Okay, as you can see in my primary summary, I think that we are all so mindlessly SPOILED by the expectation that EVERY film (ESPECIALLY a Science Fiction movie) absolutely HAS to knock us off our feet or we think it sucks! Right? C'mon now, be honest.
I'll prove it: Take the Pilot Movie to "Night Gallery" (1969) Television, right? VERY little in the way of special effects, right? But, it's a great little film! Granted it is much better quality, still, than "A Sound of Thunder", but my point is, see how spoiled we are due to the 'standard' that we set for ourselves? Now, if say, 'ASoT' had been shown on television not that terribly long ago with ONLY those expectations of tele special effects, wouldn't we just have sat back and enjoyed it and thought it was a pretty darn good film? (Let me tell you, I STARTED to watch the VERY fancy and expensive television production of 'Merlin' which they probably spent about the same amount of money on back then that they did on 'ASoT', and let me tell you, the WRITING and ACTING was SOOOOOOO abysmal, although I like the source story and even some of the actors, I just COULDN'T stomach it!!! And most people thought that was a wonderful show! This film blows that out of the water!!!) Another thing, YES comparing the brilliant and wonderful short story by the EXTREMELY talented Mr. Bradbury with this film shoots it way down; that's completely understandable. To me, it's just like David Lynch's film "Dune"; sure, compared to the rarefied brilliance of the book(s) it's gonna suck. But the key is: VIEWED SEPARATELY as a STAND ALONE story, they're not that bad, really.
I just NOW got back from seeing it; and yes, after reading all these VERY predictable 'reviews' I was steeled and determined NOT to expect ANYTHING... And I mean ANYTHING! So I sat there and kept expecting it to start to COMPLETELY suck, and it never really did. Now, keep in mind I absolutely LOATHE Peter Hyams direction!!!! As soon as I found out that this beloved short story was directed by him, I was totally depressed for days!!! : ) I HATE his absolute love and fascination with 'Hey, lets put the people in a completely DARK PLACE ("Relics", etc.) and 'Hey, lets do LOTS of fast editing and flashes of light!!!' wow... HATE IT!!! But, still the story, acting and basic suspense level and such, considering that they had to alter the story line RADICALLY, I think it could have been done a LOT worse.
Take a moment and think now of ALL the FRIGGIN' films that just INSULT the absolute daylights out of us!!! NOW THAT is what I am tired of! POOR writing, POOR acting, just plain insulting the audience. But, I honestly did NOT get that impression at all from this film. Sure, I still didn't care too much for the LONG sequences while they were traveling at night and in the 'subway' and such. Personally, without giving too much away, I would like to have seen the story element included that was in the book as to what they saw immediately when they came back where everything had been COMPLETELY changed, say perhaps after that last 'WAVE' took effect, and THEN have them work within THAT completely changed history toward the END of the film to try to fix everything.
*************** MINOR SPOILERS ************************ I do think that it was VERY clever to come up with the changes coming in 'WAVES'; I was wondering how they were gonna do the short story in full running time format according to the original story. Smart way to do it and not NEARLY as insulting and eye-rolling as the mind numbingly stupid pseudo-techno-sh*t that Rick Berman tries to get us poor Star Trek fans to swallow in his more recent 'efforts'. And, I thought that taking the story along the lines of the actual evolutionary lines being changed was clever; again, I would have rather seen them work in, perhaps in that last 'WAVE' where there was the totalitarian regime in power and where that fringe political leader actually did get elected, and THEN have them try to sneak around and try to fix stuff.
******************** END OF MINOR SPOILERS ********************* Anyway, I think that Hollywood has (like bloody Everything ELSE in this 'culture' spoiled us to where we can't just simply enjoy a neat little story without saying, 'This is TOTAL crap!!!' I feel very strongly about this, especially concerning this particular film; I mean, if the acting or writing or even the direction (overtly)had TRULY been lousy, then I'd be the first one to say, 'Hey, you're all right, it SUX!!!' but I quite honestly do not think that was the case.
4 out of 9 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends