2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
The Good Spirit Brings Peace
21 May 2014
A chilling inside look at the missionary efforts of the US evangelical right to instill their "bible based" homophobia into Uganda. I won't repeat the fine observations made by other reviewers, except to say this is a must see for all LGBT persons/ activists and their supporters. It's frightening, sobering and inspiring all at the same time. It's also remarkable for the amount of footage devoted to an inside look at the gatherings and meetings of the International House of Prayer. These frenetic prayer sessions, characterized by manic, crazed, jerky movements on the part of the participants, testify in a graphic manner to the lack of any real interior peace or integration on the part of the (perhaps) well meaning zealots. Here we have human beings in the grip of a fever of fanaticism, without the "peace that surpasses understanding" of the gospels. A fever of emotional certitude coming from the ego rather than from the depths of their interior being. Contrast this with the gentle peace and quiet confidence of the two gay- supportive pastors featured most prominently. These are both remarkable human beings who exude a compassion and wisdom that breathes peace throughout the entire documentary. These are persons centered deep within their interior beings where the Spirit lives and breathes, a peace that gives them such courage in the face of opposition. This is especially so for the saintly bishop, whose gentleness masks a steely will to stand up against injustice. He is even more remarkable for his quiet inner optimism and confidence in Uganda's future, despite the terrible situation in Uganda at

the moment. This is the quiet confidence of a man deeply attuned to his own inner being, listening to a higher voice not of his own making, which sustains and inspires him. This is not a man enslaved to his inner demons who drive him to peaks of frenetic emotionality. The bishop is a gentle quiet tenacious presence contrasted with the tin rattling clamor, noise and confusion of the zealots, insisting that they know that God wants this and God wants that. Remarkable, I wish the film had mover of him.

The simple contrast between the demeanor and peaceful body language of the supportive Christian pastors with the alarming intensity of the crazed zealots is one of the most powerful messages of the whole film. It's a simple rule of Christian discernment, the Good Spirit brings peace. (Apologies for the explicit Christian references, since the Spirit is certainly not limited to Christians alone, but In a documentary replete with so many young missionaries ignorant of the basic rules of Christian discernment, it seemed appropriate.)
8 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
mesmerizing
17 July 2012
A mesmerizing, haunting mystery thriller that requires a substantial 'suspension of disbelief' to truly appreciate it, because it leaves many loose ends and unanswered questions. But I was hooked right from the beginning all the way to its evocative, elusive, deeply mysterious denouement, which has left so many other viewers unsatisfied. The film is really a character study of the deterioration of a complex, sensitive man thrown into impossible situations, and Ethan Hawke turns in a performance of great subtly and visible anguish. As the New York Times reviewer said, "It doesn't have the kind of payoff that details who did what and why, which is a problem only if you demand tidy endings." Or as another reviewer at IMDb has recently posted, and I paraphrase, 'Do you want Mark Walberg and a trash talking teddy bear? Or do you want something that requires the viewer to engage both mind and soul?" The Woman in the Fifth is the latter, beautifully done.
15 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed