I just watched Scream 1, 2, 3, 4, and Scream 2022 this week. I wasn't sure where to start because I kept reading reddit reviews with people talking about their favourite scream movies, and which ones were bad, but eventually I noticed a trend with all these reviews: it's always people who had seen the scream movies 5 or 10 years ago and we're just operating on "nostalgia." But I, dear reader, have seen them all just this week, and they are super fresh in my mind. I can give you helpful information, where others can't (because they saw the movies 5 or 10 years ago and are just going by the "feeling" in their head that they can recall, but they will never tell you that.)
Scream 1: This is a perfect movie. There is absolutely no silliness, no absurd horror tropes, no super strength that makes no sense, no "I just bumped into someone that has been in front of me for 5 minutes" loud noises, none of that. Just horror satire, with a BIG emphasis on horror and a small emphasis on satire, relatively. This movie knows exactly what it's doing at all times. There is no wasted breath, no dragging scenes, everything serves a purpose. A perfect movie. And it holds up completely. I'm telling you, it was just as good when I saw it this week as it was when I saw it 15 years ago. There's no silly special fx that age, or cgi, or anything like that. It's all perfect, like it was made today.
Scream 2: This is where the scream movies first introduce silliness and horror tropes that annoy you and don't make sense. Super strong teleporting killers, loud noises from bumping onto someone that she should have seen or heard for the last 5 minutes, brushing off near fatal wounds like they are nothing, etc. All that gibberish that takes you out of the movie. It only gets worse from here though. However, this is still very much a scream movie, and it has some really effective scenes, like the opening scene. Scenes that are on par with the original. Unfortunately, this is far from a perfect movie.
Scream 3: This is as silly as the series gets. We have now maximized the silly horror tropes. Maximum teleporting super strong killers, maximum people brushing off near fatal wounds like they are nothing, maximum loud noises from trivial events, just maximum eye rolling moments. This movie is the bad joke of the series. Unlike Scream 4 however, this movie does advance the overall story a bit.
Scream 4 Takes itself more seriously then the last which I appreciated, but we are still at maximum teleporting killers, and maximum brushing off near fatal wounds like they are nothing, as well as maximum loud noises from trivial events.
Scream 2022: They did it. They recaptured the magic of the original, even moreso then Scream 2. This isn't a perfect movie either, with annoying horror tropes like teleporting killers, people brushing off near fatal wounds like they are nothing, and loud noises because of trivial events, but it's to such a significantly less degree then it was in scream 3 and 4. And other then those tropes, this is a fantastic movie. Not even close to as good as the first though, due to the horror tropes as well as spotty acting from a few of the new main characters. The original had none of these problems.
Scream 2022 was fun though, and I would re-watch it. It is the best sequel.
Now here's the bad news: you will definitely enjoy Scream 2022 more if you watch Scream 1 and 2 (worth it), 3 and 4 (awful) beforehand. But honestly, I want to burn all copies of screams 3 and 4. They brought the series down.
I will never again re-watch scream 3 and 4. They can go to the wayside for me, forever. If (more like when) I do a scream marathon, it will always and forever be Scream 1, then 2, then Scream 2022, and that's it. In that order.
2 out of 7 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends