kirk/Rayna love-story arc, the concept of Flint as an immortal conglomeration of the some of the greatest minds in human history and Spock's gradual realization of this secret are intriguing and engaging. What also makes this episode memorable is that it stands out so far above the largely forgettable third season, and a touching scene between Kirk and Spock helps an otherwise schlocky ending. "Methuselah" belongs nowhere near the pantheon of the likes of "Naked Time" or "City on the Edge of Forever," but it was a final reminder of what made the series so special.
45 out of 56 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed