I'm watching a movie about the Dixie Chicks. They sank from the hottest country band in the country when their singer, Natalie Pasdar, made a comment at a UK concert in the early 2000's about being "ashamed that the President of the United States is from Texas." Chaos ensued.
The singer keeps saying things that dramatize the situation. She's a drama queen at her height, revelling in the mean things people say about her. Committed to opposition of the naysayers. To be fair, there are a lot of people burning their CD's and making threats against them, calling them dumb bimbos, saying they should be strapped to bombs and dropped over Iraq. Ironic that their single at the time of the controversy was about a soldier returning home. It's weird how many opinions can turn in an instant. And this was before the Internet was big! The early 2000's.
One of the members stated the uproar needed to come from the heartland of America, a country music base for their supporters. Unfortunately, the radio stopped playing their music; silenced them. A boycott of their music, which disappeared from the popular ear. The band took up the tack of free speech to defend their lead singer's throwaway opinion. Though this movie I'm watching doesn't focus on that as much as the backlash against the band and their opinions and being hurt by the backlash.
The movie has few to no details about the war and its repercussions on free speech, anyway. At one point, Natalie says she just wants to be like Bob Dylan or Bruce Springsteen: choose not to make appearances on national TV. LOL what??? Bob Dylan was one of the most vocal anti-war musicians ever. The movie makes no allusions to the war protesters of the past: about MLK Jr., Pete Seeger, Joan Baez in the Vietnam era; and barely any arguments are made about the right to perceive your President in any way you want. There were a ton of haters against Bush (though the movie did clearly state the timeline of events as well as when Bush's approval rating downturned)! But who brought up the history of the south (much of their country music fan base) and the consequences of mass opinion there: slavery, segregation, sexism, the whole lot? I was sad to see the musicians shy away from holding their aggressors to account, and stewing in sadness and anger. Jeez, you'd think the big mouths who made the statement in the first place and then called on the First Amendment to cover their asses would at least make a show of defending the First Amendment. Everyone has a right to say what they will.
Instead, this movie is about three women's (mostly Natalie's) refusal to forgive people who manipulated their lives into chaos and fear. I get it's hard to be hated, and it takes a special type of person to thrive on negative publicity; but I don't request anything more than an acknowledgment of the right that everyone's taking advantage of to make their statements.
The Dixie Chicks took the risk to speak up, though, and kept making music; didn't apologize for their opinions. And that I respect. I do. It inspires me to do so too. But I wasn't really sure that their motives from the outset were really true...
The movie had footage from a meeting with the group's (British) manager when news came rolling in about their hate. The group members were basically all like, okay, let's apologize and rescind the statement; Natalie insisted the opinion was valid; and the manager egged them on to defend it and blow the scene up. Any publicity is good publicity, right? Reality TV before reality TV was ever a thing. Their, by their own admission, numbers never bounced back: CD's sold, tickets sold, sold-out concerts. But they are convinced they're in a better place musically and stronger as a group. Seems true, so. May be something people say to save face.
The movie has great music in it! I will definitely be adding some Dixie Chicks albums to my rotation. The soundtrack is on point, but the narrative could have defended free speech more. And the singer came off kind of like a spoiled brat.
1 out of 2 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends