Villeneuve once again delivers with his epic spaces and poetic cinematography which does a lot of depicting on the visuals for the book reader. What he does lack is the life in those characters except a couple maybe. A lot of screentime comes in the form of visions that aren't carrying the story forward yet blurring the very little that we are told. For a book reader that can still remember the story, not much is lost but I suspect a lot of confusion and misunderstanding for someone lacking the background knowledge of the setting. What's a mentat? Why are Sardaukars feared? What is the Landsraat? We are spared from critical info that would draw our interest in the story. So many characters having barely a couple of minutes or less, their lines compacted while there is no shortage of a myriad of visions with Zendaya. All together, there is a sense of sterility and disconnection that is hard to describe but permeates the movie. We go through the motions of the story but I found myself reminiscing the parts from the book at times instead.
While this is a technically very well shot, impressive movie but I'm not able to say that it's the treatment Dune deserved. I can only hope that in my lifetime, there will be another adaptation by a director who can focus on the story and characters instead of just the visuals and sound. I'll try to hang around for another 37 years.
While this is a technically very well shot, impressive movie but I'm not able to say that it's the treatment Dune deserved. I can only hope that in my lifetime, there will be another adaptation by a director who can focus on the story and characters instead of just the visuals and sound. I'll try to hang around for another 37 years.
Tell Your Friends