I usually don't like it when film reviewers complain about the choices the director or writer makes and says 'they should have done this instead.' My attitude to that usually is 'I'd prefer it if you review the film actually made and not the one you wish was made.'
However, other people have already reviewed this episode as it is. There are two problems here with the episode as written:
1.They came up with a potentially great story of a serial killer (this term wasn't used in the episode) and then dispensed with it about half way through to turn it into a bomb disposal episode.
They could have made a great episode about how they figured out how the killer was able to do all the things that he did (which have been mentioned like his closing the doors) or they could have had a killing gang which would have made this much more possible. I even thought up the idea that everybody on the ship were the killers in that it was all a plot to lure The Angels on board because everybody was placed in jail by Charles Townsend and they were looking to get even with him. (I have no idea how that could have played out.)
2.The way Gorshin, who played The Riddler on Batman, gets caught is, as previously mentioned, that he falls for the ruse that Kelly was killed. I realize his clairvoyance might not work all the time, but it must have worked enough for him to have committed the murders, and this sure was an inconvenient time for it to fail on him.
Or, did he not really have clairvoyance...Don't want to take this episode too seriously.
However, other people have already reviewed this episode as it is. There are two problems here with the episode as written:
1.They came up with a potentially great story of a serial killer (this term wasn't used in the episode) and then dispensed with it about half way through to turn it into a bomb disposal episode.
They could have made a great episode about how they figured out how the killer was able to do all the things that he did (which have been mentioned like his closing the doors) or they could have had a killing gang which would have made this much more possible. I even thought up the idea that everybody on the ship were the killers in that it was all a plot to lure The Angels on board because everybody was placed in jail by Charles Townsend and they were looking to get even with him. (I have no idea how that could have played out.)
2.The way Gorshin, who played The Riddler on Batman, gets caught is, as previously mentioned, that he falls for the ruse that Kelly was killed. I realize his clairvoyance might not work all the time, but it must have worked enough for him to have committed the murders, and this sure was an inconvenient time for it to fail on him.
Or, did he not really have clairvoyance...Don't want to take this episode too seriously.
Tell Your Friends